Talks begin to implement a high school Mexican-American studies course


The Texas State Board of Education began talks Tuesday about implementing a Mexican-American studies course.

The board rejected creating such a course in 2014.

The board did not make a decision on Tuesday.

Four years after rejecting a statewide high school Mexican-American studies course, the State Board of Education on Tuesday reprised talks about implementing one in the next few years.

“It helps them identify with their roots,” said board member Ruben Cortez, D-Brownsville, recounting what he’s heard from Mexican-American studies students. “One of them said, ‘My grades have improved because I now know that I’m not the only one dealing with these sorts of things and I’ve learned about people that have had these similar challenges.’”

Board member Marty Rowley, R-Amarillo, said he was concerned that creating a Mexican-American studies course and excluding broader Latino studies would be ideological.

Board member Marisa Perez-Diaz, D-Converse, disagreed, saying that by Rowley’s logic, the state’s current social studies courses would be considered ideological because they teach “pro-European colonialism.”

Notoriously divided along political lines at the time, the state board in 2014 rejected implementing a Mexican-American studies course. Mexican-American studies was added to a list of courses the board wanted to eventually develop, but in the meantime, school districts could choose to develop and implement such a course on their own. The board offered school districts a list of recommended textbooks for such a course and other ethnic studies areas.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE: How the discussion over a Mexican-American studies course has evolved

Most school districts don’t offer Mexican-American studies courses, and the board has yet to adopt a Mexican-American studies textbook. Over the last two years, the board has considered and rejected two proposed textbooks — one book was considered racist by Mexican-American studies scholars and activists, and the other book was not considered comprehensive enough by the board.

The board’s discussion Tuesday focused on creating a set of curriculum standards — a blueprint of the specifics that would be taught in a statewide course. The course would lead to more school districts offering Mexican-American studies and more publishers creating a good Mexican-American studies textbook, proponents said.

“Having a course approved by the state board legitimates the work that teachers and educators across the state have already been doing,” said Christopher Carmona, a University of Texas Rio Grande Valley professor and committee chair with the National Association for Chicana and Chicano Studies.

Carmona said that about 450 Texas high school students took Mexican-American studies last school year.

Of the two dozen people who signed up to provide public testimony before the board on Tuesday, no one spoke against creating a Mexican-American studies course. Carmona said the easiest way the board could speed up implementation of the course is if members approved using the Houston school district’s Mexican-American studies course as a template for the statewide version.

Carmona and seven other Mexican-American studies scholars have offered to help the Texas Education Agency create the course. Monica Martinez, an associate commissioner with the agency, said they can’t start developing a Mexican-American studies course until the end of the year because of other courses that need to be developed, financial constraints and lack of “staff bandwidth.”

The board did not make a decision Tuesday on whether to greenlight a Mexican-American studies course.

Board members decided instead they will take a formal vote during their next meeting in April about whether the course should be focused on Mexican-American studies or Latin-American studies.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Highs in the upper 90s expected for Memorial Day weekend in Austin
Highs in the upper 90s expected for Memorial Day weekend in Austin

It will be a sunny and hot Memorial Day weekend in Austin, starting off Saturday with a high temperature of 99 degrees and a heat index of 104, according to the National Weather Service. Highs will stay in the upper 90s through the holiday on Monday, so stay safe and keep hydrated if you are spending time outdoors. At night, the temperature will fall...
Community news: CodeNext hearings scheduled for Tuesday, Saturday

TRAVIS COUNTY DOWNTOWN AUSTIN CodeNext hearings scheduled The city of Austin is considering a comprehensive revision to the Land Development Code, called CodeNext, and the City Council will host public hearings at 10 a.m. Tuesday and Saturday at City Hall, 301 W. Second St. The code affects what, where and how much can be built in Austin. It covers...
Where to honor those who gave their all
Where to honor those who gave their all

No matter where you are in Central Texas, there will be a place nearby to remember those who died while serving the country’s armed forces. The following are among the places to go this Memorial Day weekend: TRAVIS COUNTY West Austin: World War II close assault re-enactments at 11 a.m. and 2 p.m. Sunday at Camp Mabry, 2200 W. 35th St. East Austin...
PolitiFact: Death penalty is now only for those 18 and older
PolitiFact: Death penalty is now only for those 18 and older

A U.S. Supreme Court ruling keeps the 17-year-old who has admitted being the shooter at Santa Fe High School from facing the death penalty because he’s not 18. Still, a meme brought to our attention by readers suggests Dimitrios Pagourtzis, who is white, is getting some type of special treatment. It contrasts his case with that of an African-American...
Is new wastewater treatment plant to blame for algae in river?
Is new wastewater treatment plant to blame for algae in river?

The South San Gabriel River was so clear as it flowed past Frank and LaWann Tull’s house on Waterford Lane in Georgetown that they held baptisms for their church in April 2016 and April 2017. But this year they couldn’t. Around the beginning of April, t he river became blanketed with thick coats of algae that...
More Stories