Commentary: Why Bobby Moore should not be on Texas’ death row

A man with intellectual disability – Bobby Moore – sits on death row at the Polunsky Unit in Livingston. Like every person on death row in Texas, Moore is in constant solitary confinement – about 23 hours per day, seven days a week, 365 days a year. For people with intellectual disability, solitary confinement is especially agonizing, cruel and intolerable.

It is against the law to execute people with intellectual disability in Texas and throughout the country. Everyone, including the Harris County district attorney’s office, agrees that Moore has intellectual disability, and that his death sentence should be commuted to life in prison to get him off death row — where he does not belong, since he cannot be executed—and out of solitary confinement.

COMMENTARY: Texas execution denies human rights.

Our organizations —The Arc of the United States and The Arc of Texas — promote and protect the civil and human rights of people with intellectual and developmental disabilities in all aspects of life, including the criminal justice system. The Arc has long advocated for capital defendants with intellectual disability to ensure their disability is properly diagnosed and considered in sentencing and that they receive appropriate accommodations while incarcerated. Research shows that for people with intellectual disability, being held in solitary confinement is particularly damaging and destructive. The fact that Moore continues to be held in such conditions is an urgent problem.

There is no longer any real dispute that Moore has intellectual disability. The Texas district court that first considered his claim said he has intellectual disability — and in ruling for him earlier this year, the U.S. Supreme Court emphasized the powerful evidence showing Moore’s disability.

Earlier this month, The Arc of the United States and The Arc of Texas joined a broad range of prominent entities and individuals with diverse perspectives and views on the death penalty, who filed briefs urging the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to grant relief for Moore. The Harris County district attorney’s office – which prosecuted Moore and obtained the death sentence against him – has now agreed that, in light of the Supreme Court’s decision and the record in this case, Moore cannot be executed because he has intellectual disability.

COMMENTARY: Why consular rights were not an issue in death row case.

Everybody in the case now agrees that Moore has intellectual disability and he cannot be executed. The prosecutors, defense lawyers, faith leaders and religious organizations, medical and intellectual disability associations, prominent Texans across the spectrum (including conservatives, moderates, and death-penalty supporters), leading lawyers, civil rights groups and many others all agree that there is nothing left to decide — and no real controversy to resolve. All that is left is for the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to issue a judgment making it official that, as established by the Supreme Court decision and the record that the Supreme Court reviewed, Moore has intellectual disability and may not be executed.

We hope that the Court of Criminal Appeals issues that judgment promptly. There is no reason to delay the resolution of Moore’s case. Every day of additional time on death row means another day of unnecessary and excruciating pain from solitary confinement. People with intellectual disability who are in prison are often punished for not complying with prison rules they don’t understand or cannot remember; the sensory deprivation and isolation of solitary confinement can be particularly overwhelming. It is, thus, imperative that Moore not only be released from solitary confinement, but also undergo a thorough assessment to evaluate his capacity for general prison life to determine the most appropriate placement for him.

It is often said that justice delayed is justice denied. The Court of Criminal Appeals should not wait a moment longer than necessary to issue its judgment. Bobby Moore should be moved from death row immediately. In taking that action now, the Court of Criminal Appeals would be serving justice and ending the needless infliction of harm on Moore.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.

Berns is chief executive officer of The Arc of the United States. Martinez is the chief executive officer of The Arc of Texas.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Letters to the editor: May 26, 2018
Letters to the editor: May 26, 2018

When Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick said we live in “a violent culture where we devalue life,” he neglected to take responsibility for his role in dehumanizing his fellow Texans. He obsessively promoted the bathroom bill, which unnecessarily violated the privacy of schoolchildren. He fights to destroy public education, a building block of our democracy...
Commentary: How Texas can keep drivers of electric cars plugged-in
Commentary: How Texas can keep drivers of electric cars plugged-in

Today, the average Texas commuter drives more than 14,600 miles per year. With more than 28 million people calling the Lone Star State home and more than 24 million registered vehicles on the road, this adds up to a significant amount of harmful tailpipe emissions that threaten our health and our economy. As more vehicles are registered in Texas and...
Editorial: After ‘poverty pimps’ flap, Austin ISD must focus on kids
Editorial: After ‘poverty pimps’ flap, Austin ISD must focus on kids

We by no means excuse the words former Austin Independent School Board President Kendall Pace used in a private text to a fellow board member. Her language was uncouth and unprofessional. The fallout cost Pace her position on the board as those she offended along with political foes turned up the political heat. Pace’s judgment in making derogatory...
Commentary: Austin’s plastic bag ban is rubbish. Go check the landfill
Commentary: Austin’s plastic bag ban is rubbish. Go check the landfill

As the Texas Supreme Court will soon make its decision regarding the legality of plastic bag regulations in Texas, this is a good time to revisit the arguments used to promote plastic bag bans. A review of the data shows that plastic bag regulations don’t reduce litter overall — and, in fact, they incentivize products that have far greater...
Opinion: How Trump gets into your bed

It’s not every day we start our discussion of current events with the president’s sex life. Well, actually, it’s gotten to be pretty frequent. But today we’re going to talk less about what Donald Trump does in bed and more about his efforts to interfere with other people’s intimate affairs. “When I ran for office...
More Stories