Commentary: Helping immigrants should not mean denying them care


The immigrant community is deeply committed to the values that this country works to uphold — values that brought many of us to this nation. The idea of the United States as a beacon for those fleeing persecution is deeply held by many communities, including many of those who come to the United States seeking a better life for themselves and their families.

The Catholic community is also called upon to take care of the most vulnerable — help the poor, heal the sick and feed the hungry. We applaud the pope and U.S. bishops for calling for greater acceptance and tolerance of migrants.

CONTINUING COVERAGE: Pregnant immigrant in Texas will test abortion access under Trump.

But we must also afford migrants the right to get the comprehensive care they need with compassion and dignity —including women and young people crossing the border who face untold horrors and abuse and often need comprehensive reproductive health care.

The latest case in Texas of an unaccompanied migrant minor, “Jane Doe,” who was being denied an abortion was an affront to our values of liberty and social justice. Thankfully, a federal judge has ruled in her favor Wednesday, upholding the legal right to abortion in a resounding victory for women’s autonomy.

But “Jane Doe” is not alone in her ordeal.

Since President Trump’s inauguration, the Department of Health and Human Services has exhibited an appalling level of overreach to prevent abortions at federally funded shelters, including in cases of rape and incest. Instead of providing the services women request, they have forced migrant women to visit crisis pregnancy centers and other faith-based groups that counsel women against having abortions. In Catholic relief organizations especially — which receive your taxpayer dollars to help those in need — migrant women are routinely denied access to emergency contraception or abortion services.

COMMENTARY: How did Heidi Group use millions? Texas women need answers.

Before “Jane Doe,” there was “Rosa,” who was raped on her journey to the United States. Rosa was denied housing by a Catholic affiliated shelter because she wanted to seek an abortion. Another young immigrant woman in Florida was denied housing at a Catholic facility near her family because she sought an abortion after being assaulted. Time and again, we have forced these young women to decide between receiving the care they need and having a roof over their heads. Where is the compassion or justice in that?

How can we not be outraged as federal funds are used to persecute and deny services to the most vulnerable in their hour of need? How can we not be outraged as “religious freedom” gets redefined to discriminate against people and deny them care? How can the Catholic Church claim to be aiding migrants when it denies them the very assistance they need to heal and to move forward with their lives?

We must strongly oppose this travesty of justice. Abortion is a right — and immigration status should not determine anyone’s ability to access it. We must reclaim our social justice tradition of helping those in need without prejudice —especially women and people fleeing domestic violence, femicide and abuse.

That is who we are as people who are passionate about the rights this country affords us. That is who we are as nation that welcomes immigrants and refugees.

Gonzales Garcia is the Policy and Program Director for the Colorado Organization for Latina Opportunity and Reproductive Rights. O’Brien is president of Catholics for Choice.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Chuck Palahniuk escalates fractures of society in ‘Adjustment Day’
Chuck Palahniuk escalates fractures of society in ‘Adjustment Day’

An uprising in Portland, Ore., leads to social revolution and terror in Chuck Palahniuk’s “Adjustment Day,” a relentless satire of our splintered times. Many writers have complained recently that current events are distracting them from doing the work. Clearly, Palahniuk has embraced the madness, crafting a dystopian nightmare that...
Herman: My turn at the wheel of the school bus
Herman: My turn at the wheel of the school bus

The wheels on the bus, as generations of gleeful children have told us in song, go round and round, round and round, round and round. But those school bus wheels don’t go anywhere unless there’s somebody behind the wheel at the driver’s seat. On a recent Saturday, I was that somebody. Oh, don’t worry. There were no kids on the...
Letters to the editor: May 27, 2018
Letters to the editor: May 27, 2018

Why do we consistently elect poorly prepared, privileged and disconnected trustees into positions where they end up way over their heads and quit instead of fulfilling their responsibilities to the Austin ISD community, parents, students, taxpayers and constituents? The texts released were only one side of a conversation that showed one person&rsquo...
Facebook comments: May 27, 2018
Facebook comments: May 27, 2018

As reported by the American-Statesman’s Jonathan Tilove, Lupe Valdez defeated Andrew White in Tuesday’s Democratic gubernatorial runoff election. “Texas is changing,” Valdez said at her victory celebration at Ellen’s, a restaurant specializing in Southern cuisine in downtown Dallas. “Look all around you. This is...
Facebook comments: May 27, 2018
Facebook comments: May 27, 2018

As reported by the American-Statesman’s Chuck Lindell, Gov. Greg Abbott said his first gun violence roundtable Tuesday yielded a list of “solid” ideas for protecting Texas schools. Some of the ideas included placing more counselors in schools, expanding the school marshal program and requiring schools to create action plans with law...
More Stories