Herman: Should doctors play with guns?


It remains a Rorschach test for our times. As I’ve noted after previous incarnations of this ongoing discussion, different people see different things when they see a gun.

Some see only a potential murder weapon. Some see good, clean recreational fun. Few have no reaction when they see or talk about guns.

So perhaps it was foreseeable that the Travis County Medical Society event that had been planned for Saturday could attract more attention than such events usually do.

“The Travis County Medical Society invites you to enjoy this exclusive event,” says the invitation. “Join your colleagues at the new, luxury shooting club.”

The invitation listed the location as the Range at Austin on the east side of Interstate 35 just north of Slaughter Lane. The facility bills itself as “not your typical gun range” and as featuring “one of the largest selection of guns and gun-related accessories in Texas.”

The event came to my attention via Austinite Bernie Gillet, a retired medical scientist who was “incredulous” about it: “I find it troubling that a profession based on the ideal of primum non nocere — first, do no harm — would choose such a social activity, especially in our current environment of gun violence. Multiple physician organizations have released statements over the years on myriad harmful outcomes associated with gun injuries and gun deaths.”

A day after the recent Florida high school shootings, American Medical Association President Dr. David O. Barbe urged physicians to “lend their voice and their considerable political muscle to examine this urgent health crisis — through federally funded research — and take appropriate steps to address it. … We are not talking about Second Amendment rights or restricting your ability to own a firearm. We are talking about a public health crisis that our Congress has failed to address. This must end.”

And he noted the AMA’s call, after the 2012 elementary school shootings in Newtown, Conn., for — among other things — “renewing and strengthening the assault weapons ban, including banning high-capacity magazines.”

Which brings us back to a “bunch of doctors walk into a shooting range.” The local medical society, founded in 1853 and now with about 4,000 members, brings physicians together for social and education functions, as well as updating them on health care trends and legislative matters related to their profession.

“One could argue,” Gillet told me, “that TCMS’s choice for an activity is not unusual, given the views on gun ownership of many Texans and, obviously, at least some of their members. Nonetheless, the escalation of massive shootings and other gun violence begs the question of why esteemed physicians would choose a shooting club for their ‘exclusive event.’”

I posed it to Marshall Cothran, the local medical society’s CEO, who told me the group has programs on public health issues as well as social events “for the purpose of fellowship, relaxation and social interaction among colleagues away from the daily pressures of their work.”

“It would be mistaken to think that, by hosting a private social event for our members at a shooting range, we condone gun violence,” he told me. “Just as it would to think that, by sponsoring a physicians’ happy hour, we are unconcerned about the tragic death toll from drunk driving and other alcohol-related crimes, accidents and diseases.”

“The issues of firearm use and gun control are extremely complex and sensitive, both here in Texas and throughout the United States,” he said. “However, as a component of the Texas Medical Association, TCMS has long advocated for the health and safety of this community, including primary prevention of firearm morbidity and mortality, and it will continue to do so.”

That was Wednesday. On Thursday, Cothran told me that of 4,000 invitations sent out, there were “three emails from members with negative feedback on the event.” He also told me the event was planned prior to the recent Florida high school shootings.

“And yes, we always second-guess ourselves when the unexpected intervenes,” he said, adding “We recognize how easily the true purpose can be obscured by events. … After a lot of thought and consideration, out of respect for those impacted by the recent tragedy and to prevent any misunderstanding of our purpose, we are canceling the event for Saturday,” Cothran said, also telling me there’s no decision as to whether it would be rescheduled for another time.

Good call, one that some might argue could have been made prior to this latest mass shooting.

Your feelings about a bunch of docs at a gun range will be guided by your feelings about guns. I’ll leave that to you.

Me? I’m concentrating on hoping this latest sad chapter in our nearly 20 years of post-Columbine inaction will have a productive ending. I remain wary of restricting the rights of the law-abiding because of the wrongs of the law-breaking. But the status quo is unacceptable.

I’m finding hope in the poise and passion, energy and intelligence of the students of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School. They approach this with a naiveté about the political process that allows them to poke and prod the way others don’t. Our stalemated system could use some poking and prodding.

Maybe mayhem picked on the wrong school this time.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Letters to the editor: Sept. 22, 2018
Letters to the editor: Sept. 22, 2018

Re: Sept. 18 article, “Is Ted Cruz’s ‘summons’ letter deceptive, illegal or fair play?” I am writing in response to the recent mailing of “summons” letters on behalf of Cruz’s campaign. As the race between Ted Cruz and Beto O’Rourke becomes tighter, the Cruz campaign has resorted to unfair play...
Opinion: Trump is racking up record of foreign policy success

WASHINGTON — In his new book “Fear,” Bob Woodward recounts that in April 2017, after President Trump saw images of dead Syrian children with their mouths foaming from a sarin attack, he called Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and issued an order: Get me a plan for a military strike to take out Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. &ldquo...
Opinions: Of time, tides and Trump

OK, I know you’re obsessed about sex and the Supreme Court. But the hurricane flooding in North Carolina has been terrible. Let’s give it some serious thought right now. Particularly when it comes to ways the government screwed up. First lesson is easy. Coastal flooding is getting way, way worse because of global warming. So obviously we&rsquo...
Herman: The building says something else, but you know him as Ronnie
Herman: The building says something else, but you know him as Ronnie

You know that deal when you don’t immediately recognize somebody’s real name? George Herman Ruth? Oh yeah, The Babe. Thomas Jonathan Jackson? Stonewall. Richard Starkey? Ringo. I kind of sort of had one of those moments this week while walking on West 11th Street across from the Travis County Courthouse. Bold letters on the bright and brand...
Commentary: When the Endangered Species Act arrived, species revived
Commentary: When the Endangered Species Act arrived, species revived

When humans arrived, species died. Homo sapiens in our geologically recent dispersal out of Africa have left paths of destruction across the planet, the one place in the universe we actually know life exists. Now, the Trump administration wants to roll back the Endangered Species Act (ESA), one of the cornerstones for the protection of this living...
More Stories