Valdez holds her own debating White, but questions on readiness remain


Highlights

Lupe Valdez gave as good as she got in her first and only debate with gubernatorial rival Andrew White.

Editorials on Friday from the Fort Worth Star-Telegram and Austin Chronicle questioned her preparedness.

Valdez said that might be because she speaks the language of the people and not of newspapers.

Lupe Valdez and Andrew White held their one and only debate Friday night in the campaign to earn the Democratic nomination to challenge Gov. Greg Abbott in November.

Each of the candidates held their own, which was welcome news for supporters of Valdez, the front-runner whose sometimes shaky performances in answering questions on the campaign trail had raised doubts about whether she was well-versed and sure-footed enough to be the party’s standard-bearer in the fall or serve as governor if she prevailed.

“There were no knockouts in the debate,” University of Houston political scientist Brandon Rottinghaus said. “It’s a split decision, but White wins on points. He showed competency, honesty and likability, but it’s likely too little too late to convince many progressive Democrats to support him or expand the pool of moderates to show up and vote.”

PHOTOS: Lupe Valdez and Andrew White debate in Austin

“Expectations were very low for Sheriff Valdez, but she had a strong performance and shushed critics who claim she’s not well-versed on policy matters,” Rottinghaus said.

Valdez, the former Dallas County sheriff, led White, a Houston entrepreneur, 43 percent to 27 percent in the March 6 primary. The runoff is May 22, and early voting begins Monday.

“While Valdez’s debate performance was far from spectacular, it was sufficiently competent to not raise serious doubts among her supporters and provide White with a game-changing moment,” Rice University political scientist Mark Jones said.

Asked by reporters after the debate why he thought he was the better candidate to take on Abbott, White said, “Here’s the data: Received the endorsement from every major newspaper in the state. Raised 10 times as much money as Lupe has. You’re going to have to raise money. I’ve proven I can do that. I’ve got the fight. We all know who Greg Abbott wants to run against. On Twitter, in tweet after tweet after tweet, he wants to run against Lupe Valdez.”

Herman: Candidates spar over abortion and who can beat Abbott

The Abbott campaign has treated Valdez as the presumptive nominee, most clearly evidenced by its launch Thursday of a new website — lupevaldez.org — seeking to do to her what the Abbott campaign did to the party’s 2014 nominee, state Sen. Wendy Davis, defining her early on as “too liberal for Texas.”

Offering a question from the audience at the debate, which was held at St. James’ Episcopal Church in East Austin, the moderator, Dallas Morning News political reporter Gromer Jeffers, asked Valdez, “Why do you think you’ve lost the endorsement of every major newspaper in the state and how do you respond to their concerns that you won’t be able to stand up to the pressure Greg Abbott will put on you?”

Valdez cited her endorsements from, among others, the AFL-CIO, Planned Parenthood, the Castro brothers — U.S. Rep. Joaquín Castro, D-San Antonio, and his twin brother, Julián, the former San Antonio mayor who is contemplating a run for president — 22 Democratic state representatives and three Democratic state senators.

“It’s not important, it’s not as important, to be able to verbalize, it’s more important to be able to act,” Valdez said.

Jeffers pressed on, asking Valdez about “the criticism of some newspapers, and quite frankly some Democrats, that you are not as sharp on the issue as Andrew White.”

‘It’s not that I’m not as sharp, because I am just as sharp,” Valdez said. “The problem may be that I don’t talk newspaper language. I talk people language.”

After the debate, White suggested that voters watch the Facebook Live of an interview earlier in the week with Valdez by the Fort Worth Star-Telegram editorial board.

“It’s a 30-minute spectacle,” said White, who also appeared before the board.

After the interviews with White and Valdez, the Star-Telegram editorialized that, “In a head-to-head debate with Gov. Greg Abbott, White could hold his own. He’s in command of the issues and decisive about what he believes.”

But, they wrote, “Throughout the conversation Valdez seemed to search for answers and what she came up with was often simplistic.”

Also Friday, the Austin Chronicle, noting that it had “tepidly endorsed Lupe Valdez in the primary,” withdrew its endorsement — while not backing White — noting her “tenuous grasp of policy.”

The Chronicle wrote that it had “previously advised the candidate to brush up on her institutional knowledge. Unfortunately, those shortcomings have persisted in a way that has made it unwise to invest in her candidacy.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

How Big Tech’s war on Alex Jones left First Reading pockmarked with Orwellian dead zones
How Big Tech’s war on Alex Jones left First Reading pockmarked with Orwellian dead zones

  Good day Austin: I’ve been in Austin five-and-a-half years. For the last couple of years I’ve had an obsessive interest in Alex Jones. This is important work, I tell myself. But I know the way other people look at me. I read the snide comments. I have been formally recognized for my obsession. I was named a ...
TRAFFIC ALERT: South I-35 frontage road closed in New Braunfels after 18-wheeler fire, police say
TRAFFIC ALERT: South I-35 frontage road closed in New Braunfels after 18-wheeler fire, police say

The south Interstate 35 frontage road at Walnut Avenue in New Braunfels was shut down on Tuesday morning after a fire broke out inside an 18-wheeler trailer, New Braunfels police said. Crews are cleaning up debris from the burnt trailer and police said the road will remain closed all morning. “The entire block in that area will remain closed...
FORECAST: High temperatures in the upper 90s in Austin on Tuesday, heat index of 103
FORECAST: High temperatures in the upper 90s in Austin on Tuesday, heat index of 103

Tuesday forecast for Austin: Austin is expected to see partly sunny skies and high temperatures in the upper 90s on Tuesday, National Weather Service forecasters said. Temperatures are expected to peak around 96 degrees during the day, then stay above 77 degrees at night, forecasters said. The heat index, or the “feels like” temperature...
OVERNIGHT: Critically injured teen taken to hospital after shooting, medics say
OVERNIGHT: Critically injured teen taken to hospital after shooting, medics say

A teenage boy was taken to Dell Seton Medical Center late Monday with critical injuries from a gun shot wound, Austin-Travis County EMS officials said. Medics were called out to the intersection of Barnes Trail and St. Merryn Road in Northeast Austin, near Harris Branch Parkway and U.S. 290, around 11:24 p.m. Monday. The boy, who is in his mid to late...
2 children, 3 adults injured after crash on Anderson Mill Road 
2 children, 3 adults injured after crash on Anderson Mill Road 

Two children and three adults were injured Monday night after a two-car crash on Anderson Mill Road, Austin-Travis County EMS officials said.  The two-vehicle collision happened around 9:10 p.m. in the 10400 block of Anderson Mill Road, about a mile west of U.S. 183, EMS officials said.  Nine people total were involved in the crash,...
More Stories