FDA again blocks Texas execution drug


The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has once again blocked Texas prison officials from importing a drug intended for executions, setting back state efforts to ensure an adequate supply of lethal injection drugs.

Problems began for Texas last fall, when the FDA seized overseas shipments of sodium thiopental even though Texas and Arizona had acquired import licenses from the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration.

At the time, FDA spokesman Jeff Ventura said the agency was relying on court opinions that determined that “sodium thiopental for the injection in humans is an unapproved drug and may not be imported into the country.”

Texas officials appealed the seizure through an internal FDA process but recently learned, via letter, that the federal agency had rejected those efforts.

Jason Clark, spokesman for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, said the FDA’s decision was preliminary, adding that the prison agency was “exploring its options moving forward regarding the lawful importation of drugs used in the lethal injection process.”

An FDA spokesman declined to comment on the letter Tuesday, saying, “This remains an ongoing proceeding.”

The availability of execution drugs has tightened as manufacturers in the United States and overseas, fearing negative publicity, have stopped making or selling drugs commonly used for lethal injection. The only U.S. maker of sodium thiopental, for example, stopped selling the drug in 2011, saying it did not want the drug used in executions.

Later that year, Texas stopped using sodium thiopental, a fast-acting anesthetic, as part of a three-drug protocol for executions.

In 2012, prison officials switched to a single dose of pentobarbital, which suppresses brain function and stops breathing — a method Texas continues to use.

In addition to seeking alternate sources of execution drugs, Texas officials have taken steps to reassure potential suppliers by acting to keep their identities secret.

Much of that effort stemmed from events in October 2013, when the pharmacist in charge of The Woodlands Compounding Pharmacy near Houston demanded that Texas return 16 vials of pentobarbital, citing a “firestorm” that erupted after the pharmacy’s identity was revealed under open records laws.

Prison officials refused the pharmacy’s request, then increased efforts to keep subsequent drug suppliers secret.

In April 2014, a federal judge in Houston blocked the executions of two death row inmates, ruling that defense lawyers could not properly challenge the planned use of a new batch of pentobarbital without knowing the source of the drug and what tests had been performed to assure its effectiveness.

Within hours, however, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overruled the judge, saying defense lawyers needed more than speculation that the new drugs could be inferior or cause risk of severe pain in inmates.

Both inmates were executed as scheduled.

One month later, then-Attorney General Greg Abbott said prison officials must keep the identity of execution drug suppliers secret, reversing previous rulings from his office that said the information must be disclosed under the Texas Public Information Act.

Revealing the drug supplier’s name would place the manufacturer or pharmacist at substantial risk of “physical harm,” Abbott’s office said in a letter to prison officials.

After his election as governor, Abbott in 2015 signed into law a bill that bars state agencies from disclosing the identity of any company or person who manufactures, tests, procures or provides an execution drug.

That was not the end of the controversy, however.

On May 5, the Austin-based 3rd Court of Appeals will hear oral arguments on a public information request that was filed before the nondisclosure law took effect Sept, 1, 2015.

Prison officials appealed an order from state District Judge Darlene Byrne, who told them to identify the state’s pentobarbital supplier to three lawyers who represent death row inmates.

Lawyers for Attorney General Ken Paxton argue that Byrne’s order, if allowed to stand, would undermine a Texas Supreme Court ruling that allowed typically public information to be kept secret if disclosure would be a safety risk.

The lawyers — Maurie Levin, Naomi Terr and Hilary Sheard — argue that Texas has presented only vague concerns about retaliation against drug suppliers, falling far short of proving a substantial threat of physical harm as required by the Supreme Court.

Additional material from staff writer Jonathan Tilove.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Crowd tried to save driver in fatal fiery crash, witness says
Crowd tried to save driver in fatal fiery crash, witness says

When a car slammed into a utility pole and burst into flames Tuesday morning, Scott Dietert could see from his western Travis County apartment as smoke filled the vehicle. It was so thick the he couldn’t see through the windows, he said. Dietert said several people crowded around the car, frantically trying to see if someone was inside. &ldquo...
Who pays when electric rental scooters cause damage? Maybe you
Who pays when electric rental scooters cause damage? Maybe you

An Austin man is suing an electric scooter rental company after he says his car was damaged in a hit-and run. Michael Fuchs has filed a petition in small claims court for $3,000 damages after he said his vehicle was side-swiped by one of the devices. About 7:45 p.m. on July 30, Fuchs said he was in his Mazda 3 stopped at the light at the South First...
REWARD FOR INFO: Men steal guns, jewelry from Austin pawn shop, feds say
REWARD FOR INFO: Men steal guns, jewelry from Austin pawn shop, feds say

Two men on Monday robbed a South Austin pawn shop, threatening an employee with a sledgehammer and breaking display cases, according to officials with the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. The men stole five pistols and over $6,000 in jewelry, officials said.   The feds are offering a reward of up to $4,000 for information...
27-year-old shot dead in San Marcos’ first killing of 2018, police say
27-year-old shot dead in San Marcos’ first killing of 2018, police say

San Marcos police are investigating the city’s first homicide of the year after a 27-year-old man was found dead at an apartment complex early Tuesday, officials said. Medics and police responded about 2 a.m. to the Park North Condos apartment complex in the 1600 block of Aquarena Springs Drive, just off Interstate 35 near Texas State University...
Hispanic civil rights group ‘suspends’ affiliation with Southwest Key
Hispanic civil rights group ‘suspends’ affiliation with Southwest Key

Hispanic civil rights group UnidosUS this week suspended its affiliation with Austin-based Southwest Key Programs, as some of its workers face allegations they abused migrant children in facilities the organization runs. One former worker at a Mesa, Ariz., facility is accused of performing sex acts on two boys and molesting six others between August...
More Stories