How a Texas foster care bill discussion veered into vaccination debate


Highlights

House Bill 39 would require children entering foster care to undergo a medical examination within three days.

The bill would require a study of how many cases caseworkers should have.

House members approved an amendment that would prevent vaccination of foster children.

The Texas House tentatively passed a bill Wednesday that would address major problems in the state’s troubled child welfare system, including overburdened caseworkers and timely health screenings of foster children.

Before the vote, however, discussion on House Bill 39 filed by Rep. Gene Wu, D-Houston, detoured into a passionate debate about whether the state should allow foster care children to be vaccinated before a judge terminates the rights of the child’s parents.

Rep. Bill Zedler, R-Arlington, who tacked on an amendment to keep such children from being vaccinated, said in some cases a doctor wouldn’t know if a child is allergic to a vaccine. He and others also said it’s a matter of personal liberty.

“Listen, I’m not against vaccinations,” said Zedler. “I am against … the vaccine schedule. We’re treated like automobiles, like you get your oil change every 3,000 miles, well we’re going to give you this vaccine at birth … and so on down the line.”

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

Rep. Sarah Davis, R-West University Place, unsuccessfully tried to change Zedler’s measure to require foster care children be given the human papillomavirus vaccination, which can prevent certain types of cancers.

“I don’t know how many times I have to say this, I don’t know how many people I have to say it to but we can eradicate cancer with a vaccine,” said Davis, a breast cancer survivor. “I’m equally dumbfounded how this body can vote against wanting to eradicate cancer in the foster care system.”

It was the second time this week that a vaccine measure was attached to a foster care bill that has passed the House. House members on Monday approved an amendment on HB 7 that would prohibit the state from removing children from their parents if they choose not to vaccinate their children.

HB 39, passed 120 to 15, would require that children who enter the foster care system undergo as soon as possible an assessment for intellectual or developmental disability and within three business days, undergo a medical examination and mental health screening, if the child lives in an urban area.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

The bill also would require the state child welfare agency to create a caseload management system that among other things would determine the appropriate number of cases a caseworker should have. It would require the agency to help current and former foster children to obtain workforce training, certificates or degrees and work with foster and adoptive families to recruit more foster care parents.

Several provisions in the child welfare bills filed this legislative session, including the ones considered on Wednesday, were part of the recommendations made by two court-appointed special masters in November. U.S. District Judge Janis Jack ordered the recommendations but hasn’t decided whether the state should have to implement them after she ruled in 2015 that a large part of the state’s foster care system was unconstitutional and dangerous to children.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Prince Charles will succeed Queen Elizabeth as head of the Commonwealth
Prince Charles will succeed Queen Elizabeth as head of the Commonwealth

It’s official: Prince Charles will succeed Queen Elizabeth as head of the Commonwealth, the BBC reported. The Queen had said it was her “sincere wish” that the Prince of Wales succeed her when she dies. Leaders of the Commonwealth discussed the issue before making their decision, the BBC reported. Unlike the British crown, the...
'Sorry,' says man, 19, who opened fire at Florida high school
'Sorry,' says man, 19, who opened fire at Florida high school

The 19-year-old gunman who caused panic and fear at a Florida high school when he opened fire Friday morning said he was “sorry.” The gunman, identified as Sky Bouche, brought a shotgun onto campus at Forest High School in Ocala and shot a 17-year-old student in the ankle, deputies said.  The shooting happened on the day planned for...
2 Louisiana elementary school students arrested over nude Snapchat photos
2 Louisiana elementary school students arrested over nude Snapchat photos

Police in Louisiana arrested a female elementary school student who took nude pictures of herself, as well as her male classmate who shared the photographs through a social media app, WGNO reported. The students, who are enrolled at Bonne Ecole Elementary in Slidell, were charged with distribution of child pornography, the Slidell Police Department...
Florida commissioner allegedly fed, housed couple in exchange for sex twice a week
Florida commissioner allegedly fed, housed couple in exchange for sex twice a week

A Florida county commissioner was arrested Thursday on multiple prostitution-related charges after authorities said he housed and fed a couple in exchange for having sex with the man’s wife twice a week, The Tampa Bay Times reported. Hernando County Commissioner Nick Nicholson, 71, was arrested Thursday by the Hernando County Sheriff&rsquo...
New Jersey state trooper indicted for pulling women over to ask for dates
New Jersey state trooper indicted for pulling women over to ask for dates

A New Jersey state trooper was indicted Thursday on charges he allegedly pulled over women on traffic stops to ask them out on dates, The Trentonian reported. Eric Richardson, 32, of Camden, faces charges including official misconduct, criminal coercion and tampering with records, the state attorney’s office announced. According to the six-count...
More Stories