Commentary: ‘Conscience’ division at HHS aims to reignite culture wars


Did you know that health care workers are complaining to the government that they’re suffering from discrimination by employers for declining to give care that violates their religious beliefs? I didn’t either.

What’s more, in 30 years of providing health care, I’ve never heard of an employee who felt their religious freedoms were threatened.

But the regulation-averse Trump administration thinks it’s such a pressing problem that on Jan. 18, it announced a proposed new regulation and the creation of the Conscience and Religious Freedom Division within the civil rights office of the federal Department of Health and Human Services. The announcement was carefully choreographed for the day before the March for Life in Washington D.C., giving anti-abortion activists renewed energy.

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Viewpoints delivers the latest perspectives on current events.

The new section will handle complaints from health workers who feel their religious or moral beliefs are being violated — for example by having to care for transgender patients or by being forced to perform or assist with procedures such as abortion, assisted death or sex-reassignment surgery.

Roger Severino was a devout anti-gay, anti-abortion activist before being tapped to head civil-rights enforcement at HHS. His new conscience division is charged with investigating complaints made by health care workers. He attempted to explain the initiative on NPR’s “All Things Considered” by saying, “The government should not be saying, ‘You cannot have a job; you cannot be a nurse because of your views on abortion.’ This is about tolerance on all sides.”

What on earth is this man talking about? How can any health care worker’s freedom of religion be threatened in a health care setting? This is a free country. If abortion offends your religious beliefs, don’t work in a setting that provides them. Health care settings are not in short supply.

And if it offends your religious beliefs to care for transgender individuals, gays or anyone else not like you, then you’re in the wrong profession. Go back and read your professional code of ethics. Every health care discipline has a code that prohibits discrimination against patients. Nursing’s, for example, reads: “The nurse practices with compassion and respect for the inherent dignity, worth, and unique attributes of every person … The nurse’s primary commitment is to the patient.” If you can’t practice under those principles, go find another line of work. You are a danger to our patients.

About one such claim was made per year of the Obama administration. But 34 complaints arose during President Trump’s first year. Is anyone surprised by the four-fold increase?

Trump’s election threw open the closet doors of suppressed white supremacists and other bigots. Ku Klux Klansmen can now throw off their hoods, stand tall and march defiantly through the streets with torches chanting muck against Jews, blacks and browns, like they did in Charlottesville — with the support of our president.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Texas news to your Facebook feed.

Let’s put these 34 complaints into perspective. With more than 18 million health care workers in this country, 34 represents 0.00000189 of one percentage point of workers. That’s enough to open a new agency division?

Apparently, the meaning of “religious freedom” has evolved from the freedom to practice no religion or the religion of your choice to freedom to discriminate against others under the guise of religion. Do we want government to protect religious liberty or enforce religious dogma?

This meaningless initiative appears designed to reignite the culture wars over “conscience protections.” It won’t work, but it will cost taxpayer money — and it will harm patients by limiting their access to needed services. I guess HHS is no longer concerned with patients’ civil rights.

This and many other Republican initiatives, such as the bathroom bill from Texas’ last legislative session, are all answers to questions no one is asking. Wouldn’t it be nice if government would come up with answers to questions people are asking? Like how do we secure health care for everyone?

Inglis is a retired editor and neonatal intensive care nurse in Austin.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Herman: About the school shootings, can we talk?
Herman: About the school shootings, can we talk?

Yes, yes, yes and yes. The correct answer is all of the below. Once again, the unthinkable has become more than thinkable. It’s become predictable. Left untreated, school shootings will happen again. We know this because we’ve seen this. And once again, this latest one in Santa Fe has us thinking about what we can do to make it the...
The Supreme Court just made it easier on employers
The Supreme Court just made it easier on employers

The already meager rights of American workers just got significantly smaller, thanks to the Supreme Court. It ruled this morning that employers can use contracts with workers to ban them from joining class-action lawsuits - and to mandate individual arbitration in the event of disputes. The decision came in a case that pitted two conflicted federal...
Commentary: All music creators should be paid for their work
Commentary: All music creators should be paid for their work

All great music comes from … other music. It’s our greatest teacher, our loftiest inspiration, and at times our cruelest measuring stick. Every song has its roots. That’s true for all songwriters and performers, and even more so for those of us from musical families, where the fabric of our childhood is so deeply interwoven with...
INSIGHT: ‘School climate’ and the unintended results of more security
INSIGHT: ‘School climate’ and the unintended results of more security

School shootings like the one that took place in Santa Fe, Texas, on May 18 are often followed by calls for enhanced security measures. But Santa Fe High School already had many of these security measures in place. For instance, the high school had a school resource officer who responded to the attack. The school also had security cameras in place...
INSIGHT: 5 fallacies about guns that creep out after mass shootings
INSIGHT: 5 fallacies about guns that creep out after mass shootings

At least 10 people were killed at a Santa Fe, Texas, high school on May 18 after a classmate opened fire with a shotgun and a .38 revolver. The shooting came just three months after another teen shooter killed 17 in Parkland, Florida, sparking nationwide youth-led protests over gun violence – and a familiar debate over what changes could really...
More Stories