Commentary: When does life begin? Thoughts from a pro-choice pastor


The pro-life movement is clear about when the life of a fetus begins — but what seems to lurk beneath the surface is a notion that pregnant women are no longer fully human or fully free. Anti-abortion advocates insist that once a woman conceives, regardless of the circumstances, she must choose motherhood — over her physical and emotional wellbeing, over her vocation, even if it means living in poverty. Even if it kills her.

During this year’s legislative session, the Texas Legislature passed a law banning the most common and very safe abortion procedure used during the second trimester, known as “dilation and evacuation.” Only 11 percent of abortions occur after the first trimester — but since they are more likely to be situations where the mother’s life is threatened, this ban directly endangers women who may already be at risk. The law is under appeal.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.

Being a white, educated, middle-class woman has shielded me as devastating anti-abortion laws have shut down women’s health clinics across the state – today, 95 percent of the state’s counties do not have an abortion provider. But this newest law may directly affect me; my husband and I are considering having a second child, but at nearly 40, I am at a risky “advanced maternal age.” Heaven forbid I encounter complications, some politicians might prefer I die than terminate a pregnancy.

For low-income women and women of color, the prognosis is even more grim. The Centers for Disease Control reports that black women are three to four times more likely to die from pregnancy-related causes than white women. Texas has the highest maternal mortality rate in the “developed” world, according to a report in the journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology.

These latest developments in Texas have reinforced the astonishing barriers American women face in determining their own reproductive freedom. Since the start of 2017, state legislatures across the country have already passed more than 50 abortion restrictions, including waiting periods and mandatory counseling designed to dissuade women from having an abortion. West Virginia and Mississippi have already banned the dilation and evacuation procedure, and similar bans are pending in Arkansas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, Kansas, and Alabama against heavy legal opposition.

As a former Southern Baptist, I know firsthand what it means to be devoutly pro-life, though experience has taught me that abortion is a much more complex issue than often portrayed. The basic limitation of the anti-abortion movement is that it attempts to confront the moral complexity of real life with a rigidly simple set of commandments. I can sympathize with this approach; it is a survival instinct. But it threatens our capacity to experience the abundant life that Jesus promised by holding women’s lives captive to the dictates of public officials.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.

Parenthood inevitably involves sacrifices. But isn’t there a qualitative difference between sacrifices freely made and those legislated for us? Do we really expect women to sacrifice their lives to bear children? When does a mother’s right to life begin? When does her personhood start?

I am not trying to convince anyone to terminate a pregnancy. I am saying that women’s lives matter to God and to their families, and they ought to matter to politicians. As long as we only define life as the protection of a fetus, we have dangerously oversimplified the issue. Only when we can affirm that a mother’s life need not end for a child’s life to begin can we truly call ourselves “pro-life.”

Fulbright is founder and director of Labyrinth Progressive Student Ministry at the University of Texas.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: GOP moderates fold to Trumpism

WASHINGTON — “Moderate Republicans are the people who are there when you don’t need them.” It was one of former Rep. Barney Frank’s many devastating zingers, and it certainly applies to the fiasco unfolding in the House of Representatives on immigration. A headline last week on Roll Call’s website might have been...
Opinion: Trump and the invasion of the West

“It is cruel. It is immoral. And it breaks my heart,” says former first lady Laura Bush of the Trump administration policy of “zero tolerance,” under which the children of illegal migrants are being detained apart from their parents. “We need to be … a country that governs with a heart,” says first lady Melania...
America the beautiful, now America the ugly
America the beautiful, now America the ugly

  MCALLEN, TX – JUNE 12: U.S. Border Patrol agents ask a group of Central American asylum seekers to remove hair bands and weddding rings before taking them into custody on June 12, 2018 near McAllen, Texas. The immigrant families were then sent to a U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) processing center...
Letters to the editor: June 21, 2018
Letters to the editor: June 21, 2018

Re: June 16 article, “Owner’s plan for Lake Austin site: elevator tower, restaurant, marina.” The proposal by the developer is vastly inferior to the 1986 approved plan for the property that included up to 64 single family homes. The developer is wanting a change that will create a commercial and residential development that will...
Commentary: Austin ISD prefers to see us appease parents than teach
Commentary: Austin ISD prefers to see us appease parents than teach

Austin ISD has adopted an “improved” approach to working with families. In this customer-service model — called AISD Cares — educators will prioritize parent requests regardless of professional judgment. This new focus shifts attention away from student needs to submit to the public. In an age when students are at greater risk...
More Stories