Sutherland Springs suit alleges military negligence led to massacre


A woman who was shot four times during the Sutherland Springs church shooting last year is suing the U.S. government, alleging that it failed to prevent the deadliest mass shooting in modern Texas history.

Margarette Vidal and her children, Monica Shabbir, Robert Vidal, and Ramiro Vidal Jr., filed a lawsuit in federal court on Tuesday seeking damages from the government for physical pain and suffering, mental anguish, health care expenses, physical impairment and disfigurement, and loss of income, according to the suit.

INTERACTIVE: Mapping 51 years of mass shootings in America

Vidal previously filed a wrongful injury claim against the military in civil court in January.

Authorities say Devin Kelley shot and killed 26 people during Sunday services inside the First Baptist Church in Sutherland Springs, about 35 miles southeast of San Antonio, on Nov. 5. Vidal was one of 20 people injured.

The family alleges in its lawsuit that the U.S. government was negligent and could have kept Kelley from possessing guns if it had properly managed his military records.

Kelley was convicted of domestic violence in 2012 while in the U.S. Air Force, but officials failed to report the conviction to the FBI background check system, as they are required to do.

Had the Air Force reported the conviction, Kelley would not have been able to purchase a firearm.

The Air Force admitted its mistake after the shooting in November.

PHOTOS: Memorial service for shooting victims in Sutherland Springs on Nov. 6

The family’s attorney, Jamal Alsaffar, said the government had six months to respond to a notice of claim requesting it take responsibility for failing to report Kelley’s conviction, but didn’t.

“Despite acknowledging that it failed to protect this community and many others, the government did nothing the past six months to try to right the wrong. So the family had to file a federal lawsuit to ensure that the government is held accountable for its negligence and to make this and other communities safer,” Alsaffar said.

Similar lawsuits have been filed against government agencies since the shooting.

The Holcombe family, which lost nine of its members in the shooting, sued the U.S. government in June.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Man critically hurt after collision with truck near downtown Austin
Man critically hurt after collision with truck near downtown Austin

A man was critically injured after his vehicle was pinned underneath a semi-truck on Interstate 35 near downtown Austin early Sunday. Austin-Travis County EMS medics responded around 4 a.m. to the start of the southbound lower deck of I-35. Firefighters had to lift the semi-truck off the car to remove the person. The rescue took about 30 minutes. One...
Florida probation officer accused of sexual misconduct with woman he supervised
Florida probation officer accused of sexual misconduct with woman he supervised

A probation officer in Florida was arrested on a charge that he had sexual relations with a woman under his supervision, WFLA reported. >> Read more trending news Jeffrey Thomas Desimone, 40, of Tarpon Springs, was arrested Thursday on a felony charge of sexual misconduct, the Tampa Bay Times reported. He was booked into the Pinellas...
FORECAST: Sunny and hot with a high near 98
FORECAST: Sunny and hot with a high near 98

Today will be mostly sunny and hot with a high near 98 and a low around 76. Heat index values could reach as high as 103. Triple-digit temperatures are expected for Austin throughout the week, the National Weather Service said. High temperatures are expected to gradually warm each day this week, ranging from the upper 90s to around 105 degrees Monday...
3 killed when bus, 3 vehicles collide on New Mexico interstate
3 killed when bus, 3 vehicles collide on New Mexico interstate

Three people were killed and 22 were injured in a crash involving a passenger bus and three other vehicles early Sunday on a New Mexico interstate, the Sandoval County Sheriff’s Office said. >> Read more trending news  The crash, which involved the bus, a semi trailer, a passenger vehicle and a pickup truck, closed I-25 in both directions...
TxDOT to receive $1.1 billion boost from surging oil business, economy
TxDOT to receive $1.1 billion boost from surging oil business, economy

Texas highways will get a $1.1 billion boost over the next year from the state’s vibrant economy, officials say, with much of that additional funding flowing from the booming oil and gas industry. The added money for the Texas Department of Transportation — generated by taxes dedicated to the agency’s highway fund as a result of constitutional...
More Stories