Doggett: Ending the taxpayer subsidy for exorbitant executive bonuses


There is an outrage in our tax code and it’s costing you money.

Federal law currently gives publicly held corporations a special tax deduction when they pay their executives huge “performance-based” bonuses. The deduction can be worth millions of dollars. The more they shower their executives with such pay, the less publicly held corporations pay in federal taxes.

And when giant companies don’t pay their fair share, that tax burden is then shifted onto small businesses and working families.

Public outcry over huge pay packages and corporate tax dodging has nothing to do with envy. It’s based on an understanding that a top-heavy economy — where more and more money goes to the wealthiest 1 percent and less and less to the middle and bottom — is not only unfair, it’s unstable.

In 1978, when prosperity was still widely shared in America, an average CEO earned 29 times what an average worker did, according to the Economic Policy Institute. But over the past four decades, executive compensation skyrocketed by 875 percent, while the wages of an average worker crept forward by only 5.4 percent. By 2012, CEOs earned 273 times more than an average worker.

The staggering gap between extremely well-compensated executives and everyone else is bad enough – but our tax code makes the problem worse. Corporations can deduct from their taxes any amount paid to executives in salaries, bonuses and stock grants as long as it’s labeled “performance based.” Companies effectively get a giant tax break for paying their executives outlandishly.

The “performance” required is rarely Olympic caliber, and the bar can be always be lowered if it proves too high.

When JPMorgan Chase pays Jamie Dimon $20 million in a year that his bank paid billions in penalties for wrongdoing, “performance” may have a different meaning than most small-business owners assume when trying to grow their companies.

Excessive pay and other corporate tax avoidance often go hand in hand. In a recent study, Anthony Petrello of Nabors Industries topped the list of highest-paid executives, with pay totaling $68.2 million in 2013. Nabors renounced its American citizenship to avoid taxes in 2002, when it moved its place of incorporation to Bermuda, while keeping many of its corporate operations in Houston.

Wal-Mart is a good example of how this tax loophole has contributed to out-of-whack executive pay. Between 2009 and 2014, eight top executives were paid a total of $334 million, of which nearly $300 million — or 90 percent — was supposedly “performance” pay, according to a report by Americans for Tax Fairness and the Institute for Policy Studies. The taxpayer subsidy for Wal-Mart’s bonuses: more than $100 million.

Wal-Mart’s not alone. The total cost of subsidizing CEO super salaries at America’s biggest corporations over the next decade is $50 billion, according to the nonpartisan Joint Committee on Taxation.

That kind of pricey loophole has a lot of company in the corporate tax code. The U.S. House of Representatives may soon take up two expired tax breaks that make it easier for big corporations to ship jobs and hide profits offshore. They will cost taxpayers $80 billion over 10 years. Such loopholes allowed more than 100 of the nation’s biggest corporations to pay zero federal income tax in one of the past five years, a recent Citizens for Tax Justice study found.

This tax subsidy hurts working Americans in other ways too. The $50 billion cost of this loophole could pay for a lot of things — educating our kids, rebuilding roads and bridges, finding new cures for dread diseases.

Even in this divided Congress, there has been bipartisan acknowledgement that we must fix this problem. Chairman Dave Camp, my Republican colleague on the Ways and Means Committee, included a similar, though more limited, provision in his draft tax reform plan. When Senator Chuck Grassley was chairman of the Senate Finance Committee he acknowledged that this area of the tax code is “broken.”

My legislation to eliminate this loophole would put an end to unlimited tax write-offs on executive pay. It would make the $1 million tax-deduction cap real. There is similar legislation in the Senate. Corporations would still be free to shower their CEO’s with huge bonuses if they liked. They just couldn’t demand the rest of us help pay for it.

Rep. Lloyd Doggett (D-Austin) is a member of the tax-writing House Ways and Means Committee.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Commentary: When the Endangered Species Act arrived, species revived
Commentary: When the Endangered Species Act arrived, species revived

When humans arrived, species died. Homo sapiens in our geologically recent dispersal out of Africa have left paths of destruction across the planet, the one place in the universe we actually know life exists. Now, the Trump administration wants to roll back the Endangered Species Act (ESA), one of the cornerstones for the protection of this living...
Letters to the editor: Sept. 21, 2018

One intriguing aspect of “all politicians lie” is no politician ever disputes the claim. Politicians welcome the phrase as normal behavior in society. Once accepted, politicians are free from the burden of telling the truth. A trial defendant caught in a lie will be convicted. An applicant who lies during a job interview will not be hired...
Editorial: Take time to vet Kavanaugh allegation, run proper hearing
Editorial: Take time to vet Kavanaugh allegation, run proper hearing

The stakes couldn’t be higher. The next justice to be sworn onto the U.S. Supreme Court will likely serve for decades, providing a pivotal fifth vote on a nine-member court that has been narrowly divided on critical issues. The Affordable Care Act. Marriage equality. Protections for immigrants and visitors from Muslim-majority countries. Regulations...
Facebook comments: Sept. 21, 2018
Facebook comments: Sept. 21, 2018

As reported by the American-Statesman’s Mary Huber, 13 neighborhoods are starting to gentrify or see longtime residents displaced by rising property values, according to a new University of Texas study. Touted by researchers as one of the first steps toward solving the city’s affordability problem, the study looked at areas with large proportions...
Opinion: The late hit on Judge Kavanaugh

Upon the memory and truthfulness of Christine Blasey Ford hangs the Supreme Court nomination of Judge Brett Kavanaugh, his reputation, and possibly his career on the nation’s second highest court. And much more. If Kavanaugh is voted down or forced to withdraw, the Republican Party and conservative movement could lose their last best hope for...
More Stories