Editorial: Texas must do more to end suspensions of youngest students


Just two years ago, Austin schools issued 321 suspensions to the district’s youngest students, those in prekindergarten through second grade, sometimes over infractions as small as using rude language or leaving the classroom without permission. Those numbers included 288 out-of-school suspensions and 33 in-school suspensions.

This year, Austin had just eight out-of-school suspensions for that age group, and fewer than five in-school suspensions, according to preliminary Austin school district figures.

That’s a commendable improvement, thanks to changes in district policy and state law allowing suspensions of the youngest students only when a firearm, act of violence or substance abuse is involved.

However, as the American-Statesman’s Julie Chang recently reported, some Central Texas districts still suspend these students at concerning rates, continuing a disproven practice that disproportionately burdens boys, African-American and Hispanic students, and those with learning disabilities. Even in districts with falling suspension numbers, the job is far from done; the need for more counseling and mental health support in schools is undeniable.

RELATED: Central Texas suspensions of young students raise concerns

We urge the Legislature, which took an important first step last year in curbing the use of suspensions for the youngest students, to press the issue further next session. Lawmakers should empower the Texas Education Agency to hold districts accountable when they misuse their suspension tool. They should also create a central resource for training and supporting teachers who are dealing with difficult students in the classroom.

Studies have shown yanking kids out of class for disciplinary reasons doesn’t work. With lost class time, these students fall behind, leading to higher rates of academic failure and dropping out. The removal adds to students’ feelings of being ostracized and does nothing to address the underlying reasons they’re acting out. As we noted last year, when the Austin school district changed its policy, such suspensions often reflect misunderstood behaviors or missed opportunities to diagnose learning disabilities, untreated trauma or mental health issues.

EDITORIAL: Suspensions alone won’t solve behavior problems of young students

The law passed last year, championed by state Rep. Eric Johnson, D-Dallas, narrowly defines the offenses that can trigger a suspension for the state’s youngest students, but House Bill 674 provided no enforcement mechanism. So, the state had little recourse when the Killeen school district, which has only two-thirds as many students as the Austin school district, issued a whopping 571 suspensions this year for students in pre-K through second grade. That shocking figure not only suggests Killeen schools are not adhering to the law, but proves they are failing to help many of the youngest and neediest students in their care.

Children’s advocacy groups are also rightly concerned about the suspension rates for youngsters in the Round Rock and Pflugerville districts. Round Rock has half as many students as Austin but twice as many suspensions among the youngest students: 18. The Pflugerville district has a quarter of Austin’s enrollment but three times the number of suspensions: 26.

Lawmakers must add teeth to HB 674 by giving TEA the power to enforce it. When districts post high numbers of suspensions among the state’s youngest students, or dole out suspensions for reasons not allowed by law, the agency should be able to compel districts to develop and follow an action plan to reduce suspensions.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints tweets the latest insights and analyses on politics

More importantly, the Legislature should provide meaningful support for schools seeking to improve campus culture, a preventive approach that can neutralize an array of disciplinary and safety problems. The state already funds the Texas School Safety Center, housed at Texas State University, to provide research, training and expert support to districts across the state on campus safety matters. Lawmakers should follow that model in creating a center to provide similar support to districts on student mental health, behavioral issues and school climate.

The nonprofit Texans Care for Children called for such a center after a student opened fire in May at Santa Fe High School, killing 10 and injuring 13. That attack sparked a sense of urgency among state leaders to protect other schools from mass shootings. But we see common threads between that mission and efforts to transform school discipline. A 2004 report by the Secret Service and the U.S. Department of Education found the potential for school violence decreases on campuses where problems are addressed early, kids and adults alike are treated with respect and students feel a sense of connectedness to the school — all features, we note, of a school that makes the effort to help disruptive students instead of tossing them out on suspension.

ANALYSIS: Why security measures alone won’t stop school shootings

Austin largely eliminated its suspensions of its youngest students by creating temporary diversion programs within each school, providing individualized instruction and behavioral counseling for up to 15 days before those students return to their regular class. Other Austin ISD programs help all students develop empathy, manage their feelings and learn to resolve conflicts.

Still, there’s room for improvement: The Austin school district published a review last month in which several elementary principals said they need more staff to address behavioral issues, particularly with children reeling from traumatic experiences at home. We suspect other Texas districts face the same need.

All Texas students deserve the same opportunity to thrive in school, even as their needs call for an array of educational and behavioral interventions. It is up to lawmakers to ensure districts have the resources — and the motivation — to meet the needs of the youngest, most challenging students at school instead of sending them away.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Letters to the editor: July 16, 2018
Letters to the editor: July 16, 2018

I think we should have a city law — a state or national law would be even better — that says every business must have its address number posted where it is easily visible from the street. This is apparently already a requirement for residences, since they are usually easy to find. I am often frustrated in trying to find what block I am...
Opinion: What the cave boys teach us about abortion

Twelve boys and their adult coach trapped in a dank, oxygen-deprived cave in Thailand riveted the world’s attention for two weeks. Why, people ask at times like this, are we so focused on these individuals when half a million Rohingya refugee children are in danger of starving on the Bangladesh border, or when 400,000 Yemeni children are severely...
Opinion: Trump, tariffs, tofu and tax cuts

According to early indications, recent U.S. economic growth was full of beans. No, seriously. More than half of America’s soybean exports typically go to China, but Chinese tariffs will shift much of that demand to Brazil, and countries that normally get their soybeans from Brazil have raced to replace them with U.S. beans. The perverse result...
Herman: Sights and lessons in the Holy Land
Herman: Sights and lessons in the Holy Land

The wonderful thing about world travel is how it can open your eyes to how, despite the differences that make this world so troubled, there are some things that unite much of personkind. I recently enjoyed one of those wonderful moments during my first day in Jerusalem on my first trip to Israel. It came in the back seat of a cab as we headed back...
Facebook comments: July 15, 2018
Facebook comments: July 15, 2018

As reported by American-Statesman staff, Twitter users were quick to note Kay Bailey Hutchison’s seemingly uncomfortable reaction when President Donald Trump presented NATO leaders with a list of grievances during a meeting Wednesday. Hutchison is a former U.S. senator from Texas and is now serving as the U.S. ambassador to NATO. She was seated...
More Stories