State audit slams Alamo oversight, appears similar to ‘doctored’ draft


The General Land Office released an internal audit critical of its management of the Alamo.

The audit’s conclusions are consistent with a draft audit the Statesman reported on in February.

Land Commissioner George P. Bush had said that draft audit had been “doctored.”

The Texas General Land Office released an internal audit Thursday critical of accounting practices at the Alamo that is consistent with a draft report from September that the American-Statesman had obtained and written about in February but which Land Commissioner George P. Bush had described as “doctored.”

The document, which questions the use of a nonprofit to manage the Alamo, was characterized by the agency as a “proactive internal audit of the Alamo’s accounting and financial management — the first of its kind in Alamo history — undertaken by the Texas General Land Office to modernize and reinforce oversight and accountability.”

“Many of the recommendations have already been implemented while others are being fulfilled through the implementation of a new Alamo management contract with the Alamo Trust,” Bush said in the statement.

RELATED: George P. Bush plans to step down from nonprofit Alamo Trust board

The audit begins with the internal auditors’ “overall conclusions,” which are presented in language identical to the draft report quoted by the Statesman in February and which agency spokeswoman Brittany Eck said then had been “altered,” but would not say how.

At the time, Bush was being challenged in the Republican primary by his predecessor, Jerry Patterson, and two other candidates, who made his management of the state’s most hallowed site a central issue in the campaign. Eck said then that the audit would be made public in the spring. In the meantime, Bush’s campaign labeled the Statesman story “fake news,” and Bush won the March 6 primary, with 58 percent of the vote to 30 percent for Patterson and 12 percent for the two other candidates, Davey Edwards and Rick Range.

Bush faces Democrat Miguel Suazo in the fall. Suazo said Thursday the audit “clearly demonstrates that George P. Bush is in over his head and lacks the competence to manage our state’s most historic landmark.”

Audit concerns

The audit raises red flags about how the agency uses a nonprofit — now called the Alamo Trust — to manage Alamo operations using public money but without all the checks and public scrutiny that are supposed to follow those dollars.

The audit concludes that “the current situation obscures the control of the funds. It also has created a situation where GLO is responsible for state laws over the use of funds, but with limited control since the expenditures are prior to approval by the GLO.”

RELATED: In remembering the Alamo, George P. Bush is forced to defend himself

It recommends that the General Land Office “reconsider the current structure and funding model for operating the Alamo.”

Members of the state Senate Finance Committee took the same view at a Dec. 5 hearing, questioning Bush about what they considered the Alamo’s convoluted management structure. The senators were unaware of the draft internal audit report at the time, which concluded, in language that remains intact in the final audit, “This is an unusual situation that has created complexity and a lack of clarity regarding the nature and the use of the funds used for Alamo operations.”

“It is also the root cause of several of the observations in this report,” the audit says. “We determined that the financial formation and accounting of the Alamo Complex fund did not comply with state requirements. Also, not all contract requirements of the agreement to operate the Alamo are being met. In addition, controls over budgeting, expenditures, contracting, and reconciliations should be strengthened.”

Agency’s response

In seeking to dissuade the Statesman from reporting on the draft audit report in February, Eck asserted in an email, “This is a document that has been significantly altered and leaked before being presented to you as authentic.”

“The real question any journalist should be asking is who is criminally tampering with government documents in violation of Sec. 37.10 of the Texas Penal Code in an effort to politicize and detract from the root mission of preserving the Alamo,” Eck said.

In February, Bush said the alleged altering and leaking of the draft audit report was being investigated by state law enforcement officials. There has been no further word on that investigation, and Eck did not reply Thursday when asked about the status of the investigation.

Instead, on Thursday, the agency boasted about an audit that drew the same conclusions as the draft audit whose authenticity it had sought to impeach.

“The fact of the matter is that the GLO proactively initiated this audit — the first of its kind in Alamo history — to modernize and reinforce oversight and accountability,” Eck said in an email. “Our focus is, and will continue to be, making proactive operational changes that raise the standards for accountability and operations above and beyond any previously at the Alamo.”

RELATED: George P. Bush reaped $129,000 from contractors at the agency he leads

Patterson’s answer, which was also articulated by some members of the Senate Finance Committee, was that the agency should manage the Alamo using state employees.

“Let’s make them GLO employees,” state Sen. Lois Kolkhorst, R-Brenham, told Bush at the hearing. “I know you don’t want to see this big bump in employees because we’re small-government Republicans, but I think this one we could explain.”

The agency’s response to the audit recommendation that it reconsider how it operates the Alamo was that it was moving “toward an industry-standard nonprofit museum management model” that “will take some years, and is taking place in the context of a historic renovation at the Alamo and its surroundings in San Antonio.” Bush is overseeing a $450 million plan to redevelop and improve the historic site.

The response also cited some personnel changes, with the agency chief financial officer being named acting chief financial officer for the Alamo as of Jan. 5, the hiring by the agency of an Alamo finance director to replace the trust’s accounting director, and converting all the trust accountants into agency employees. It also noted the creation of new purchasing policies, to be implemented Sept. 1, and a new management agreement requiring the trust to comply with state purchasing guidelines.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Gay rights pioneer Dick Leitsch, who orchestrated 'Sip-In,' dead at 83
Gay rights pioneer Dick Leitsch, who orchestrated 'Sip-In,' dead at 83

Dick Leitsch, whose milestone “Sip-In” in 1966 ensured the right of gay patrons to be served in a licensed bar, died Friday, The New York Times reported. He was 83. >> Read more trending news  The cause of death was liver cancer, according to Paul Havern, a friend. That was confirmed by Leitsch’s niece, Cheryl Williams...
China restaurant burned by all-you-can-eat promotion 
China restaurant burned by all-you-can-eat promotion 

An all-you-can-eat promotion by a struggling restaurant in southwestern China backfired as customers ate so much food the establishment was forced to close because of excessive debt, CNN reported. >> Read more trending news The Jiamener Hotpot Restaurant in Chengdu, introduced an unlimited menu on June 1 after struggling since opening in...
Protesters gather in Pittsburgh for third straight night
Protesters gather in Pittsburgh for third straight night

People flooded the streets of Pittsburgh for the third straight night Friday, protesting the police shooting death of a teenager during a traffic stop earlier in the week. >> Read more trending news  Residents were angry over Tuesday’s death of Antwon Rose, 17, who was unarmed.  The Homestead Grays Bridge was closed for approximately...
Grass poisoning could be cause for 'drunk' kangaroos, veterinarians say
Grass poisoning could be cause for 'drunk' kangaroos, veterinarians say

Veterinarians in Australia are conducting tests to determine whether kangaroos that appear to be drunk have actually suffered neurological damage because of a strain of grass, The Guardian reported. >> Read more trending news The veterinarians, from the University of Melbourne, said Phalaris aquatica -- a common pasture crop in central Victoria...
A 1-in-30 million shot: Rare yellow lobster caught off Maine coast
A 1-in-30 million shot: Rare yellow lobster caught off Maine coast

Maine is famous for its lobsters, but yellow lobsters are a rare find. >> Read more trending news One of those rare crustaceans was caught off the Maine Coast, the Maine Coast Fishermen's Association reported Wednesday. The F/V Short Fuse, of Bremen, caught the lobster this week, WGME reported. The odds of catching a yellow lobster...
More Stories