Appeals court to weigh UT professors’ move to ban guns from classrooms


Highlights

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will hear oral arguments Wednesday in New Orleans.

Three UT professors claim they face a chilling effect because of possibility of concealed handguns in class.

Lawyers for three University of Texas professors who want to prohibit concealed handguns in their classrooms will try to revive their lawsuit seeking that result during oral arguments Wednesday before federal appeals judges in New Orleans.

U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel of Austin denied a request in August 2016 for a preliminary injunction that would have allowed Jennifer Lynn Glass, Lisa Moore and Mia Carter to declare their classrooms gun-free zones.

Yeakel said he found no precedent for the professors’ argument that they have a right of academic freedom under the First Amendment so broad that it overrides decisions of the Legislature and the university that employs them. In July 2017, he dismissed the case, ruling that the plaintiffs lack standing to assert their constitutional claims.

The three women appealed to the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, arguing that the lower court failed to consider claims that their rights under the Second Amendment and the Constitution’s equal protection clause have been impinged. They want the appeals court to rule that they have standing to present those claims and to send the case back to the district court for further proceedings.

Court papers filed by the professors’ lawyers summarized their case this way: “(i) under the First Amendment, claiming that their right to academic freedom would be chilled; (ii) under the Second Amendment, claiming that they should not be subjected to the guns-in-the-classroom rule because the state could not demonstrate that carrying guns in Texas is ‘well-regulated’ within the meaning of the amendment’s introductory clause; and (iii) under the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, claiming that the distinctions in UT-Austin’s policy between where concealed carry had to be allowed and where it could be disallowed were not rationally drawn.”

The defendants in the case — state Attorney General Ken Paxton, UT President Gregory L. Fenves and UT’s governing board — contend that the three professors don’t have a legal leg to stand on.

State law has allowed holders of concealed handgun licenses to carry such weapons on the grounds of public colleges and universities since 1995. Senate Bill 11, passed in 2015 by the Republican-controlled Legislature and signed by GOP Gov. Greg Abbott, permits handgun license holders to also carry in campus buildings, subject to rules established by each college president.

Fenves has said that handguns have no place on a college campus, declaring them “contrary to our mission of education and research, which is based on inquiry, free speech, and debate.” But he also has said that he is duty-bound to comply with the law, and in drafting rules for the Austin flagship he concluded that banning guns from classrooms would have the effect of generally prohibiting them on campus, in violation of the law.

The UT president now finds himself part of the state’s full-throated defense of campus carry. Indeed, the defendants’ court papers describe the campus carry law as part of a “thoughtful reformation of the State’s gun laws” by the Legislature.

“Plaintiffs came to federal court to vindicate their inflated conception of the privileged status they hold compared to all other public employees,” the state’s lawyers wrote, “but they failed to bring with them the necessary case or controversy.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

3 young cancer patients sworn in as police officers for day 
3 young cancer patients sworn in as police officers for day 

Three young cancer patients from New York were sworn in as police officers for a day in a surprise ceremony Wednesday, Newsday reported. >> Read more trending news  Jesse Pallas, 11, Sean Hughes, 10, and Zachary Cote, 9, have been undergoing cancer treatments. They met at an event for families dealing with childhood cancer and became...
Flores’ upset victory casts doubt on ‘blue wave’ for Texas Democrats
Flores’ upset victory casts doubt on ‘blue wave’ for Texas Democrats

Casting doubt on Democratic hopes for a blue wave in Texas, Republican Pete Flores defeated Democrat Pete Gallego in Tuesday’s runoff election for a vacant seat in the state Senate — a seat that had been safely in Democratic hands for years. With the crucial midterm elections only seven weeks away, better-organized Republicans flipped the...
BLOTTER: San Marcos man accused of holding ex-girlfriend hostage
BLOTTER: San Marcos man accused of holding ex-girlfriend hostage

SAN MARCOS Man accused of holding ex-girlfriend hostage San Marcos police arrested a man Tuesday who they say held his ex-girlfriend hostage in his apartment for 24 hours. Timothy Gomez, 23, has been charged with unlawful restraint and continuous violence against a family member, police said. He was at the Hays County Jail on Wednesday on those charges...
Online scammers stole $350,000 from wife of Florida Gov. Rick Scott
Online scammers stole $350,000 from wife of Florida Gov. Rick Scott

Online scammers attacked the personal email account of the wife of Florida Gov. Rick Scott on two occasions and robbed her of $350,000, the Tampa Bay Times reported Wednesday. >> Read more trending news  The email account of Ann Scott was hacked in 2012 and 2014 and both incidents were connected to Broward and Miami-Dade counties, the...
JUST IN: Man accused of holding ex-girlfriend hostage in San Marcos apartment
JUST IN: Man accused of holding ex-girlfriend hostage in San Marcos apartment

San Marcos police arrested a man Tuesday who they say held his ex-girlfriend hostage in his apartment for 24 hours. Timothy Gomez, 23, has been charged with unlawful restraint and continuous violence against a family member, police say. He was at the Hays County Jail on Wednesday on those charges and for an outstanding warrant for burglary of a habitation...
More Stories