Commentary: How would the U.S. secure time and money to arm teachers?


It feels as though we live in an upside-down world where extremism rips apart all traces of sanity and balance. Can we even fathom a notion of working together to solve school shootings? Without a togetherness goal, can we even survive, much less flourish?

No one expects fully armed military personnel to sit in a circle to teach language fundamentals to prekindergarten children. Equally bizarre would be an expectation for teachers to be armed and ready to perform as soldiers. No one doubts the challenges faced by our military.

VIEWPOINTS: Listen, America. Our children have something to say about guns.

No one should doubt the daunting — although totally different — challenges of teaching children and teens. I suggest that we set aside the lunacy of assuming one another’s roles. Please consider:

• Teachers teach. Tax accountants balance numbers. Police and military maintain safety. Life works best when each of us accomplishes what we came here to do.

• Every time society dumps another task in the laps of teachers, their stamina for serving children takes a hit. Add lack of respect and less-than-adequate salaries to an unrealistic job expectation, and we wonder why anyone stays in the classroom. Now, we deliberate adding concealed carry to teachers’ job expectations?

COMMENTARY: Why Texas classrooms aren’t silent about Florida attack.

• Instead of spending resources to get teachers gun-ready, imagine targeting issues that possibly drive students to harm peers. Early childhood teachers recognize a child who functions in different and dangerous ways within minutes. Currently, with school budgets slashed to the core, few resources exist for salvaging a child who steps on a risky path at an early age.

Although proposed solutions differ, I suspect all of us want our kids to be safe at school. We differ over guiding principles.

A principle based squarely on fear recommends that we fight guns with more guns. We’ve all heard, “What stops a bad guy with a gun? A good guy with a gun.” Today, I also hear an argument that a teacher with a concealed gun could stop an assumed killer at the door. That gives me pause until I remember that the killer at most classroom doors will probably be another kid. Damaged kids remain our kids.

ANALYSIS: What the Secret Service already knows about school shootings.

The other principle states that intelligent individuals can solve even drastic challenges thoughtfully, with careful planning, and will. This principle adheres to faith in our capacity to make positive changes by working cooperatively. A principle based on intelligent problem solving begs everyone to investigate and consider multiple options.

In closing, the best teachers arrive with hearts wanting to nurture as well as to educate. Police and military seek to protect. Thank you to those with the drive and talent to keep us safe. Thank you to teachers who show up day after day to give their best to students. If we honor the skills of one another and lean in together, we will solve this tragic problem. If we choose to arm teachers, we will be bowing to a token god of fear. Any time we surrender to fear, everyone loses.

Frandsen retired from St. Edward’s University after teaching in Austin for 33 years, including at Langford and Patton elementary schools.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Texas news to your Facebook feed.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Family separation policy will continue to inflict damage

President Donald Trump has lied so much and so consistently that it should come as no surprise that he lied yet again when he promised to sign “something” that would end the separation of migrant children from their families at the southern border. Within hours after Trump put his signature on an executive order that purported to end the...
Letters to the editor: June 25, 2018
Letters to the editor: June 25, 2018

The Austin City Council voting on CodeNext dishonors the act of voting, the 2012 council vote for Imagine Austin and the individuals who sacrificed for voting rights and our form of government — veterans, first responders and citizens. It’s time to stop the process, otherwise the city’s goals set forth in Imagine Austin will go unfulfilled...
Opinion: Return of the blood libel

The speed of America’s moral descent under Donald Trump is breathtaking. In a matter of months we’ve gone from a nation that stood for life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness to a nation that tears children from their parents and puts them in cages. What’s almost equally remarkable about this plunge into barbarism is that it&rsquo...
Opinion: On being decent

Not too long ago, I returned to my parked car and found a sheet of paper on the windshield bearing an expletive-laden message. The anonymous poster had obviously gone to some effort to make these flyers on his home computer — complete with color cartoon figures and such. It let me know what an (obscenity) I was. My sin was having parked my car...
Herman: Beto O’Rourke flashes star power at Texas Democratic Convention
Herman: Beto O’Rourke flashes star power at Texas Democratic Convention

Some takeaways taken away from three days with 7,500 or so delegates at the Texas Democratic Convention: In general, the Dems didn’t approve a platform with nearly the volume of nutty stuff the Repubs did at their convention. Oh, there’s plenty in the Dem platform that some folks won’t like, but there’s nothing approaching the...
More Stories