In reversal, court upholds sexual assault conviction for Baylor player


Highlights

State’s highest criminal court upholds sexual assault conviction of Baylor football player Sam Ukwuachu.

Ruling reverses a lower-court opinion that tossed out the conviction and jail sentence.

The state’s highest criminal court on Wednesday upheld the sexual assault conviction of former Baylor football player Sam Ukwuachu, reversing the decision of a lower court that had ordered a new trial because jurors were not shown text messages between the accuser and a friend.

The Waco-based 10th Court of Appeals had tossed out the conviction in March 2017, ruling that the trial judge improperly excluded several texts that the accuser, a fellow student-athlete identified in court documents as “CW,” had sent to a friend on the night of the charged offense in October 2013.

Defense lawyers wanted jurors to read texts sent prior to a message in which CW said Ukwuachu “just raped me basically,” arguing that the earlier texts indicated that she had previously consented to sex with him. Jurors, however, were shown only texts sent after the incident.

On Wednesday, a unanimous Texas Court of Criminal Appeals decision said the trial judge properly excluded the prior text messages, reinstating the sentence of 180 days in jail and 10 years of probation given to Ukwuachu, a one-time All-American who had transferred from Boise State but did not play for Baylor before he was suspended in 2014.

Ukwuachu’s sexual assault case and the 2014 sexual assault conviction of another former player, Tevin Elliott, helped ignite a scandal at the Baptist school, prompting a string of lawsuits and eventually leading to the firing of football coach Art Briles and Ken Starr’s removal as president.

Wednesday’s ruling — an opinion joined by four judges and two concurring opinions joined by the court’s five other judges — returns Ukwuachu’s case to the Waco appeals court to consider other objections raised by the former player but not yet ruled upon.

First, however, the lawyer for Ukwuachu said he will ask the Court of Criminal Appeals judges to reconsider their decision, saying it was limited to a single point — whether the trial judge acted properly in excluding several text messages — when the lower court issued a much wider-ranging ruling.

“We’re disappointed in the manner they went about dealing with issues as presented to them by the (Waco) court of appeals, whose opinion was very much more expansive,” lawyer William Bratton III said.

In a concurring opinion, Judge Kevin Yeary said the texts prior to the alleged attack were properly withheld from jurors under the state’s “rape shield” law, which generally bars evidence of a victim’s past sexual behavior in sexual assault trials.

The withheld messages were ambiguous, particularly a text advising CW to “wrap it up this time,” which could have referred to CW’s past encounters with Ukwuachu but also could have referred to relations with another man or even had a nonsexual meaning, Yeary wrote.

In a separate concurring opinion, Judge David Newell said he believed that defense lawyers should have been allowed to admit the entire string of text messages.

Even so, Newell said, there was no harm done and therefore no need to toss out Ukwuachu’s conviction because the texts would have been of limited help to his defense, providing only “weak” support for his argument that sex with CW was consensual.

“The exhibit also carried the potential to reinforce the victim’s testimony that she had never had sex with (Ukwuachu) before and did not want to have sex with him on the day of the offense,” Newell wrote.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Fantasy Football 2018 preview: AFC South
Fantasy Football 2018 preview: AFC South

Knowledge is power and the greatest asset you can acquire in order to compete for a fantasy football championship. Here’s your 2018 preview of the AFC South, the third of eight division profiles leading to draft season. ——— 2018 Fantasy MVP: DeAndre Hopkins, WR Not many holes in Hopkins game. He’s a target monster (averaging...
Perez, Alberto lift Round Rock over Memphis

Carlos Perez doubled and singled three times as the Round Rock Express topped the Memphis Redbirds 4-2 Saturday in Memphis, Tenn. Perez finished 4 for 4 with a run scored while Hanser Alberto homered and singled for Round Rock. Reed Garrett allowed a run but got Carson Kelly to fly out with a runner on second to end the game for his third save of the...
A’s beat Astros to tie for AL West lead
A’s beat Astros to tie for AL West lead

Trevor Cahill pitched one-hit ball for seven shutout innings and the Oakland Athletics, far behind in the American League West standings earlier this summer, tied Houston for the division lead by beating the Astros 7-1 Saturday. Khris Davis, Matt Olson, Josh Phegley and Stephen Piscotty each hit two of Oakland’s team record-tying eight doubles...
Maryland regents take control of investigation

The University of Maryland Board of Regents has assumed authority over the investigation into the death of Jordan McNair, who collapsed during football practice and later died. The board also voted to take control of the commission formed to investigate the culture of the football program. The actions were announced Friday night after the board was...
Sun Belt Conference begins new era in 2018 with title game

The Sun Belt Conference is entering its final football season under the leadership of Commissioner Karl Benson, who took over at a time of major transition and uncertainty. Benson — who at 66 has decided to step down next summer — expects the action on the field this fall to show how far the Sun Belt has come since his arrival in 2012,...
More Stories