3 deaths in 1 week: How risky is high school football?


A 16-year-old high school football player died Wednesday following an on-field collision.

Tom Cutinella was a junior at Shoreham-Wading River High School. He was pronounced dead after collapsing during the third quarter of a varsity football game.  But school officials say football is not to blame.

STEVEN COHEN, Shoreham-Wading Superintendent WNBC: "It was the result of a typical football play.  It was just a freak accident."

Cutinella's death is the third death of a high school football player due to football-related injuries in a week.  Demario Harris Jr. of Troy, Alabama, died Friday after being tackled. That same day, Isaiah Langston of Rolesville High School collapsed and died during pre-game warm-ups.

That certainly makes for an eye-catching headline. But let's look at the overall numbers behind school football deaths.

In a 2013 study, The American Journal of Sports Medicine found football-related fatalities in high school and college average 12.2 per year.  That is about one in every 100,000 participants. Fatalities are most commonly from indirect causes, such as heat illness and cardiac failure. College football players are also 2.8 times more likely to suffer fatal injury than high schoolers.

And the popularity of college football may be an issue here. The New York Times paraphrases Kate Carr, president and chief executive of Safe Kids Worldwide, as saying that "some of the intense culture of professional and collegiate football is trickling down to the high school level."

Some school districts have instituted stricter practice and equipment guidelines in response to evidence that deaths have increased since 1994.

According to a study in the International Journal of Biometeorology, deaths from heat-related injuries nearly tripled from 1994 to 2009. Researchers said some of the increase may be explained by higher temperatures during practice times and an increase in average BMI among football players, though those are only a couple of possible factors.

Students and teammates held a candlelight vigil for Cutinella on the school's football field Thursday.  Cutinella's grandfather told The New York Times that even though there are risks associated with football, he would never ask his grandsons to quit playing.

 



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in High School Sports

Size matters: The building boom continues for bigger, better athletic facilities
Size matters: The building boom continues for bigger, better athletic facilities

Jimbo Fisher inherited a palace of a football stadium when he accepted the job at Texas A&M. The Aggies are three years removed from finishing a $500 million renovation of Kyle Field, giving them the largest stadium in the Southeastern Conference and one of the biggest in the country. But in the big business of college football, building...
More strikeouts than hits? Welcome to baseball’s latest crisis
More strikeouts than hits? Welcome to baseball’s latest crisis

One thing you learn from studying baseball history is that people have always predicted the sport’s demise. Over and over, the game weathers every perceived crisis and continues to thrive. More than 70 million fans will attend major league games this season; another 40 million or so will go to minor league games. Countless more watch the sport...
Our preseason Top 10: No. 8 Cedar Ridge
Our preseason Top 10: No. 8 Cedar Ridge

PRESEASON TOP 10 COUNTDOWN: NO. 8 CEDAR RIDGE By Chris Bils, American-Statesman Correspondent In Central Texas, August means scorching days and heated preseason debates about the area’s top high school football teams. Leading up to the season’s kickoff Aug. 30, we unveil our Top 10, as selected by our high school reporting staff. No. 8...
Memphis opens series with win over Round Rock

Lane Thomas hit a run-scoring fielder’s choice in the second inning, leading the Memphis Redbirds to a 7-4 win over the Round Rock Express Friday in Memphis, Tenn. The fielder’s choice started the scoring in a four-run inning and gave the Redbirds a 4-3 lead. Later in the inning, Wilfredo Tovar hit an RBI double, driving in Adolis Garcia...
Texas State notebook: Bobcats agree to three-year series with Baylor
Texas State notebook: Bobcats agree to three-year series with Baylor

Texas State and Baylor have agreed to a home-and-home football series starting in 2021. The first matchup will be Sept. 4, 2021, in San Marcos, with the final two games of the series — Sept. 17, 2022, and Sept. 2, 2023 — to be played in Waco. The 2021 game will be the first time a Big 12 team has played at Bobcat Stadium since Texas Tech...
More Stories