Commentary: Keep Texas economy strong by updating — not replacing — NAFTA


You may have heard the adage, “As Texas goes, so goes the nation.”

It often refers to the state’s ability to set the national agenda thanks to our size, unique way of doing business and bold politics. However, this saying might now serve as a cautionary tale as our nation’s leaders test the important relationship we share with Mexico.

In recent months, harsh rhetoric in Washington, D.C., has painted Mexico as a competitor rather than an ally — a trade foe rather than a partner. These characterizations are wrong and threaten Texas and national interests.

GUEST COMMENTARY: Without globalization, adios ‘Texas miracle.’

The financial ties that connect us with Mexico are symbiotic, not parasitic. After all, Mexico is Texas’ top trading partner with about $173 billion in trade a year. Additionally, trade with Mexico supports about 463,000 jobs and thousands of small businesses and manufacturers in Texas.

We not only sell to each other, we build things together. Roughly 40 percent of all goods imported from Mexico consist of parts that originated in the United States. By comparison, only 4 percent of products imported from China have U.S. origin.

Studies show that when U.S. companies grow their workforce in Mexico, they also grow their American workforce, increase their exports and spend more domestically on research and development. For those of us who live, work and do business along the U.S.-Mexico border, we see these benefits firsthand.

These realities are often lost in less-nuanced political rhetoric. Short-term thinking on U.S.-Mexico relations will lead to long-term negative consequences for American workers and businesses. The recent pivoting on the North America Free Trade Agreement by President Donald Trump exemplifies the importance of our economic relationship with Mexico.

While Trump has called NAFTA the worst trade deal in history, we must acknowledge the benefits it has brought to states like Texas and the nation as a whole. NAFTA supports 5 million jobs across the U.S. — and by one economist’s estimate, it enriches the U.S. by $127 billion anually. Texas’ exports to Mexico have grown by 354 percent since NAFTA, far outpacing export growth in other states and the nation as a whole. Texas also enjoys a $12 billion trade surplus with Mexico.

VIEWPOINTS: The Statesman’s editorial writers and columnists tackle local and national issues.

There are certainly ways in which NAFTA could be updated — the original agreement predated much of the technological advances of the last quarter century — but this should be done in the spirit of cooperation, not antagonism. In fact, if we focus on the growing energy and technology markets as a region, we could become stronger competitors in the global economy.

The administration’s latest signaling not to terminate NAFTA is a move in the right direction and an opportunity for business and elected leaders in Texas. Our state sees the benefits of collaborating with our southern neighbor by building regional supply chains and innovating together to compete globally. We can shape the national agenda once again by influencing the outcomes of an updated trade agreement and how we define our economic relationship with Mexico.

Barela is chief executive officer of the Borderplex Alliance, a binational economic development agency promoting the economic growth of El Paso, Ciudad Juarez and Southern New Mexico.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Commentary: The lessons learned from CodeNext’s death
Commentary: The lessons learned from CodeNext’s death

CodeNext may be dead, but it should not rest in peace. There is much to be learned from the failed CodeNext process. First, let’s acknowledge that CodeNext got some things right. The process started with a strong critique of the current development code, which is a mess. Austin’s development process is unpredictable and wasteful. It benefits...
Letters to the editor: Aug. 19, 2018
Letters to the editor: Aug. 19, 2018

Thanks, and congratulations, to retired admiral William H. McRaven and the other National Security officials who have spoken out about the decisions being made by the current administration. They, along with some journalists, business leaders, and a few members of Congress, are finally calling to task the current president for decisions that are destroying...
Facebook comments: Aug. 19, 2018
Facebook comments: Aug. 19, 2018

The Austin American-Statesman was among the hundreds of newspapers across the country to publish editorials on Thursday defending the freedom of the press in light of President Trump’s labeling of stories he doesn’t like as “fake news,” and his branding of journalists as “the enemy of the people.” The editorial board...
Six more Asian stories that Hollywood should turn into movies
Six more Asian stories that Hollywood should turn into movies

We hear the expression “representation matters” all the time, and it’s still worth repeating. As a Korean-American, I grew up yearning to see actors who looked like me. On the rare occasions I saw an Asian celebrity, I adored them unflaggingly. Still, I can count those figures on one hand: champion figure skater Kristi Yamaguchi,...
Irish comic’s memoir offers insight on moving to, working in US
Irish comic’s memoir offers insight on moving to, working in US

Irish comic and writer Maeve Higgins gathers essays about her experiences living and working in the United States in “Maeve in America: Essays by a Girl From Somewhere Else.” In this sharp and readable book, Higgins tells the story of how she came to America as an adult still learning how to go about “the endlessly tricky business...
More Stories