Jack Hunter: Americans are more emotional about Trump than ever

Visiting home in Charleston, South Carolina over the holidays, conversations with friends and family often turned political.

And by “political,” I mean Donald Trump.

On the week before Christmas, when the president signed the tax bill into law, my right-leaning acquaintances were hailing the legislation (which they should, though it still ignores the unignorable problem of massive spending) while progressive friends thought it was a disaster, designed to gouge them and everyone else with higher taxes (most Americans will get a tax cut even if they don’t believe it).

In their jubilation, conservatives did not want to hear about the lack of spending reform, though Republicans once threatened to shutdown the government over the same kind of recklessness during the Obama administration. Progressives really didn’t know what to say about so many major corporations and businesses handing out bonuses and raising wages in the wake of the bill’s passage, so they just stuck to script about reducing corporate rates being a break for “the rich” (when President Obama wanted to cut corporate tax rates for much the same reason Trump is doing so, I don’t remember many Democrats being too critical).

But when it comes to Trump, discussing policy is often just the excuse: Some people really like Donald Trump, and some really loathe him no matter what he does. No matter how much I tried to emphasize to conservative friends that the same kind of deficit increases contained in this tax bill was the same thing Tea Party Republicans had railed against for years, the response was something like, “well everyone is just against everything Trump does.” No matter how much I tried to explain that the tax bill would actually lower most people’s taxes, liberal friends zeroed in on Trump, the man, and how nothing good could ever possibly come from him.

Of course, this is not new. Trump has been one of the most uniquely polarizing political figures for over two years now. But one year into his presidency, instead of his defenders beginning to see more flaws, or critics calming down some, the emotions of many in each camp seem to have intensified. Not for all of them or perhaps even most of them, but enough. I was somewhat taken aback by some of the conversations I had when returning home. I thought some of the passion would have subsided. Merely bringing up the tax bill reminded me on more than one occasion that this was not the case. The same had been true of the net neutrality repeal debate two weeks prior, where people claimed the internet was being either “destroyed” or “saved” based on the new FCC policy - with all the fury still being personified in Trump.

I generally put more stock in what people in South Carolina, or most people anywhere else outside of Washington, DC, have to say about politics. The Beltway elite never saw the Trump phenomenon coming in the first place. When liberal documentarian Michael Moore returned to his home of Flint, Michigan in 2016, he then became certain Trump would win. Most politicians and pundits (including me) thought Hillary Clinton was a shoo-in. Obviously, the “experts” were wrong. Today, Moore thinks Trump will win a second term.

It’s too soon to make such predictions. But two polls released last week were telling, in terms of the media’s portrayal of Trump compared with the public’s perception and what that could mean for the future.

The Pew Research Center reported that the media had been three times more negative toward Trump in his first year than they had been with President Obama in his first year. I mentioned this to a pro-Trump friend. His response? “Duh.” I mentioned to an anti-Trump friend, too. She said that the Trump coverage was more negative because obviously there were more negative things to report compared to Obama.

But couple the Pew finding with a Rasmussen poll released last week that showed that when comparing Trump and Obama’s first year polling numbers, both presidents had about equal approval and disapproval. Trump has a 45 percent approval compared to Obama’s 46 percent and both men had a 53 disapproval rating at the end of their first year.

What does this mean? Will Trump also go on to serve two terms? No one knows.

But many do continue have strong opinions about him, positive and negative, arguably more so than any other modern president.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Commentary: Why Austin should take Dale Watson’s exit seriously
Commentary: Why Austin should take Dale Watson’s exit seriously

There’s a conversation in Austin that’s as predictable as starting the day with breakfast tacos and it revolves around the question that’s on a lot of people’s minds: Is our Austin dying? From Pinballz to Luis’ Corner Barber Shop and Yoga Vida to the patio over at LaLa’s, we love talking about what Austin is evolving...
Letters to the editor: March 25, 2018
Letters to the editor: March 25, 2018

Truly we all feel the Austin Police Department did an outstanding job of apprehending the bomber that terrified the city. As many other law enforcement agencies assisted in this process, the Austin police served as the base to create the successful outcome. The mayor and City Council can now come to terms to provide a mutually agreed upon contract...
Herman: Napkin folding, hand kissing and other diplomatic intricacies
Herman: Napkin folding, hand kissing and other diplomatic intricacies

Our president recently tweeted this at us: “Mike Pompeo, Director of the CIA, will become our new Secretary of State. He will do a fantastic job!” Exciting. The guy in charge of getting dirt on other countries will become the guy in charge of getting along with other countries. What could possibly go wrong? The change means Secretary of...
Facebook comments: March 25, 2018

As reported by the American-Statesman’s Sean Collins Walsh, Claire Osborn, Tony Plohetski, Jeremy Schwartz and Mary Huber relatives of Mark A. Conditt issued a statement Wednesday afternoon saying they are shocked and devastated by the revelation that he was behind the string of bombings that have terrorized Austin this month. The statement was...
Jonathan Evison’s latest, ‘Lawn Boy,’ brings humor to life’s misfortunes
Jonathan Evison’s latest, ‘Lawn Boy,’ brings humor to life’s misfortunes

An aimless young man decides to get his life together, but life has other plans in Jonathan Evison’s “Lawn Boy.” Mike Muñoz doesn’t quite know what he wants out of life, but he knows he deserves better than what he’s got now: a terrible job cutting lawns, a truck that barely runs, and a tiny house packed with a...
More Stories