Commentary: Setting the record straight on value of palliative care


In a recent CNN debate about health care, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz claimed people confronted with life-threatening diseases who receive palliative care services were “essentially doped up with some drugs” and told “well, now is your time to go.”

We find these statements absurdly misrepresentative of the goals of palliative care.

If Cruz has his way, caring for people with life-threatening illness or at the end of life may become much more difficult. Cruz’s comments seem to reflect a basic ignorance of medical ethics and evidence-based outcomes. His insistence that unrestrained access to high-cost medical interventions is somehow equated to “better health care” is simply unsupported with regard to outcomes.

Just because we can do everything does not mean that we should do everything — and in the medically fragile population, these heroic interventions can cause more suffering with no clear long-term benefit.

Palliative care is an interdisciplinary medical specialty focused on supporting patients and families through serious, life-threatening illnesses. Palliative care helps patients live as well as they can for as long as they can. The focus is not on death, but on life. In fact, a study in 2010 found that early palliative care not only improved quality of life but also extended length of life.

Palliative care teams work with children with complex medical needs and their families. They focus on reducing pain and other uncomfortable symptoms, understanding the family’s goals for their child, facilitating conversations between the family and the medical team, and supporting the family’s social and spiritual needs.

The palliative care population is incredibly fragile and vulnerable — and it requires a holistic model of care that focuses not just on illness but on the entire family.

For example, Corinne Weildler, a beautiful 3-year-old from Austin, is currently receiving palliative care. When she was a year old, she was diagnosed with atypical teratoid rhabdoid tumor of the brain, a rare and fast-growing cancer that is difficult to treat. Soon after, Corinne’s family met with a palliative care team. We all talked through the treatment options and how to best support and maintain Corinne’s quality of life while she went through months of chemo, radiation and surgery.

For her and Corinne’s family, palliative care acts as an additional layer of support — a team to collaborate with about how to manage symptoms, improve communication between all of the child’s doctors, and to sit quietly with during the hardest moments. Despite 13 surgeries and more than 40 rounds of radiation and chemo, Corinne has maintained a good quality of life.

The Concurrent Care for Children Requirement of the Affordable Care Act makes palliative care and hospice services more accessible to children who wish to continue receiving potentially life-sustaining treatment for their underlying illnesses. Hospice, similar to palliative care, focuses on reducing burdensome symptoms and improving quality of life for patients and their families.

For many years, children had to choose to decline curative treatments to receive beneficial hospice services. Clearly, many families opted to continue chemotherapy or radiation, vital medications, physical and speech therapy, and home nursing support, while losing the chance to engage with their local hospice team. With this provision of the ACA, children are able to continue to receive all treatments associated with their illness while also accessing comprehensive hospice services.

By making irresponsible statements and by working to repeal the ACA, Cruz and many of his colleagues would eliminate this vital benefit that can help tens of thousands of children live better and fuller lives. The fact is the ACA includes a number of important life-saving measures — and lawmakers must keep in mind how this affects the most vulnerable of populations.

Lawmakers should be fighting to keep the Concurrent Care for Children provision of the ACA so that providers can continue to offer children and families the best possible options for increased quality of life.

And if Cruz and his colleagues continue to put politics ahead of compassion, common sense and children’s health, voters should tell them it’s their “time to go” directly out of office.

Jones is a professor and associate dean for health affairs in the School of Social Work at the University of Texas. Carnahan-Metzger is a pediatric palliative care social worker.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Why Austin isn’t getting as much affordable housing money as you might think

Facing an urgent need to fund more affordable housing in Austin, the City Council set its sights on some tax dollars it figured no one would miss. New tax dollars. Specifically, the shiny new tax revenue that materializes when government-owned land, which doesn’t pay property taxes, becomes private housing, commercial...
Commentary: The danger behind North Korea’s jiu jitsu diplomacy
Commentary: The danger behind North Korea’s jiu jitsu diplomacy

After months of frantic brinkmanship with North Korea, President Donald Trump is now preparing for a summit meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un. This would be comical if it wasn’t so dangerous. He has played right into North Korea’s hands. Trump no doubt thinks that his tough rhetoric has struck fear into the heart of the North...
Letters to the editor: April 25, 2018
Letters to the editor: April 25, 2018

Every time I endeavor to enter MoPac Boulevard at Enfield Road going south during the afternoon-evening rush “hour,” I feel screwed yet again. The backup of traffic from downtown at the southbound Winsted Lane entry ramp causes at least a 15- to 25-minute wait to enter the horribly backed-up freeway. In the meantime, those few drivers who...
Commentary: Asphalt is the last crop
Commentary: Asphalt is the last crop

Missed in the coverage of the recent release of the 2018 Farm Bill is an obscure program that will significantly impact the future of Texas. It is not a commodity program nor does it deal with nutrition assistance. It is smaller in scope and cost than those programs, yet is just as far-reaching. The Agricultural Conservation Easement Program (ACEP)...
President Bill Clinton coming to Bass Concert Hall on June 10
President Bill Clinton coming to Bass Concert Hall on June 10

Bass Concert Hall will host “A Conversation with President Bill Clinton” at 7:30 p.m. June 10. Clinton will discuss “The President is Missing,” his new novel co-authored with bestselling writer James Patterson. This is the first time a president has collaborated with a bestselling novelist on a work of fiction.  Tickets...
More Stories