Over Ken Paxton’s objection, judge OKs gay marriage settlement


Turning aside objections from Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, a Travis County judge approved an out-of-court settlement Tuesday that recognizes the eight-year relationship of two Austin women as a common-law marriage.

The settlement accepted by Travis County Probate Judge Guy Herman ended an estate fight between Sonemaly Phrasavath and family members of the woman soon to be legally acknowledged as her wife — Stella Powell, who died of cancer in June 2014.

Reached last week with the help of a mediator, the agreement divided Powell’s estate roughly in half between Phrasavath and members of Powell’s family. It also acknowledged Phrasavath as Powell’s spouse from a common-law or informal marriage — a legal distinction that doesn’t require a marriage license.

An Oct. 5 hearing has been set to formally declare Phrasavath as Powell’s heir due to marriage — the first common-law marriage finding for a same-sex couple in Texas history, lawyers said.

Lawyers for Paxton opposed the designation during a hearing before Herman on Tuesday, arguing that the settlement ended the legal dispute over Powell’s estate, making any decision about Phrasavath’s marital status moot and beyond Herman’s jurisdiction.

But Brian Thompson, Phrasavath’s lawyer, told Herman that his client would settle for nothing less than the recognition of her relationship as a valid marriage, particularly after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned state laws banning same-sex marriage in June.

“How many more courts have to tell Ken Paxton that these statutes (banning same-sex marriage) are unconstitutional?” Thompson said. “Apparently one more.”

Thompson also asked Herman to remove Paxton from the case, saying his office had “no interest in this family dispute.”

“The denial of my client’s fundamental right to marry needs to end today, and Ken Paxton’s groundless, harassing and mean-spirited attacks on same-sex couples needs to end today,” he said. “The only reason the state is attempting to continue to interfere in this case is because Som and Stella were a same-sex couple, and Ken Paxton can’t live with the fact.”

Ruling from the bench after the 20-minute hearing, Herman granted the motion to remove Paxton as a party to the probate case. The judge also approved the settlement without comment.

Paxton’s office is evaluating its options to challenge Herman’s finding, which could create confusion by potentially reopening already finalized probate cases, spokeswoman Cynthia Meyer said.

Thompson disagreed, saying other courts have rejected the argument in cases involving the death of a same-sex spouse.

Neither Phrasavath nor Powell’s family attended Tuesday’s hearing.

Texas courts can recognize a common-law marriage if a couple who lives together — no time limit is specified — agrees they are married and presents themselves as married, such as introducing each other as a spouse.

Phrasavath and Powell met the legal definition of informal marriage, Thompson said, noting that they began dating in 2006 and celebrated a 2008 marriage ceremony that, though not recognized under Texas law, was performed by a Zen Buddhist priest. They lived openly as spouses in a Northwest Hills home, he added.

Phrasavath also cared for Powell, acting with her medical power of attorney during Powell’s eight-month fight with cancer before she died at age 53, Thompson said.

Herman’s court became involved because a will dividing Powell’s estate among her three siblings, mother, Phrasavath and a church was never executed. Unable to agree with Phrasavath on how to divide the estate, two of Powell’s siblings filed suit last fall stating that Powell died single because she wasn’t married under Texas law. Phrasavath responded by challenging the constitutionality of Texas’ ban on gay marriage and moved to establish her relationship as a common-law marriage.

The case became national news in February when Herman ruled in Phrasavath’s favor, declaring that the Texas ban violated the U.S. Constitution’s promise of equal protection and fair treatment under the law.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Cold front to bring rain, cooler temperatures to Austin
Cold front to bring rain, cooler temperatures to Austin

Any rain is good rain in Austin, as long as it doesn’t fall too fast, forecasters say — and it likely won't on Wednesday as a weak cold front comes into Central Texas near the end of a particularly wet month.   The cold front moving from the west into the area could produce showers and thunderstorms through Thursday, National...
Hiking cost of entry fees attempts to address city’s ailing pool system
Hiking cost of entry fees attempts to address city’s ailing pool system

Starting next week, the price to take a dip in a city of Austin pool will rise. On Monday, adult residents will start paying $5 — or $2 more — to enter Barton Springs Pool and all other city pools. Juniors aged 12 to 17 will pay $3, and children from 1 to 11 will pay $2. Both figures represent a $1 increase. Senior residents will pay $2...
UT investigating Sen. Charles Schwertner after sexual misconduct claim
UT investigating Sen. Charles Schwertner after sexual misconduct claim

The University of Texas is investigating an allegation that state Sen. Charles Schwertner sent a sexually explicit image and text message to a graduate student he met at an on-campus event this summer, three senior UT officials with knowledge of the investigation told the American-Statesman. If the allegation is deemed true, the university would consider...
Driver hits, critically injures pedestrian near Guadalupe, 29th streets
Driver hits, critically injures pedestrian near Guadalupe, 29th streets

A driver hit and injured a pedestrian near Guadalupe and 29th streets Tuesday afternoon, Austin police said. The man, estimated to be in his 30s, was hospitalized with critical, life-threatening injuries, Austin-Travis County EMS officials said.  The driver stayed at the scene after hitting the man, police said.  Police responded at 3:53...
Report: Church that opposes gay marriage can still use AISD center
Report: Church that opposes gay marriage can still use AISD center

Amid pressure from conservatives, the Austin school district will continue allowing Georgetown-based Celebration Church to rent the district’s Performing Arts Center for Sunday service, according to church officials. “We are proud to support the excellent work of the AISD and are thankful that all community organizations like Celebration...
More Stories