Sonia Cacy found innocent in old arson-murder case


The state’s highest criminal court declared Sonia Cacy innocent of murder on Wednesday, ending a long legal battle in a West Texas case featuring bad arson science, falsified evidence and a rarely granted parole from state officials.

Cacy, now in poor health and living with her son in South Texas, was convicted of setting a fire in her Fort Stockton home that killed her uncle, Bill Richardson, while he slept in 1991. She was sentenced to 99 years in prison.

Supporters who continued working on her behalf, including now-deceased chemist Gerald Hurst of Austin, uncovered evidence showing that Richardson, a 76-year-old who smoked up to three packs of cigarettes a day, died of a heart attack while smoking in bed.

Arson investigators ignored multiple cigarette burns on Richardson’s sheets and around his bed, and they failed to acknowledge the significance of an autopsy report showing no smoke in his lungs, indicated he was already dead when the fire started. court records show.

Presented with the new evidence, the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles took the unusual step of granting Cacy parole after she had served only six years of her sentence, and efforts began to have the courts formally acknowledge her innocence — which the Court of Criminal Appeals granted in an 8-0 ruling Wednesday.

The two-page opinion did not discuss reasons for the ruling, though two judges filed a concurring opinion stating that they believed Cacy did not prove herself innocent, but merely presented enough new evidence to make it unlikely that she would have been convicted had jurors seen the information.

Judge Bert Richardson did not participate in the court’s deliberations or ruling because he oversaw Cacy’s case as a visiting judge before his election to the appeals court.

In his findings in the case, Richardson had recommended that Cacy be found innocent, noting that new evidence also cast doubt on lab tests that had found gasoline on the clothes worn by Cacy’s uncle. Investigators later showed that a tester falsified the evidence receipt for the man’s clothing, and that tests performed by another employee of the Bexar County Forensic Science Center detected no accelerants on the clothes, the judge determined.

Gary Udashen, Cacy’s lawyer, praised the ruling.

“I think Sonia’s case is a very clear example of how bad science in court can cause such an egregious injustice that it ruins people’s lives,” he said. “Texas is leading the country in dealing with the issues of bad science, and the court’s opinion here is another instance of the Court of Criminal Appeals taking steps to rectify this problem.”

Cacy’s innocence also was supported by a review of old arson cases by the State Fire Marshal’s Office, which determined that the arson finding in her case was not supported by modern science.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Austin pastors among Methodist leaders filing complaint against Attorney General Jeff Sessions
Austin pastors among Methodist leaders filing complaint against Attorney General Jeff Sessions

Hundreds of leaders within the United Methodist Church, including some Austin pastors, filed a formal complaint Monday against Attorney General Jeff Sessions, requesting that church authorities “dig deeply into Mr. Sessions’ advocacy and actions that have led to harm against thousands of vulnerable humans.” Sessions is Methodist...
Class action suit calls out Travis County officials over sex assault investigations
Class action suit calls out Travis County officials over sex assault investigations

A federal class action lawsuit filed Monday slams current and former Travis County and Austin officials, including district attorneys and police chiefs, arguing that they don’t adequately investigate or seek to prosecute suspects in women’s sexual assault cases. The suit names as defendants the city of Austin, Travis County and five individuals...
Cómo ayudar a las familias separadas en la frontera
Cómo ayudar a las familias separadas en la frontera

Varias organizaciones en Texas están buscando firmas, donaciones y voluntarios después de que casi 2 mil menores inmigrantes han sido separados de sus padres en la frontera entre Texas y México como parte de una nueva iniciativa del Departamento de Justicia de Estados Unidos. El 6 de abril, el procurador general Jeff Sessions anunció...
Austin ISD board approves $1.4 billion budget, with employee raises
Austin ISD board approves $1.4 billion budget, with employee raises

The Austin school board Monday night adopted a $1.4 billion budget, which requires dipping into its fund balance by nearly $30 million to cover the district’s shortfall. It is the second consecutive year the district will need to pull from its reserves to cover expenses. The board voted 7 to 1, with Trustee Ted Gordon voting against. Gordon said...
Austin ISD board adopts plan that leaves some schools without nurses
Austin ISD board adopts plan that leaves some schools without nurses

The Austin school board Monday night approved a $7.1 million student health services plan that will continue to leave some campuses without a school nurse and others with a part-time nurse on site. Seton Healthcare Family, which has provided the district’s student medical services for nearly 25 years, will provide 75 nurses and 48 clinical assistants...
More Stories