The Texas Supreme Court is brewers’ last chance to get rid of 2013 beer law


Texas craft brewers are facing a new blow from the courts, capping off a disappointing legislative year — but they plan on fighting back.

A reversal of a judge’s decision that gave them monetary compensation for distribution rights was announced Friday, leading a group of the brewers involved in the initial case to declare their intent to appeal the decision to the Texas Supreme Court.

Last year, Austin-based Live Oak Brewing and Dallas/Fort Worth-area Peticolas Brewing and Revolver Brewing successfully sued the state to regain valuable capital they said they can get from selling their distribution rights, which they were able to do prior to a 2013 law.

The law was part of a landmark bundle of legislation that was otherwise a boon for breweries in the state. But Senate Bill 639 required them to give their distribution rights to distributors, rather than sell them, and the brewers sued. Last August, state District Judge Karin Crump declared the law to be unconstitutional. Her decision was consequently reversed Friday by the Texas Third Court of Appeals.

Brewers only have step left: to hope the Texas Supreme Court will disagree with the appellate court. 

“It is well established that the Texas Constitution protects economic liberties, and these rights do not cease to exist when the government begins licensing and regulating individuals and businesses,” Institute for Justice’s managing attorney Arif Panju, whose firm represented the brewers in court, said in a news release.

The institute’s senior attorney Paul Sherman added that the law only benefits distributors.

“Texas’s prohibition on selling distribution rights was written by distributors, for distributors, at the expense of brewers. That sort of naked wealth transfer is unconstitutional,” he said in the release.

The reversal is just the latest disappointment for Texas brewers this year. When the state legislature was in session this spring, the brewers hoped to get laws passed that would, among other things, allow production breweries to sell beer to-go from their taprooms, something the country’s 49 other states permit in some capacity.

Instead, brewers were faced with a bill they see as detrimental to the industry and pushed, as with SB 639, by the state’s beer distributors. House Bill 3287, passed in May, prohibits breweries of a certain size from running an on-site taproom. 

Though nearly all breweries in the state make well below the barrel limit dictated in the bill, most of them view it as limiting their growth and continuing distributors’ stranglehold on their products.

Another case still winding its way through Texas courts is a lawsuit that Dallas-Fort Worth’s Deep Ellum Brewing and others have lodged against the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission to allow them to sell beer from their taprooms for off-premise consumption. 

RELATED STORIES:


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Austin360

Driving through Austin: 22 things to do along Manor Road
Driving through Austin: 22 things to do along Manor Road

East Austin has always been a hotbed of culture, and Manor Road is no different. If you find yourself on our near the up-and-coming Austin street, here are 22 things to do, see, eat and drink in the area, starting closest to Interstate 35 and working east. El Chile Cafe y Cantina -- 1809 Manor Road This laid-back Mexican restaurant is...
There’s a new round of limited ‘Game of Thrones’ beers to last us to the final season
There’s a new round of limited ‘Game of Thrones’ beers to last us to the final season

It’s been the first year since 2011 that we haven’t had a new season of “Game of Thrones.” Though the final round of episodes won’t grace our TV screens until 2019, we’ve at least got the next best thing in the form of limited-edition themed beers. Brewery Ommegang has once again teamed up with HBO to make a...
Want to see sharkosaurus movie ‘The Meg’ on the water? Of course you do.
Want to see sharkosaurus movie ‘The Meg’ on the water? Of course you do.

Alamo Drafthouse’s Rolling Roadshow is presenting the man vs megalodon movie “The Meg on the shores of Lake Travis at Volente Beach Resort Aug. 5. (Sadly, this movie is not, as rumored, about an enormous Meg White who eats a regular sized Jack White.) “‘The Meg’ on the Water” attendees will float on inflatable...
Move over McConaughey: WWE Superstars The Miz and Maryse have moved to Austin 
Move over McConaughey: WWE Superstars The Miz and Maryse have moved to Austin 

There’s a new celebrity “It couple” in town.  WWE’s Mike “The Miz” Mizanin and Maryse, packed up their home in Los Angeles and moved across the country to Austin this spring. The couple will star in an upcoming reality TV series called “Miz and Mrs” featuring the birth of their infant daughter...
Luby’s says it’s looking to close more locations
Luby’s says it’s looking to close more locations

Luby’s, the Houston-based cafeteria chain, announced in a news release Monday that it plans to close more restaurants in an effort to reduce its debts. The chain, famous for its “LuAnn” platter and beloved by many Texans as an after-church lunch locale, said that it hopes to raise $20 million through the sale of some locations...
More Stories