Commentary: How cellphones are connecting teens with danger


As a pediatrician, I meet every day with parents overwhelmed by the responsibility of making the right choices for their babies. Hours of research, anguished soul-searching, piercing self-doubt – and that’s just choosing a car seat model. Once you’ve cut your teeth in the baby stroller wars and move on to even more meaningful and controversial territory, the stress can be paralyzing. And yet, every day, my heart is uplifted by the great strength parents display as they make all the decisions they need to make in their child’s best interest.

Why does that stop at age 10?

I am not worried about the babies of America; they have the most dedicated parents around. I am, however, very worried about the teens and preteens of America: They are facing an unprecedented mental health crisis — and the people tasked with watching over them are not even putting up a fight.

COMMENTARY: Giving kids an old-fashioned childhood is not abuse.

The crisis is real. Rates of anxiety, depression, and suicide in teens have exploded the last 10 years. One out of every 3 American teens now suffers from anxiety. Hospitalizations for suicidal thoughts and actions have doubled. In one typical survey, the American College Health Association documented a dramatic increase in self-reported ‘overwhelming anxiety’ – an already frightening 49 percent of students in 2010 jumping up to 62 percent last year. Here in Austin, pediatric mental health providers are overwhelmed, with many no longer willing to see new clients, leaving me few good or timely options when it comes to finding help for my own patients.

What can you, as parents, do to help protect your child’s mental health in the midst of this epidemic? While there is undoubtedly a complex interplay of root causes at work, here is one simple trick that will pay off big time in helping your family: Take the smartphone away.

In “iGen” by psychologist Dr. Jean Twenge, she details the unprecedented spike in mental health problems among our newest generation of teens — the first generation to grow up with smartphones, Facebook and social media. A key takeaway from all the research: “Teens who spend more time than average on screen activities are more likely to be unhappy, and those who spend more time than average on nonscreen activities are more likely to be happy. There’s not a single exception.”

To reiterate, “All screen activities are linked to less happiness, and all nonscreen activities are linked to more happiness.”

The arrow of causation is not in doubt, either: It’s not that already unhappy teens are more likely to spend time online, but that the more time you spend on sites like Facebook, the more unhappy you become. Nor is the unhappiness just a passing mood, either, as kids who spend more time on social media are more likely to develop clinical depression and to formulate plans for suicide.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.

When I talk to parents about all the other negative effects of smartphones — stunted attention spans, the death of conversation at the dinner table, the decreased sleep time, the wasted daylight hours — they often concede the point, but tell me it’s still worth it in the name of safety.

Smartphones do not make your children safer. They do make your child more likely to kill himself or herself. If there were a vaccine that had this side effect profile, it would be banned in a second. If there were a car seat that left so much damage in its wake, it would be pulled from shelves. I’d compare social media to street drugs — but my understanding is that crack at least makes you feel happy for a while, though Facebook doesn’t. Don’t stop fighting for your children just because they’re no longer on the breast. Smartphones are destroying their generation and, yes, making them unsafe – get rid of them.

Think of the time and money you’ll save. And think of your children. Instead of zoning out — with noses buried in the latest status updates in their palms, trying to find the nearest WiFi network to connect to — maybe they’ll be able to uncrick their necks to the beauty of the natural world — and to truly connecting with you.

Gaty is with Chisholm Trail Pediatrics in Round Rock.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Phillips: Last hurrah for Confederate groups in Veterans Day parade
Phillips: Last hurrah for Confederate groups in Veterans Day parade

During his 22 years in the Air Force, Lt. Col. Daarel Burnette observed Veterans Day events around the world, from Izmir, Turkey, to Colorado Springs, from military bases to the Pentagon. In all those places, during all those years, the emphasis was on sacrifice of U.S. veterans, said Burnette, who retired in 2001. It was about honoring soldiers who...
Herman: After months of kicking it around, Austin goes major league
Herman: After months of kicking it around, Austin goes major league

Great news! We’re getting a big-league football team. Less great news for some: It’s the other football, the one in which you actually use your feet for something other than running. Me? I’m good with the Austin City Council’s 7-4 vote Wednesday that should clear the way for the Columbus Crew to relocate to Austin and eventually...
Commentary: When I cut the cord to social media, I saw the change IRL
Commentary: When I cut the cord to social media, I saw the change IRL

Social media once made the world smaller. I connected with fellow nerds who liked Jim Thompson novels or the same Elmore James or Black Sabbath records. We could talk about “Pulp Fiction,” or where to get the best bacon cheeseburger from Galveston to Sydney. I’ve met friends who changed my life thanks to Twitter or Facebook. But then...
Editorial: Journalists are watchdog neighbors, not enemy of the people
Editorial: Journalists are watchdog neighbors, not enemy of the people

Politicians on both sides of the aisle have long decried unfavorable press coverage as erroneous or incomplete, seeking to blunt the impact of reporting that holds those in power accountable. President Donald Trump, however, has taken that tactic to the extreme, labeling stories he doesn’t like as “fake news” and branding journalists...
Letters to the editor: Aug. 16, 2018
Letters to the editor: Aug. 16, 2018

While Major League Soccer is professional, today it is very small in America. MLS wants to start small using a space in Austin that doesn’t accommodate expansion and also lacks necessary parking and retail expansion space. That is a shortsighted idea and creates a throwaway facility. MLS needs to think about its strategy for real success when...
More Stories