Report: Suspensions of youngest Texas students still a problem


State law passed last year bans out-of-school suspensions of youngest students, but not in-school suspensions.

Killeen had some of the highest rates of pre-K suspensions in the state in 2015-16.

Texans Care for Children say suspensions of youngest students don’t address underlying issues.

State officials and school districts need to do more to drive down disciplinary action taken against Texas’ youngest public school students, according to a report released Monday by a child advocacy group.

The Legislature last year passed House Bill 674, which prohibits out-of-school suspensions of prekindergarten through second-grade students unless they brought a gun to school, were involved with drugs or committed a violent offense.

The bill did not bar in-school suspensions, which some Texas school districts have used excessively against young students, according to a report by Austin-based nonprofit Texans Care for Children.

“Just as they’re figuring out what they think about school and if they fit in, a suspension tells them they don’t fit in and they’re a bad kid,” said the organization’s CEO, Stephanie Rubin, who recommends eliminating the use of in-school suspensions. “Suspending a young child does nothing to resolve underlying issues, which are always at play with challenging behavior.”

Using disciplinary data that school districts report to the Texas Education Agency each year, the organization said that in the 2015-16 school year, Texas school districts issued more than 101,000 suspensions against students in pre-K through second grade, and two-thirds of them were in-school suspensions.

The Jasper school district in East Texas had the highest rate of in-school pre-K suspensions, issuing 71 to 23 of the district’s 122 pre-K students.

Although most school districts with high rates of in-school suspensions were smaller, moderately sized Killeen was near the top after doling out 880 suspensions to 319 of the district’s 3,423 pre-K students.

Killeen school district spokesman Terry Abbott said schools have been working to reduce the use of suspensions of all kinds at the lowest grade levels since 2015-16. So far this school year, he said, Killeen has used in-school suspensions 702 times against 212 of the district’s 3,812 pre-K students.

Schools disproportionately suspend young students who are boys, black, in special education or in foster care, according to the report. Studies have shown that students removed from classrooms for disciplinary behavior are more likely to have poor grades, engage in further misbehavior and drop out of school, Texans Care for Children said.

Rubin fears school districts that frequently suspend students will rely more heavily on in-school suspensions, which are still allowed under the new law.

“There needs to be more exploration of what kinds of training and supports are available, in particular to smaller rural districts,” Rubin said. “It’s important to look at school codes of conduct. Some have very zero-tolerance approaches, and others have much more supportive school environments.”

READ: Austin trustees weigh ban on suspensions for youngest students

Some of the state’s largest school districts — including Houston, Dallas, El Paso and Austin — received positive marks from the organization for not only having low suspension rates but for eliminating the use of out-of-school suspensions on the district’s youngest students before HB 674 became law.

Six years ago, the Austin school district began implementing an alternative to suspensions and expulsions through social emotional learning, a curriculum that teaches children to self-regulate, verbalize their issues, learn empathy and get along better with others. Three years ago, the district started training in a specific way to help children who have experienced trauma.

In 2015-16, Austin reported 18 pre-K suspensions out of more than 4,800 students, one of the lowest rates in the state. The district had 351 suspensions in pre-K through second grade that year.

“We believe the decrease is a direct result of support our students receive from AISD teachers, counseling staff and administrators,” said Edmund Oropez, Austin district’s chief officer of teaching and learning.

Other recommendations from Texans Care for Children included better data reporting, as well as:

• Training teachers, staff and local child care centers on alternative behavioral management practices.

• Ensuring districts are providing young students with special education services if they need it.

• Investing more in school counselors.

• Strengthening the state’s Early Childhood Intervention program, which helps babies and toddlers with disabilities and developmental delays to receive therapies and support.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Georgetown police: Man has harassed Sun City residents since 2016
Georgetown police: Man has harassed Sun City residents since 2016

Georgetown police are searching for a man who has been harassing Sun City residents for more than two years, even walking into their homes at night and standing at the foot of their beds until they wake up, a police spokesman said. Sun City is a retirement community with several thousand homes in Georgetown. The man has been involved in at least 50...
Former MLB athlete Kelly Wayne Gruber arrested in Austin on DWI charge
Former MLB athlete Kelly Wayne Gruber arrested in Austin on DWI charge

Former Major League Baseball athlete Kelly Wayne Gruber was arrested in Austin on a DWI charge Saturday, records show. Gruber, 56, was a two-time All-Star while playing baseball for the Toronto Blue Jays from 1984 to 1992. As a teenager, Gruber played baseball for Westlake High School.  An Austin officer pulled Gruber over after noticing...
Police: Man attacked, cut person he thought was behind home invasion
Police: Man attacked, cut person he thought was behind home invasion

An Austin man is accused of cutting an apartment resident with a machete because he thought the victim was involved in a home invasion, according to an arrest affidavit released this week. Samuel Diaz-Parra, 58, was charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, a second-degree felony punishable by up to 20 years in jail. The attack happened...
Temple physician arrested for child porn, Texas Medical Board says

TEMPLE Texas Medical Board: Physician arrested for child porn The Texas Medical Board on Monday suspended the license of Temple physician John Middlemiss Palmer after he was arrested on child porn charges. “The Board panel found that on or about April 18, 2018, Dr. Palmer was charged with possession of child pornography by the Texas Attorney...
Jury weighs murder charge in Austin stabbing death of Daniel Spencer
Jury weighs murder charge in Austin stabbing death of Daniel Spencer

A Travis County jury began deliberating Monday evening in the murder trial of 67-year-old James Robert Miller Jr., who is accused of fatally stabbing 32-year-old Daniel Spencer in September 2015. Miller’s attorney says it was self-defense. Spencer was killed at his home early on the morning of Sept. 21, after inviting Miller to his house to play...
More Stories