Texas 130 builders concealed road’s flaws, new owners say in lawsuit


Highlights

Texas 130’s first owners knew early on that the road’s pavement and finances would fail, the suit says.

The lawsuit says the companies didn’t disclose the problems to lenders who had given them $1.22 billion.

The new owners allege that the builders fraudulently paid a subsidiary to build the road despite the problems.

The original owners of the Texas 130 tollway south of Mustang Ridge knew before the road opened that both its pavement and its finances were doomed, a lawsuit filed Thursday by the new owners alleges, yet concealed that information from investors and fraudulently paid almost $330 million to a company they created to build the road.

The 41-mile road’s current owners — made up primarily of those who lent Ferrovial S.A. of Spain and Zachry Industrial Inc. of San Antonio about $1.22 billion to design and build Texas 130 and then took over the bankrupt road in 2017 — are asking a federal bankruptcy court in Austin to award them all money paid for construction between February 2011 and December 2012.

Representatives of Cintra, a Ferrovial subsidiary, and Zachry say the accusations in the suit have no merit.

The current ownership group took over the road after SH 130 Concession Co., Ferrovial and Zachry’s operating subsidiary for the project, emerged from bankruptcy still owing much of what it had borrowed. That group, and thus the plaintiffs in the lawsuit, includes the U.S. Department of Transportation, which had lent the project almost $500 million. The current owners estimate that repairing cracks, heaving pavement and other flaws at multiple locations will cost $130 million. Some of that work has already been done.

Texas 130’s owners have started repair work on the bumpy road.

The 14 defendants, all of them affiliates of either Ferrovial or Zachry, or both, include Central Texas Highway Constructors, which was owned half and half by the two parent companies, the lawsuit says. That company, known as CTHC in the lawsuit, had a contract for about $924 million to build the four-lane tollway between Mustang Ridge and Seguin.

“From the outset of construction in 2009,” the lawsuit alleges, “CTHC performed abysmally under the (design and construction) contract. In both design and construction, it cut corners, failed to follow industry practice, failed to implement its own designs and, in the end, designed and constructed a (road) with significant defects from one end to the other.”

Beyond that, the plaintiffs allege, the consortium knew early on during construction that the pavement was likely to fail soon after opening, and that traffic and revenue estimates made in 2007 during the project’s gestation were wildly optimistic. The lenders, the suit says, were purposely not told about those fundamental problems in violation of lending agreements.

“I hope that nobody starts asking questions,” the lawsuit says one representative of Cintra, a Ferrovial subsidiary, wrote in 2011 to the then-chairman of SH 130 Concession Co., the lawsuit said.

Looking back at Texas 130’s 2012 opening.

Traffic on the road, meanwhile, was “hopelessly overstated” by the original study, the lawsuit says. Ferrovial and Zachry, in fact, had commissioned an updated analysis in 2011, the suit says, and SH 130’s then-chairman expressed “shock” at “poor income prospects” of that section of Texas 130. But the company did not share the updated, discouraging study with its investors, according to the lawsuit.

In 2013, the first full year of operations, the road had $18.4 million of toll revenue, the lawsuit says, just over a quarter of the $69.9 million predicted in the original traffic and revenue study.

The lawsuit’s claim for damages is limited to $330 million, officials said, because of a statute of limitations that allows them to reach back only to February 2011.

“Cintra believes the allegations against it and its affiliated companies have no merit and intends to defend itself vigorously,” said Patrick Rhode, the Austin-based vice president for corporate affairs for Cintra’s United States arm. “We stand by our more than 50-year history of successfully delivering transportation solutions around the world.”

Tara Snowden, director of public and government affairs for Zachry Construction Corp., said that “of course we deny the allegations, and to the best of our knowledge there was no impropriety by Zachry Construction or its employees.”

Ferrovial and Zachry built the road under a 50-year lease with the Texas Department of Transportation. The new owners are operating under the same lease, and pay TxDOT 4.65 percent of all toll revenue. The state agency, which owns the ground beneath the tollway, has no financial exposure on the project.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Central Health sets public hearing for Saturday on future of Sendero
Central Health sets public hearing for Saturday on future of Sendero

Central Health is continuing to weigh the future of its nonprofit insurance provider, Sendero Health Plans, and will hold a special meeting on Saturday, where members of the public will be allowed to speak. Travis County commissioners on Tuesday delayed voting on the health district’s proposed $258 million budget for fiscal ...
BREAKING: Austin man at center of 3D-printed gun debate faces sex assault charge
BREAKING: Austin man at center of 3D-printed gun debate faces sex assault charge

Cody Wilson, an Austin man whose fight over 3D-printed guns thrust him into the national spotlight, faces a charge of sexual assault, according to an arrest affidavit filed in Travis County district court on Wednesday. The affidavit said a counselor called Austin police on Aug. 22 to report that a girl under the age of 17 told her she had sex with...
She's the mayor, a great-grandma, and now a gator hunter
She's the mayor, a great-grandma, and now a gator hunter

When it comes to public safety, don’t mess with Nana. Especially when she is the mayor. >> Read more trending news  Judy B. Cochran, a gun-totin’ grandma who recently was elected mayor of Livingston, Texas, killed a 12-foot, 580-pound alligator Monday with one shot at her ranch along the Trinity River in nearby Goodrich, ...
Florida neighbors can't bear the sight of nude gardener
Florida neighbors can't bear the sight of nude gardener

Adam and Eve may have been naked in the Garden of Eden, but neighbors in a South Florida city are not happy about a nude gardener in their paradise. >> Read more trending news  Residents in a north Stuart neighborhood called the Martin County Sheriff’s Office to complain about a man who does yard work and walks around his property...
FORECAST: Sunshine, high of 92; rainy days ahead starting Thursday
FORECAST: Sunshine, high of 92; rainy days ahead starting Thursday

Wednesday forecast for Austin: This could be the last day we see sunshine in the metro area until early next week as a low pressure system from Mexico moves into Texas, bringing possibly heavy rainfall this weekend, the National Weather Service said. Temperatures could reach 94 degrees in Austin on Wednesday as the heat index value, or the &ldquo...
More Stories