Commentary: Kids suffer worldwide. So, why are the Thai boys special?


Even while the world watches with attention and interest as the Thai soccer team is rescued from a cave, many people wonder why a similar focus is not placed on other suffering children in refugee camps and war zones around the world. It may feel as if the media and public ignore the plight of millions of children to focus on the Thai story.

In this country, in the Middle East, in Africa, it’s not hard to find terrible stories of abused, suffering, and neglected refugee children. What’s the difference? Why do we follow the story of the Thai soccer team — but not stories coming out of refugee camps and wars?

As a professor of persuasion and communication, I have observed with some interest the Thai cave rescue and can offer one answer. It is important to pay attention to rhetoric, to the dimensions of storytelling that make the Thai story different from others. A rhetorical analysis not only explains what is unique about the Thai story but sheds light on how the media and persuasion work.

Related: Who are the boys, their coach; timeline of the rescue.

• The Thai story is not politically charged, nor risky, as would be a story about Syrian kids trying to get into Austria, or Central Americans trying to get into the U.S. Human interest stories are more likely to get attention when we are not distracted by politics. In the U. S., people on the left and right, and President Trump, have all united in expressing concern.

• The Thai event is neatly bound in time and space and thus manageable from a story point of view — and it has been moving toward a definite conclusion — good or bad — unlike the endless grief of refugees elsewhere. A nice, clear story makes good media coverage — and that’s what we have here.

• There is international feel-good story material from the start, as people from all over the world gather round to help. In a sense, a little U.N. is cooperating outside that cave. In a world that seems to be constantly at odds with itself, to see so many nations contribute help is heartening.

How to send a letter to the editor: Click this link to send us your thoughts.

• It appeals to a sense of technological creativity and MacGyverosity, which is attractive in our day and age. We are often reminded that the situation is unique, and that solutions must be devised as they go along. Even Elon Musk has gotten into the act, instructing his engineers to build a boy sized submarine.

• The Thai story features very specific examples of highly photogenic kids, which appeals much more than any description of mass suffering. You can talk all you want to about children suffering on this and that border; that can’t compete with photos of 12 actual boys. The drama is run through with specifics that provide points of identification: the boys want fried chicken; they want fried rice with basil; they want teachers to take it easy on them with the homework; they have specific messages for their families.

Be the first to know: When big news breaks, we send emails. Click here to sign up.

Yes, I wish we could and would focus on the wider and larger issues of all these refugee children. But there are reasons rooted in principles of rhetoric, persuasion, and narrative that account for why the Thai boys dominate the news. And the reasons why tell us about what attracts our attention and interest in general: in world events, in politics, in local news.

Brummett is the Charles Sapp Centennial Professor in the Moody College of Communication at the University of Texas.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Letters to the editor: Sept. 20, 2018
Letters to the editor: Sept. 20, 2018

Re: Sept. 16 commentary, “Both-sideism presents more than journalistic problem.” Leonard Pitts raises an important structural issue in journalism related to fairness. Some would have us believe that ethical and moral considerations exist as mathematical equations. This inevitably leads to false equivalencies in which cultural values are...
Editorial: Hard liquor ban is first step in safer Greek life culture
Editorial: Hard liquor ban is first step in safer Greek life culture

Removing hard liquor from University of Texas fraternity houses and events is an important first step. But, the Greek organizations, university leaders and lawmakers looking to prevent drinking-related deaths and other tragedies, as well as dangerous hazing incidents, also need to add some things to the equation: Greater public transparency on whether...
Editorial: Hard liquor ban is first step in safer Greek life culture
Editorial: Hard liquor ban is first step in safer Greek life culture

Removing hard liquor from University of Texas fraternity houses and events is an important first step. But, the Greek organizations, university leaders and lawmakers looking to prevent drinking-related deaths and other tragedies, as well as dangerous hazing incidents, also need to add some things to the equation: Greater public transparency on whether...
Opinion: Three big lessons we didn’t learn from economic crisis

Ten years ago, after making piles of money gambling with other people’s money, Wall Street nearly imploded, and the outgoing George W. Bush and incoming Obama administrations bailed out the bankers. America should have learned three big lessons from the crisis. We didn’t, to our continuing peril. First unlearned lesson: Banking is a risky...
Young: If Pence will take a polygraph test, let’s ask these questions
Young: If Pence will take a polygraph test, let’s ask these questions

Mike Pence has offered to take a polygraph. Quick. Rush a device to his side. No – there’s no chance whatsoever he’s the senior official who wrote the anonymous New York Times commentary that branded his boss petty, amoral and consistently acting in ways “detrimental to the health of this republic.” Why do we know the...
More Stories