Catholic bishops sever ties to Texas Right to Life, exposing rift


Bishops direct Catholic churches and schools to refrain from working with Texas Right to Life.

Group conducts misleading attacks on politicians, misrepresents Catholic positions, bishops’ directive says.

Exposing a deep and widening rift in the state’s energetic anti-abortion movement, the Catholic bishops of Texas have directed churches across the state to refrain from working with Texas Right to Life, which bills itself as the “oldest and largest statewide pro-life organization.”

According to a written directive, Texas Right to Life has engaged in misleading attacks against political candidates, lied about the Catholic Church’s position on legislation at the state Capitol and opposed church-supported bills by arguing that they don’t go far enough to limit abortions.

“We’ve asked our pastors, parishes and Catholic schools to refrain from asking (Texas Right to Life representatives) to come onto our premises because their teachings don’t always align with what the Catholic Church teaches regarding certain life issues,” said Bishop Joe Vásquez, head of the 25-county Diocese of Austin.

The one-page written advisory from the Texas Catholic Conference of Bishops, which sets policy for the parishes serving the state’s 8.3 million Catholics, was released Thursday and distributed across the Austin Diocese on Friday.

The directive laid bare a long-simmering clash over tactics and priorities that has increasingly divided groups that have a similar goal — an end to legal abortion.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

On one side are Texas Right to Life and its close associate, Empower Texans. Fueled by social and religious conservatives, the groups have adopted a take-no-prisoners approach at the Capitol, particularly when it comes to attacking organizations and politicians that oppose or decline to fully support their priorities. Both groups have targeted House Speaker Joe Straus, R-San Antonio, who is retiring, and other centrist Republicans, saying they have blocked abortion limits and other favored legislation for too long.

On the other side are groups that Right to Life and Empower Texans have denigrated as “fake pro-life organizations” — including the Catholic Conference of Bishops, Texas Alliance for Life and the Texans for Life Coalition.

Kyleen Wright, president of the Texans for Life Coalition, said the bishops’ decision to call out Right to Life for its bullying tactics was a watershed moment for the movement.

“This is really big,” Wright said. “It’s very, very unfortunate that it came to this. But for our organization, and me personally, to be maligned and slandered for several years, and for our candidates and people who work in good faith to advance good policy down in Austin to be unfairly and maliciously attacked, that hasn’t been good for our movement, either.

“It’s very difficult, this type of family war,” she said.

Leaders for Texas Right to Life did not return several phone calls seeking comment.

But state Rep. Briscoe Cain, a Deer Park Republican and Texas Right to Life supporter, said the bishops were “literally going after a group for being too pro-life.”

Voter guide at issue

In their directive, the bishops took issue with Right to Life’s voter guide and scorecard, saying the compilations were “not based on a fair analysis of a legislator’s work” but rather on each politician’s willingness to bend to the organization’s wishes — leading the group to oppose incumbents “who have consistently voted for pro-life legislation.”

Cain said the bishops were seeking to provide cover for Republican politicians who try to hide their lack of support, if not outright opposition, for strong limits on abortion.

“It is undeniably true that there are multiple members in the House Republican Caucus who have voted in favor of abortions. I have absolutely no sympathy for organizations that defend and support legislators who vote in favor of murderous activity,” Cain said.

Right to Life, he said, is “the leading voice on advancing pro-life legislation in the Capitol. They take arrows because they don’t provide cover for pro-choice Republicans.”

But Wright said the Right to Life crossed the line when it endorsed primary challengers to four Republican legislators who had received a 100 percent rating from Right to Life for votes taken in the 2017 legislative session as well as previous sessions — Reps. Giovanni Capriglione of Southlake, Wayne Faircloth of Galveston, Dan Flynn of Canton and Chris Paddie of Marshall.

“I have refrained from speaking out for a very long time. I’ve been more outspoken this election cycle because it’s gotten so bad,” Wright said.

‘Respectful advocacy’

Vásquez, the Austin bishop, said that although the directive raised objections to Right to Life’s scorecard and voter guide, its release during early voting for the March 6 primary was coincidental.

“We were working on this for a while. It has nothing to do with the primaries or the elections going on. It just happened to be that this was time we … were ready to send it out as a notice to our priests,” he said. “This needed to be clarified.”

The directive also noted that Catholic-supported legislation, which often sought to make “incremental improvements” to legal limits on abortion, has been opposed by Right to Life for being too tentative and contrary to true Catholic teaching — a contention that clearly chafed the bishops.

“Texas Right to Life is not the group or organization entrusted to defend Catholic teachings. That’s the bishops,” Vásquez said.

The directive also encouraged Catholics to remain active in opposing abortion and endorsed participation in Texans for Life Alliance, Texas Alliance for Life and “pro-life groups which engage in respectful legislative advocacy.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Of course Bill Murray pops by as alumnus gifts UT with comedic posters
Of course Bill Murray pops by as alumnus gifts UT with comedic posters

The Harry Ransom Center at the University of Texas holds some of the most treasured cultural artifacts the world over, one of the school’s distinguished alumni, Cappy McGarr, said Saturday. That includes one of only eight copies of the Gutenberg Bible in the United States and the first photograph ever taken, two centuries ago. The storied library...
JUST IN: Person in custody after intentional dumpster fire at Kohl’s, $100K in damages
JUST IN: Person in custody after intentional dumpster fire at Kohl’s, $100K in damages

Fire investigators took a person into custody Saturday after they say a fire was intentionally started in a dumpster outside of a Kohl’s in North Austin. The Austin Fire Department responded around noon Saturday to a fire in the dumpster at the store at 13609 North Interstate 35. The blaze was contained to the dumpster and did not spread...
Asylum seeker released from Taylor detention center, group says
Asylum seeker released from Taylor detention center, group says

A Salvadoran woman seeking asylum who has said that a guard groped her inside a Williamson County immigration detention facility has been released, a group supporting her said Saturday morning. Laura Monterrosa was released from the T. Don Hutto detention facility in Taylor on Friday night, the group Grassroots Leadership said. The group did not say...
Elderly woman navigates busy traffic in Memphis on mobility scooter
Elderly woman navigates busy traffic in Memphis on mobility scooter

A woman alarmed drivers in Memphis on Friday night as she drove a mobility scooter onto a dangerous highway. The woman, who appeared to be in her 70s or 80s, was seen driving around 7 p.m. The incident was recorded live on Facebook.  The video was being filmed as a cry for help. Facebook user, Towanna Murphy, asked her friends to please share...
FORECAST: Warm, cloudy Saturday at SXSW; only slight chance of showers
FORECAST: Warm, cloudy Saturday at SXSW; only slight chance of showers

It’s the last Saturday of South By Southwest and the National Weather Service expects it will be warm and cloudy, with only a slight chance of showers in the afternoon. Saturday’s highs should be around 86 degrees under mostly cloudy skies, and meteorologists put rain chances at 20 percent, most likely after 1 p.m. As bands take the outdoor...
More Stories