Ken Paxton appeal rejected, making criminal trial likely


The state’s highest criminal court on Wednesday rejected Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s request to dismiss securities fraud charges against him, setting the stage for a trial that could begin as early as spring.

The Court of Criminal Appeals’ decision to refuse Paxton’s case, delivered without comment, was a severe setback to Paxton’s pretrial attempts to toss out three felony charges linked to private business deals from 2011 and 2012, when he was a member of the Legislature.

Defense lawyers, arguing that the charges against Paxton lacked merit, said they will ask the court to reconsider its decision.

“We anticipate filing a motion for rehearing because we have tremendous confidence in our case,” Paxton lawyers Philip Hilder and Bill Mateja said in a written statement.

The appeals court, however, rarely grants requests to rehear a rejected appeal, and prosecutors said Wednesday that they were preparing for an as yet unscheduled trial in Collin County.

“Today’s ruling marks an end to Mr. Paxton’s almost yearlong attempt to avoid being judged by a jury of his peers,” prosecutor Brian Wice said. “We look forward to going to trial and seeking justice on behalf of the people of Texas.”

SPECIAL REPORT: Is Ken Paxton’s legal trouble motivated by politics?

A Collin County grand jury last year indicted Paxton on two securities fraud charges accusing him of touting Servergy Inc. without revealing to potential investors that the McKinney tech company was paying him to push its stock. The first-degree felonies carry a penalty of up to 99 years in prison, though probation is common for many first-time, white-collar convictions.

A third charge accused Paxton of failing to register with state securities regulators, a third-degree felony.

A conviction for any felony would require Paxton to step down as attorney general, the top lawyer for state government.

RELATED: Ken Paxton campaign takes in almost $945,000, signaling an aggressive re-election effort

The legal setback came five days after Paxton prevailed in civil court when a federal judge dismissed a lawsuit by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission that accused Paxton of fraud in his dealings with Servergy investors.

U.S. District Judge Amos Mazzant III said the SEC’s allegations weren’t recognized under federal securities law, which he said didn’t require Paxton to disclose his deal with Servergy. The decision had no effect on the criminal charges against Paxton.

Mazzant gave the agency until Oct. 21 to amend its lawsuit if it can find “additional facts” to support its accusations. The SEC — which was seeking fines and an order for Paxton to repay “ill-gotten gains” from the Servergy deals — also could appeal Mazzant’s decision.

According to the SEC’s lawsuit, Paxton secured $840,000 in Servergy investments from five people, including state Rep. Byron Cook, R-Corsicana, and received 100,000 shares of private Servergy stock, worth $1 each, in compensation for his recruiting efforts.

NEWS STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX: Click here to get our Morning Headlines email

In the criminal case, Paxton’s lawyers told the Court of Criminal Appeals that he shouldn’t have to stand trial on the charges because he was indicted in 2015 by a Collin County grand jury that was improperly formed by a state district judge.

In addition, defense lawyers argued that Paxton couldn’t be charged with failing to register with state regulators because the law is unconstitutionally vague and because he was representing a company that had registered with the SEC, superseding his need to register with the state.

Paxton’s trial judge and the Dallas-based 5th Court of Appeals rejected versions of those arguments during previous attempts to dismiss the indictments.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Austin pastors among Methodist leaders filing complaint against Attorney General Jeff Sessions
Austin pastors among Methodist leaders filing complaint against Attorney General Jeff Sessions

Hundreds of leaders within the United Methodist Church, including some Austin pastors, filed a formal complaint Monday against Attorney General Jeff Sessions, requesting that church authorities “dig deeply into Mr. Sessions’ advocacy and actions that have led to harm against thousands of vulnerable humans.” Sessions is Methodist...
Class action suit calls out Travis County officials over sex assault investigations
Class action suit calls out Travis County officials over sex assault investigations

A federal class action lawsuit filed Monday slams current and former Travis County and Austin officials, including district attorneys and police chiefs, arguing that they don’t adequately investigate or seek to prosecute suspects in women’s sexual assault cases. The suit names as defendants the city of Austin, Travis County and five individuals...
Cómo ayudar a las familias separadas en la frontera
Cómo ayudar a las familias separadas en la frontera

Varias organizaciones en Texas están buscando firmas, donaciones y voluntarios después de que casi 2 mil menores inmigrantes han sido separados de sus padres en la frontera entre Texas y México como parte de una nueva iniciativa del Departamento de Justicia de Estados Unidos. El 6 de abril, el procurador general Jeff Sessions anunció...
Austin ISD board approves $1.4 billion budget, with employee raises
Austin ISD board approves $1.4 billion budget, with employee raises

The Austin school board Monday night adopted a $1.4 billion budget, which requires dipping into its fund balance by nearly $30 million to cover the district’s shortfall. It is the second consecutive year the district will need to pull from its reserves to cover expenses. The board voted 7 to 1, with Trustee Ted Gordon voting against. Gordon said...
Austin ISD board adopts plan that leaves some schools without nurses
Austin ISD board adopts plan that leaves some schools without nurses

The Austin school board Monday night approved a $7.1 million student health services plan that will continue to leave some campuses without a school nurse and others with a part-time nurse on site. Seton Healthcare Family, which has provided the district’s student medical services for nearly 25 years, will provide 75 nurses and 48 clinical assistants...
More Stories