Kendrick: Perry should veto testing bill


The Austin Chamber of Commerce encourages Gov. Rick Perry to veto the Legislature’s bill to lower state graduation requirements. We encourage the Legislature to work with the governor to immediately craft a bill which will retain the good parts of House Bill 5 without lowering graduation expectations. Central Texas has tens of thousands of high-wage, high-skill jobs. We have to set up our children to be prepared for those opportunities.

Six years ago, the Texas Legislature overwhelmingly passed House Bill 3 to replace the four TAKS exit tests with a new system which would assess whether students had learned enough academic content in math, science and English to be prepared for post-secondary education and the high-performance workplace.

Employers and Chambers of Commerce statewide applauded. At the time, only 37 percent of Texas graduates met the state definition for college/career readiness. This added financial pressure on unprepared students and their families, since they had to pay to re-learn what they failed to learn in high school. For many, it meant the end of their pursuit of high-performance careers.

Unfortunately, in 2007, House Bill 3 overshot the mark, instituting a complicated set of 15 end-of-course assessments and tying grades, class rank and graduation plan requirements to them. To compound matters, the Texas Education Agency was slow to make decisions. Students, parents, educators and the public wanted much more clarity than TEA was communicating.

So a few days ago, the Texas Legislature again attempted to rectify the situation, this time overwhelmingly passing HB 5. Unfortunately, the 2013 Legislature again overshot. While the bill does reduce the number of graduation tests, it would also actually reduce what high school students must demonstrate to levels below even that of the four TAKS tests.

To make matters worse, House Bill 5 introduces even more complexity than what occurred in 2007.

House Bill 5 creates three new courses of study. All students are placed on the middle course of study upon entering high school. Strangely, students become eligible for scholarships by completing the lowest course of study. They only become eligible for the top 10 percent automatic state university admission, however, under the highest course of study.

Beyond the three courses of study, the Legislature creates five “endorsements” and three “seals” for students who complete courses ranging from specific ability to speak another language to the ill-defined arts and humanities endorsement. Surprisingly, the Legislature puts no money into the budget to help students, parents, counselors and the public understand all this complexity.

In this special session, the Legislature can fix House Bill 5. Here’s how:

• Reduce graduation testing by at least half. Continue to expect students to demonstrate knowledge at least on par with TAKS to graduate. If the Legislature doesn’t scrap end-of-course testing altogether and return to the TAKS, they should at least choose the six tests which cover the same content: algebra, geometry, biology, chemistry, physics, and English 11/writing.

• Continue to place students on an internationally competitive course of study. In House Bill 5, this would be either an endorsement or the distinguished course of study. Continue to ensure parents have a major say in the decision made about their child’s graduation plan.

• Ensure each endorsement requires students to learn content in physics and algebra II or statistics (applied or traditional). Manufacturing is built on these skills.

• Continue to keep all incentives like college scholarships, top 10 percent automatic admission and university admission aligned to student completion of that competitive course of study.

• Ensure innovative courses which teach traditional content in a hands-on way first receive approval from Texas’ Education commissioner or the State Board of Education to ensure that, if the family moves, credits transfer with the child.

• Fund the state to train every high school counselor thoroughly on the raft of new options, graduation plans, seals and college eligibility requirements.

This approach reduces testing, reduces mandates, increases flexibility, keeps the system simple but doesn’t lower expectations.

Most importantly, this approach encourages innovation while allowing the chamber to continue to credibly tell taxpayers, parents, international, U.S. and locally-based companies that Central Texas wants our public school graduates to be as prepared as those anywhere in the world.

Kendrick is the 2013 Austin Chamber of Commerce chair for education/talent development


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Letters to the editor: Sept. 25, 2018
Letters to the editor: Sept. 25, 2018

Query: What are the Republican senators and Chuck Grassley afraid of? What is President Donald Trump afraid of? They all do not want an FBI investigation into the events leading to the accusation of sexual assault, attempted rape of Dr. Ford, by then-high school student Brett Kavanaugh. Why? Many years ago, during another Supreme Court Justice Senate...
Commentary: Fathers need to remember that their sons are watching

CHICAGO — What’s it like to be a boy these days? It’s a frequent thought for me as I navigate my son’s 17th year of life in a world where the scourge of toxic masculinity shares the public consciousness with admiration of spectacularly muscled sports stars and big-screen superheroes whose worth is predicated on their physical...
Facebook comments: Sept. 25, 2018

Recently the American-Statesman’s Lori Hawkins and Shonda Novak gave an update on development on South Congress Avenue, where a number of construction projects are under way. Some of the projects include The Magdalena, a Liz Lambert hotel under construction at Music Lane and Academy Drive with a projected fall 2019 opening; Saint Vincent, a three-story...
Opinion: The burden of proof for Kavanaugh

Last week, I wrote a column taking the view that conservatives supporting Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination to the Supreme Court because they hope he will overturn Roe v. Wade should be willing to encourage his withdrawal if his accuser testifies credibly against him and the cloud over his nomination can’t be expeditiously cleared up. Even if...
Opinion: Is Senate committee equipped to grasp Kavanaugh allegations?

For all their well-learned politesse, the Republican members of the Senate Judiciary Committee have scarcely been able to conceal their determination to get Christine Blasey Ford out of their hair. Ford is the last obstacle to confirming conservative Judge Brett Kavanaugh to the U.S. Supreme Court. And she’s a formidable one. She has alleged...
More Stories