Commentary: When it comes to race, America is an unfinished project


On a recent Easter weekend, lonely in a hotel room and far from a church, I found myself searching YouTube for hymns I remembered from my boyhood. I came across a video of President Obama singing “Amazing Grace” at the funeral of one of the victims of the church massacre in Charleston, S.C.

The sincerity of his gesture led me to sob even more deeply than I had in 2015. For as he sang, I thought about how many killings since then had worked to drive those nine awful murders from our thoughts.

More than anything, President Obama’s eulogy for the Rev. Clementa Pinckney reminded me how very far we seem from grace today. It reminded me that as we hope to see America live up to its great promise — and as we work to make that happen — we struggle with a hatred we cannot seem to shake.

VIEWPOINTS: Impact on community was clear. Austin bombings were acts of terror.

The Austin bomber could have left his murderous packages anywhere, but he first targeted a part of the city home to many people of color. It is hard to see this as an accident. We can parse his motives 100 ways — but in the end, what matters are the people he killed and injured, and the families and community he harmed.

What matters also is the inadequate police response to the murder of his first victim, a family man who did nothing to deserve his fate.

Like so many white Americans, I have been reluctant to acknowledge the profound disregard we have for each other in this country. I told myself that this was the land of opportunity, and that hard work would eventually be rewarded no matter one’s race or ethnicity.

Like a lot of white Americans, I have been reluctant to talk about racism, hoping that if we just take people as they come, everything will work out.

ALBERTA PHILLIPS: Election imperils seat for Austin blacks in Legislature.

So many of us don’t want to think of ourselves as bad people; yet, there are wrongs done to others every day that we bear responsibility for. Sociology has fancy terms to describe this, but perhaps it is enough to say the following: It is not necessary to be bad in order for bad things to happen in our name.

For instance, I have never met an Austin police officer that hasn’t been courteous and professional with me. So, when reading the news, it is hard for me to explain how an unarmed African-American man can be chased down and shot in the back of the neck without having committed a crime. Yes, I might not run when an officer orders me to halt — but I would feel comfortable obeying such a command precisely because people in my shoes aren’t so regularly harmed by police officers.

It is often said that America is an unfinished project. I believe that to be true — and I think we have a special burden to come to grips with the sins of our past.

My colleague Ted Gordon recently pressed Austin’s school board to change the names of schools commemorating Confederate soldiers. He ruffled some feathers — but I am glad he persisted. Symbols are important, and our values are reflected in what we call things.

EDITORIAL BOARD: Why Austin ISD is reviewing 62 schools named since 1960s.

The removal of Confederate monuments and plaques is a good beginning. While it is possible to miss the artistry of those bronze statues, perhaps the empty pedestals will prompt reflection and conversation about how much is left to do.

For we need to do a great deal more to make America fairer for all. Where should we start? I have three suggestions:

• First, we need to support our system of public education in this city, state and nation — from pre-kindergarten through community colleges and the research universities. Public education is the gateway to a better life for many, and needs all the resources we can afford. Strong schools help lead to a stronger society.

• Next, we need to insist that public safety not come at the expense of civil rights. Our police officers have a hard and stressful job, certainly, and most are extremely competent at what they do. At the same time, however, they are carrying deadly weapons. We have an obligation to demand oversight of and accountability for their actions. There is no room for police brutality in America.

JUAN CASTILLO: Bloated water bills. Secret hiring. This isn’t ‘fake’ news.

• Finally, we need to support journalism, both in this newspaper and across all other forms of media. Good reporters are a society’s eyes, ears and conscience. Our journalists need the freedom to follow stories of importance, no matter how difficult or painful the truths they uncover.

The words of the beautiful hymn that our president sang nearly three years ago point out that we have already come through many dangers, toils and snares. The song also promises that “grace will lead us home.” I believe in my heart that we will need grace to get us safely to where we are going.

But grace alone will not be enough. We will need to work hard — and together — to have an America whose amazing potential is available to all.

Bruster is a professor of English at the University of Texas.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Our rules of the game — U.S. Constitution

Justice Anthony Kennedy’s retirement, leading to President Donald Trump’s nomination of Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court, has thrown progressives, the Democratic Party and the news media into an out-and-out tizzy. The online magazine Slate declared, “Anthony Kennedy Just Destroyed His Legacy as a Gay Rights Hero.” The New...
Opinion: Trump composes an elaborate “Thank you, Putin” note
Opinion: Trump composes an elaborate “Thank you, Putin” note

In the run-up to the Trump-Putin summit, many wondered how the Mueller investigation’s latest indictment would impact the outcome. After all, the language of the indictment was very specific and very detailed. Russian intelligence officers were mentioned by name. More to the point, the indictment revealed that Russian hackers were inside the...
Facebook comments: July 17, 2018
Facebook comments: July 17, 2018

As reported by the American-Statesman’s Dave Thomas, a new Make America Great Again hat signed by Donald Trump was sent to the teenager whose hat was taken from him at a San Antonio Whataburger. Hunter Richard, an Orlando teenager, was wearing his hat in a San Antonio Whataburger when a man threw a drink in his face and took his hat. The incident...
Letters to the editor: July 17, 2018
Letters to the editor: July 17, 2018

Re: July 8 commentary, “If Texas won’t give sick leave, at least let Austin do it.” If paid sick leave was really about protecting income of workers, that would be one thing. Instead, the ordinance is about providing anyone who works, whether full- or part-time, paid time off. Should a small business be required to pay a part-time...
Opinion: After Kavanaugh, the deluge

In the second year of his presidency, Donald Trump has become more and more willing to act Trumpishly rather than deferring to the official wisdom of his party. But with his second Supreme Court nomination, notwithstanding all the head-fakes and reality-television atmospherics, Trump has demonstrated that he’ll take his Trumpishness only so far...
More Stories