breaking news

NFL owners adopt new policy to address anthem protests

Why I voted to release the Nunes memo


In 1885, Woodrow Wilson wrote in his treatise “Congressional Government: A Study in American Politics” that “the informing function of Congress should be preferred even to its legislative function.”

I voted to release the Nunes memo because, like Wilson, I believe that the duty to inform the American public is one of my biggest responsibilities as an elected representative in our democratic republic. This is in accordance with the Legislative Reorganization Act of 1946, which directed House and Senate committees to “exercise continuous watchfulness” over executive-branch programs.

Furthermore, according to rules of the House, the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, on which I serve, may disclose publicly any information in its possession after a determination by the committee that the public interest would be served by such disclosure.

I spent close to a decade as an undercover officer in the CIA and have spent most of my adult life collecting intelligence and protecting sources and methods. It is my job to know the difference between information and intelligence. As a result, I’ve been asked by some how I could vote to make classified information public. My response is simple: Not all classified information has national security implications. If it does, it should be withheld. But as David Garrow, a Pulitzer Prize-winning historian, once said, “Just because you see it in a top-secret document, just because someone had said it to the FBI, doesn’t mean it’s all accurate.”

Classified information includes much more than the actual “secrets” acquired. It includes how they were acquired and the process by which related analyses were made. Professionals refer to the stages of the intelligence cycle as collection, processing, analyzing and sharing information. In most cases, the implications and significance of raw pieces of information found in classified materials are reviewed and vetted to keep sensationalized and unsubstantiated accounts from being deemed credible. This process should also identify circular reporting, which is when a piece of information appears to come from multiple sources but in fact comes from only one source, even though it is offered through different channels.

In matters addressed by the Nunes memo, I am not confident that proper vetting occurred, and I believe that the American people should have the ability to decide for themselves.

As the nation’s premier law enforcement agency, the FBI is expected to maintain the highest levels of professionalism and excellence. I have had the honor of working side by side with true American patriots in the FBI who have made tremendous sacrifices for our country. There is little doubt we have been free of another attack on the scale of the one that occurred Sept. 11, 2001, because of the men and women in our intelligence services, armed forces, diplomatic corps and federal law enforcement agencies - especially the FBI.

However, if the FBI requests a warrant from a federal court to conduct surveillance on an American citizen, it has a duty to every citizen not to use information that the then-FBI director himself considered “salacious and unverified,” or information drawn from circular reporting and rumors.

My vote to release the memo was not about discrediting the special counsel’s investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election. It was not about debasing the hard-working men and women serving in the FBI. Rather, I supported the release because I do not agree that an American citizen’s civil liberties should be violated on the basis of unverified information masquerading as intelligence.

The Intelligence Committee also voted this week on whether to release the minority response. This secondary memo included many references that would affect existing intelligence activity. I voted against releasing the minority response until revisions are made to ensure that it would not jeopardize national security.

Let me be clear, special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation must continue to ensure that our democracy was not compromised by Russian interference.

However, regardless of Mueller’s investigation, all Americans should understand the implications of the actions taken by the leaders of our federal law enforcement agencies and their impact on our citizenry. I understand the FBI and Justice Department’s unprecedented public denunciation of the potential publication of the memo, because they don’t want to see a precedent set by which Congress firmly exercises its informing function.

But it is the right of our citizens to demand that they are kept informed by the men and women they send to Washington, especially during troubling and contentious times. My vote to release this memo did exactly that.

Hurd, a Republican from Texas, is a member of the House Intelligence Committee.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Commentary: I got arrested for standing up against poverty
Commentary: I got arrested for standing up against poverty

This past Monday, I was arrested for blocking traffic in front of the U.S. Capitol along with 170 other low-income people and faith leaders from across the country. At first, I was scared and nervous to risk arrest, but I eventually felt at ease as we sang freedom songs and chanted for justice. This nonviolent civil disobedience was part of the launch...
Letters to the editor: May 24, 2018
Letters to the editor: May 24, 2018

Re: May 19 article, “What’s the best sunscreen? We put more than 20 to the test.” The article failed to emphasize that no matter how good the product, sunscreen is ineffective if not applied correctly. I swim outdoors year-round and know from firsthand experience and close observation that most pool visitors apply sunscreen incorrectly...
Donald Glover, king of the world: Why we hope to one day see ‘Lando: A Star Wars Story’
Donald Glover, king of the world: Why we hope to one day see ‘Lando: A Star Wars Story’

In October 2016, Starwars.com confirmed what had been rumored: Donald Glover had been hired to play a young Lando Calrissian in “Solo: A Star Wars Story.” At the time, Glover was best know as a comedy writer on “30 Rock,” a strong actor on the sitcom “Community,” a good-not-great stand-up comic, and a musical...
Author tackles one of the greatest baseball teams you’ve never heard of
Author tackles one of the greatest baseball teams you’ve never heard of

When Anne Keene, the Austin author of “The Cloudbuster Nine: The Untold Story of Ted Williams and the Baseball Team that Helped Win World War II,” was growing up, she knew that her father both loved and hated the game of baseball. She knew he adored it, loved the old players, told stories about them to the point that it became something...
Herman: Time for the look-at-me candidate to look ahead
Herman: Time for the look-at-me candidate to look ahead

In the end, as loser Andrew White sees it, “look at me” beat “listen to me” as Democrats, the relatively few who showed up to vote, picked former Dallas County Sheriff Lupe Valdez as their November candidate against GOP Gov. Greg Abbott. “It’s been an odd race,” White told me two hours before the polls closed...
More Stories