Texas abortion law adds risk for patients, doctors testify


Federal court trial begins with abortion doctors testifying about concerns over new Texas law.

Five days of testimony are scheduled to end Wednesday, with a judge’s decision to follow sometime later.

A Texas law banning second-trimester abortions on living fetuses requires doctors to use untested, complicated and riskier procedures that have no medical benefit to the woman, an Oregon doctor who teaches and performs abortions testified Thursday.

Kicking off a five-day federal court trial on a bid by abortion providers to overturn the law, Dr. Mark Nichols said the regulation would force Texas physicians to choose from several methods of inducing “fetal demise” that carry increased risks of infection and injury for what is otherwise the safest and most common form of second-trimester abortion — dilation and evacuation, or D&E.

Two methods of injecting toxins into the fetus require special skills and equipment and are not guaranteed to work, forcing doctors to consider a second injection — adding to the health risks for women — or face prosecution for violating the law, he said.

“I would be very nervous about being able to provide this service and not violate the law,” said Nichols, who teaches at the Oregon Health and Science University in Portland.

REPORT: Texas leads nation in abortion laws with no scientific basis

Darren McCarty with the Texas attorney general’s office challenged Nichols, noting that some Texas doctors prefer to induce fetal demise before a D&E abortion because they believe there are medical benefits, including making it easier to complete the procedure.

McCarty also scoffed at claims that the differences between the 17th and 18th week of pregnancy would be great enough to raise the risks faced by women.

But Nichols said the smaller size of the fetus, coupled with the larger amount of amniotic fluid, makes fetal demise procedures more difficult “the earlier you are in the pregnancy.”

In addition, Nichols and two other abortion providers testified, D&E abortions are usually performed beginning in the 15th week of pregnancy, but the injection procedures are not used before the 18th week, requiring doctors to use untested methods to meet the fetal demise requirement.

“I think it would be inappropriate, and it would be experimenting on my patients unnecessarily,” said Dr. Robin Wallace, medical director of the Southwestern Women’s Surgery Center in Dallas.

A third method of fetal demise, cutting the umbilical cord, can be difficult if not impossible for some women based on the placement of the placenta or scarring in the uterus, Wallace said. A doctor might have to grope around in search of the cord, significantly increasing the risk of infection or of perforating the uterus, she added.

The Texas law, approved by the Legislature in May as part of a sweeping set of abortion regulations in Senate Bill 8, was blocked from taking effect on Sept. 1, leading to the trial scheduled to end Wednesday before U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel.

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who attended the last two hours of Thursday’s trial in downtown Austin, said the proceedings were a historic step in the fight “for the dignity of the unborn.”

“Senate Bill 8 prohibits the live dismemberment of babies still in the womb,” Paxton said outside the federal courthouse. “In live dismemberment, the abortionist literally tears a fully formed child apart limb by limb. … By defending SB 8, Texas is protecting the dignity of everyone involved.”

Wallace will remain on the stand when the trial resumes Friday, with abortion providers expected to call several more doctors to testify before Paxton’s lawyers begin presenting their witnesses.

When the trial ends, Yeakel is expected to take the matter under advisement, issuing a written ruling later on whether the law improperly blocks access to abortion.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

JUST IN: Former MLB athlete Kelly Wayne Gruber arrested in Austin on DWI charge
JUST IN: Former MLB athlete Kelly Wayne Gruber arrested in Austin on DWI charge

Former Major League Baseball athlete Kelly Wayne Gruber was arrested in Austin on a DWI charge Saturday, records show. Gruber, 56, was a two-time All-Star while playing baseball for the Toronto Blue Jays from 1984 to 1992. As a teenager, Gruber played baseball for Westlake High School.  An Austin officer pulled Gruber over after noticing...
Police: Man attacked, cut person he thought was behind home invasion
Police: Man attacked, cut person he thought was behind home invasion

An Austin man is accused of cutting an apartment resident with a machete because he thought the victim was involved in a home invasion, according to an arrest affidavit released this week. Samuel Diaz-Parra, 58, was charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, a second-degree felony punishable by up to 20 years in jail. The attack happened...
Temple physician arrested for child porn, Texas Medical Board says

TEMPLE Texas Medical Board: Physician arrested for child porn The Texas Medical Board on Monday suspended the license of Temple physician John Middlemiss Palmer after he was arrested on child porn charges. “The Board panel found that on or about April 18, 2018, Dr. Palmer was charged with possession of child pornography by the Texas Attorney...
Jury weighs murder charge in Austin stabbing death of Daniel Spencer
Jury weighs murder charge in Austin stabbing death of Daniel Spencer

A Travis County jury began deliberating Monday evening in the murder trial of 67-year-old James Robert Miller Jr., who is accused of fatally stabbing 32-year-old Daniel Spencer in September 2015. Miller’s attorney says it was self-defense. Spencer was killed at his home early on the morning of Sept. 21, after inviting Miller to his house to play...
Onyeri says he didn’t mean to shoot Judge Kocurek, rails at banks
Onyeri says he didn’t mean to shoot Judge Kocurek, rails at banks

Chimene Onyeri took the witness stand Monday and continued to deny that he purposefully shot state District Judge Julie Kocurek while also railing at banking institutions and attempting to discredit several dozen witnesses who have testified against him. Onyeri spent much of the day sparring with federal prosecutors, refusing to identify his associates...
More Stories