Texas sues ‘deceptive’ national opioid maker Purdue Pharma


Highlights

Texas sues drugmaker, saying it worsened the opioid crisis by lying about the risk of opioid addiction.

Nationally, 116 people are dying each day from opioid overdoses, federal agencies say.

Accusing a national drug manufacturer of helping to fuel the deadly opioid crisis, state Attorney General Ken Paxton announced Tuesday that Texas has filed suit against Purdue Pharma and is considering taking legal action against other drugmakers as well.

Filed in state District Court in Travis County, the lawsuit accused Purdue Pharma of violating state law by misrepresenting the risk of addiction associated with its opioids, particularly OxyContin, in a “sophisticated marketing scheme aimed at consumers and health care providers alike,” Paxton said.

“In the face of abundant evidence showing that the drug was dangerous, Purdue saw fit to exchange destroyed lives for financial gain,” Paxton said in an Austin news conference. “We must make those who caused the opioid crisis feel the pain that they have inflicted on our communities.”

As the national death toll from opioid addiction topped 350,000 since 1999, hundreds of lawsuits have been filed against drug manufacturers and distributors in federal courts across the nation — cases that have been consolidated under one judge in Cleveland.

RELATED: 5 things to know about opioids in Travis County

Paxton said his office filed suit in Travis County because a state law known as the Deceptive Trade Practices Act can provide powerful leverage — the ability to get an injunction barring Purdue from continued misrepresentation of its painkillers and penalties of up to $20,000 per violation.

“We felt like this case needed to be tried under Texas law and in Texas courts,” he said, adding that it is too early to know how many violations, and how much in penalties, his lawyers will seek under the lawsuit.

Democrats, however, said Paxton has been late responding to a national epidemic that killed people at a rate of 116 per day in 2016 — five times the rate of opioid-related overdoses in 1999, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Justin Nelson, a Democrat hoping to unseat Paxton in the November election, called the lawsuit window dressing to hide the Republican’s lack of attention to the health crisis.

“Lawsuits in other jurisdictions have been much stronger than this one, including the suit filed by Oklahoma nearly a year ago,” Nelson said. “This lawsuit is too little, too late for so many Texas families suffering from the opioid crisis.”

Paxton said the lawsuit was filed as soon as possible after his lawyers examined information collected via investigative subpoenas served last year on eight pharmaceutical companies by attorneys general in 41 states, including Texas. Additional action is likely, he said.

“Purdue is far from the only culprit, and my office continues to investigate other players,” Paxton said, adding that he “would not be surprised” if similar action is taken against other drugmakers in the future.

Purdue Pharma has denied similar accusations contained in other lawsuits, saying its products make up only 2 percent of all prescribed opioids and had been approved by the Food and Drug Administration.

RELATED: Travis County opioid drug overdoses on the rise, 2006 through 20016

“As a company grounded in science, we must balance patient access to FDA-approved medicines, while working collaboratively to solve this public health challenge,” the company, based in Stamford, Conn., said in a written statement in response to a lawsuit by Alabama in February.

According to the CDC, prescribed and illegal opioids including heroin, fentanyl and oxycodone are involved in two-thirds of all overdose deaths across the nation, and President Donald Trump declared the opioid crisis to be a public health emergency in October.

While many other states have been harder hit, particularly West Virginia and Ohio, opioid overdoses killed 1,375 Texans in 2016, while all overdose deaths rose 7.4 percent in Texas from the year before, according to the CDC and the National Institute on Drug Abuse.

In addition to Paxton’s legal action, a dozen other counties — including Travis County — have filed lawsuits in state courts accusing 18 opioid manufacturers and related distributors of making misleading statements about the risks posed by prescription opioids, leading to addiction, abuse and the use of illegal drugs such as heroin.

In April, the drug companies sought to move all of the lawsuits, including any filed in the future, to one Texas court, arguing that the move would save time and effort while avoiding conflicting pretrial rulings.

Action on all of the lawsuits has been halted while the request — which is not opposed by most of the counties — is being considered by the five-judge multidistrict litigation panel.

Patrick Sweeten, Paxton’s senior counsel for civil litigation, told the panel last week that his office will oppose lumping the state lawsuit in with the county lawsuits. If that is denied, Sweeten requested that all of the lawsuits be heard by a court in Travis County.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Accused dealer took ferry, brought children on drug buy, police say
Accused dealer took ferry, brought children on drug buy, police say

A New York man accused for his part in a heroin and fentanyl distribution ring commuted from the Bronx to Staten Island to sell the illicit drugs -- and took his children on a drug buy, police said. >> Read more trending news  Steven Ildefonso was one of six suspects arrested and indicted Thursday, the New York Daily News reported. ...
Tennessee man admits to whipping child, 6, to death with extension cord
Tennessee man admits to whipping child, 6, to death with extension cord

A Tennessee man was arrested for whipping his 6-year-old child to death with an extension cord, police said. >> Read more trending news  Memphis police said Donald Rich, the child’s stepfather, called 911 after the child “began to throw up and became unresponsive.” The incident happened Wednesday.  The...
Police arrest suspect in stabbing death of DC jogger
Police arrest suspect in stabbing death of DC jogger

Police in Washington, D.C., arrested a 23-year-old man and charged him in the fatal stabbing of a woman jogging through the city, the Washington Post reported. >> Read more trending news  Anthony Marquell Crawford was arrested and charged with first-degree murder in the death of Wendy Martinez, 35, who was attacked shortly before 8...
Jet Airways flight in India forced to return due to low cabin pressure
Jet Airways flight in India forced to return due to low cabin pressure

A Jet Airways flight from Mumbai to Jaipur in India was forced to turn back Thursday when 30 passengers complained of nose and ear bleeds because of low pressure in the cabin, CNN reported Thursday. >> Read more trending news  "The B737 aircraft, with 166 guests and 5 crew landed normally in Mumbai," Jet Airways ...
Sprint Car driver Greg Hodnett killed in crash during race
Sprint Car driver Greg Hodnett killed in crash during race

Sprint Car driver Greg Hodnett was killed in a crash Thursday night during an event at BAPS Motorspeedway in York Haven, Pennsylvania, the World of Outlaws said in a news release. He was 49. >> Read more trending news  Hodnett, from Spring Grove, Pennsylvania, was a five-time champion at Williams Grove Speedway in Pennsylvania and was...
More Stories