Commentary: Universities, not FBI, should clean up college basketball

The “dark underbelly of college basketball” has now been exposed. For years, the limelight of March Madness has thrilled millions of college basketball fans. Yet, a history of shady recruiting practices and the exploitation of young men who dream of playing in the NBA has remained in the shadows.

Recently, the FBI and Joon Kim, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, dropped a bombshell on college basketball by filing criminal complaints against coaches, agents, financial advisors and even a shoe-company executive — in short, targeting all those who seek to make money off of teenage basketball stars.

SPORTS: Blockbuster arrests not shocking to college hoops followers.

To date, no Texas university has been directly implicated; Oklahoma State is the closest university to the state embroiled in the scandal. Yet, the reverberations from this case will affect every major college basketball program in Texas.

The federal investigation exposed a systematic bribery scheme to pay families and coaches to steer players toward certain schools, companies and agents.

And while college sports are accustomed to NCAA charges of recruiting violations, impermissible benefits and lack of institutional control, this time the FBI called the inappropriate recruiting practices what they are: corruption and bribery.

To suggest that this case represents just the tip of the iceberg is insulting to icebergs.

We are only at the beginning of this story, but it is already clear that this is the largest college sports scandal in our lifetime.

The NCAA and universities have complained that because they do not have subpoena power, there was only so much they could do to eliminate wrongdoing. The Justice Department and FBI will use the full extent of their powers to root out many of the problems in college basketball.

Undoubtedly, more charges are coming and many more universities will be implicated by what the FBI finds. As FBI Assistant Director William Sweeney Jr. ominously warned during a press conference announcing the charges: “We have your playbook. Our investigation is ongoing and we are conducting additional interviews as we speak.”

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Viewpoints page brings the latest commentaries to your feed.

The tentacles of this investigation will — and should — fundamentally change the nature of college basketball.

But while the FBI will identify criminal wrongdoing, it’s the universities themselves that need to begin the hard work of repairing the sport.

As a researcher of higher education and an observer of college athletics for nearly two decades, I propose three steps for fixing college basketball:

• End the practice of “one and done.” The idea that a player can attend one year of college basketball and then jump to the NBA makes a sham of the student-athlete ideal. In fact, the possibility of a quick NBA payoff was at the heart of many of the criminal charges in this case. We do not allow this practice in college football or baseball, and we should not allow it in basketball either.

• Hold athletics directors accountable — and fire them if necessary — when improper recruiting practices occur at their institutions. Too often, coaches and athletics directors magically retain plausible deniability. This must end. Moreover, if athletics directors know they may be fired, they may think twice before hiring a coach or assistant coach with a history of breaking the rules.

• Blow up the current system of recruiting. The byzantine NCAA recruiting rules and policies no longer work; the time for an entirely new system has come. In creating it, current and former players should be heavily involved because they alone — not any coach, athletics director or university president — understand the flaws of the current system and the demands placed on these young players.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.

No one university or even the NCAA can create enough rules and policies to avoid outright illegal activity. We can only hope that the watchful eye of law enforcement helps control the darkest elements of intercollegiate athletics.

However, universities need to take the lead in cleaning up this issue. The FBI has done universities a huge favor by bringing these sleazy practices to light. Now, universities must immediately begin reforms to make sure the system is changed for good.

Harris is an associate professor at Southern Methodist University. This commentary was published by TribTalk.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Bomber is dead, but case not over with many questions that linger
Bomber is dead, but case not over with many questions that linger

Central Texans are exhaling a collective sigh of relief at the news that suspected serial bomber Mark A. Conditt is dead. For much of March, the 23-year-old Pflugerville resident held the city captive as it held its breath awaiting the next explosion. In all, five bombs detonated, not counting the one he turned on himself early Wednesday morning. Add...
Young: This week on: ‘(U.S.) House Makeover’
Young: This week on: ‘(U.S.) House Makeover’

The Republican Party just spent $10 million on one congressional election in Pennsylvania and reaped nothing but agony. What it spent amounted to $100 per vote cast for the loser (Donald Trump). You might claim that the loser in Pennsylvania’s congressional District 18 was Rick Saccone, who lost to Democrat Conor Lamb. That’s true technically...
INSIGHT: Tariffs won’t save U.S. jobs — but we can help steelworkers
INSIGHT: Tariffs won’t save U.S. jobs — but we can help steelworkers

President Donald Trump has been promising to save American manufacturing, and the steel industry in particular, since the presidential campaign. His attempt to follow through on that promise was the March 8 tariff increase on foreign steel and aluminum, arguing that the tariffs were necessary to protect U.S. industries and workers. Trump joins a long...
Commentary: Major League Soccer is ready for Austin — and so are we
Commentary: Major League Soccer is ready for Austin — and so are we

Austin is at the precipice of bringing its first professional sports franchise to our city. The City Council debate and scheduled vote today that would direct a detailed city staff review of the McKalla Place site for a potential soccer/mixed-use community stadium is a milestone for our city. We in the Major League Soccer in Austin Supporters Group...
Letters to the editor: March 22, 2018
Letters to the editor: March 22, 2018

I live in Austin, and so do many of my family and friends. While we are terrified by the recent bombings, we are reassured by the many local, state and federal agents that are working 24/7 to track down the perpetrator of these heinous crimes. There are currently over 500 agents working on this case, including 350 from the F.B.I. These are career civil...
More Stories