Little support in House committee for private school scholarships


More than 50 people signed up to testify on House Bill 253 on Tuesday.

The bill would, among other things, create a private school tax credit scholarship for schoolchildren.

Chairman of the House panel said the chamber has proposed other programs to help students with special needs.

Several members of a House panel on Tuesday showed little support for a bill that would help supplement private school tuition for schoolchildren.

Gov. Greg Abbott has made such a bill a special legislative session agenda item and the Senate passed a version last week.

Public school advocates, however, have called the scholarships a voucher scheme by lawmakers who critics say should be focusing on building up public schools instead of taking students and funding out of them. Proponents of the scholarships say they give a small number of students who aren’t getting the necessary services in their public schools the opportunity to find a better fit for them.

Under House Bill 253 by Rep. Ron Simmons, R-Carrollton, public school students who have disabilities can qualify for up to $10,000 in tax credit scholarships to attend a private school. Students with disabilities who want to stay in public school would get some money, too — up to $500 in 2019 and increasing 5 percent every year after that.

The tax credit scholarships and education assistance program would be funded by donations from insurance companies, who in return would receive a tax credit from the state, capped at $75 million each fiscal year.

“There will be some students that fall through the crack just because (a public school) just doesn’t fit their particular need and I’m just trying to provide some hope for those children,” said Simmons, who added only a small number of students will use the scholarship.

READ: Texas House looks to rainy day fund for teacher retirement funding

Chairman of the House Public Education Committee Dan Huberty, R-Houston, said he wasn’t convinced that the scholarship was the best solution to helping special education students. Through the hourslong hearing on Tuesday, he repeatedly mentioned other efforts from the House, including a bill he has resurrected from the regular legislative session that would give school districts grants to shore up services for students with autism.

“We’ve offered meaningful solutions that were … dismissed when they went over to the Senate,” Huberty said. “If they don’t want to have a policy discussion, then there’s no point in us continuing down that road.”

Fellow committee members Diego Bernal, D-San Antonio; Harold Dutton, D-Houston; and Joe Deshotel, D-Beaumont, also raised concerns about the bill. Another member Gary VanDeaver, R-New Boston, introduced in the hearing Tuesday a bill that would help certain special education students in public schools by creating a $10 million per year program to help them received services such as tutoring and educational therapy.

READ: House panel changes $1.9 billion school funding proposal

More than 50 people signed up to speak on HB 253 Tuesday. Many of them were in favor of the bill, including private school officials and parents with children with special needs for whom public schools had failed.

“I have nine years … to get him ready to be an adult,” said Katy resident Agatha Thibodeaux, whose son has autism. “I don’t have time for the school district to figure it out through lengthy processes.”

Among those who spoke against it were public school supporters who warned that parents who choose private school give up federal education laws that protect children with disabilities and that even with the scholarship, tuition would still be unaffordable for many families.

“This movement is nothing more a gift card for a select few,” said Kyle Ward with Texas PTA.

Other provisions in the bill includes $120 million over the next two years to help public charter schools and school districts to build facilities and a $150 million hardship grant program that would help school districts that are slated to lose so-called ASATR funding in September.

The committee did not vote on HB 253 on Tuesday.

HB 253 is similar to Senate Bill 2, which the Senate passed last week.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Cruz opens up 9 point lead over O’Rourke, poll finds
Cruz opens up 9 point lead over O’Rourke, poll finds

U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, has a 9-percentage point lead over challenger U.S. Rep. Beto O’Rourke, D-El Paso, according to a poll of likely voters released Tuesday. A Quinnipiac University Poll in August of registered voters — not likely voters — had Cruz, seeking a second term, holding an apparent 6-point lead. In May, another Quinnipiac...
Police say man stole $22 in food from Whole Foods, head-butted guard
Police say man stole $22 in food from Whole Foods, head-butted guard

A man is accused of stealing $22.78 worth of food last week from Whole Foods near downtown Austin and head-butting a security guard when he was confronted outside the store, court documents said. In arrest affidavits filed against Evan Joseph Nesby, Austin police said the 33-year-old walked out of the store on 5th Street and Lamar Boulevard with ...
These are the four state capitals better to live in than Austin, list says
These are the four state capitals better to live in than Austin, list says

How can Austin be both simultaneously the “best place to live in America” and only the fifth-best state capital to call home in the country?  Ask financial services company Smart Asset, which recently compiled a list of the “Best State Capitals to Live In” in 2018. In compiling the list, the site looked at...
Community news: Meetings set on mobility bond projects

TRAVIS COUNTY AUSTIN Mobility bond open house set The Austin Transportation Department will host public open houses this month as part of the 2016 mobility bond for substandard streets. Open houses will be from 6 to 8 p.m. Wednesday at Abiding Love Lutheran Church, 7210 Brush Country Road; 4:30 to 6:30 p.m. Sept. 26 at Cowan Elementary School, 2817...
Central Health to reconsider budget, hold hearing on Sendero closure
Central Health to reconsider budget, hold hearing on Sendero closure

2 p.m. update: Travis County commissioners on Tuesday agreed to postpone a vote on the county health district’s budget to give the agency time to schedule a public hearing on whether it should close its nonprofit health insurance provider, Sendero Health Plans. Commissioner Jeff Travillion said the extra time will give commissioners...
More Stories