Statesman sues city of Austin over city manager secrecy


The American-Statesman has sued the city of Austin after officials denied requests under the Texas Public Information Act to disclose the identities of finalists for city manager.

The Statesman filed the suit Tuesday in a Travis County district court as the Austin City Council began the first of two days of interviewing finalists. The lawsuit seeks disclosure of the city manager candidates’ names. The Statesman has independently confirmed the identities of four of the candidates.

“The residents of Austin will be paying the salary for a new city manager, and at the very least should know the finalists being considered by the city for such a critical role,” Statesman executive editor Debbie Hiott said. “Whether the City Council agrees or not, the legislative intent of the Texas Public Information Act has always been clear, that this is the type of information the public is entitled to know. If the city doesn’t want to inform the public, the newspaper will.”

Last week, the city denied a Statesman request under the Texas Public Information Act seeking the names of finalists for the city manager job. In a letter to the Texas attorney general, the city stated that revealing their identities would undermine the search for the best job candidates, citing a Texas Supreme Court ruling often applied to businesses competing for government contracts.

Texas does have laws in place that guard the identities of candidates for school superintendent or chief executive of an institution of higher learning, but none for government officials such as a city manager.

“Because the Legislature has not made the names of applicants for city manager confidential — as it has with other public job positions — the ‘competitive bidding’ exception to the (Texas Public Information) Act should not be interpreted to apply to such information as a matter of law,” the Statesman’s suit said. “The decision whether to make that information confidential must be left to the Legislature, not the city.”

The city manager is the top bureaucratic position at the city of Austin. The position has remained vacant for more than a year since former city manager Marc Ott left for a job in Washington. Interim City Manager Elaine Hart has filled the post since then, running the day-to-day operations of a city with 14,000 employees and a $3.9 billion budget. Hart is earning $306,233 in the interim role.

The City Council in March voted to keep applicants and even finalists for city manager secret as they hired the consultant company Russell Reynolds to perform the nationwide search.

Despite a private company conducting the search, Texas law still requires documents related to the hiring of a position like city manager to be disclosed to the public.

Kelley Shannon, executive director of the Freedom of Information Foundation of Texas, told the Statesman Tuesday that the city’s attempt to keep the finalists names hidden was the most recent contortion of the Texas Supreme Court case Boeing v. Paxton, a ruling made to protect the bidding process.

“When you are hiring (for) an important position like city manager, city attorney or police chief, that rises to the level of position that transparency is needed,” Shannon said. “And the public needs to be in a loop in the finalists and the hiring process.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Dallas somehow named the sweatiest city in Texas; Houston baffled as Austin comes in second
Dallas somehow named the sweatiest city in Texas; Houston baffled as Austin comes in second

  We all know the stereotypes: Houston is hot and humid, Austin is hot yet hipster and Dallas is absolutely a city in Texas (with a famous football team and some terrific art museums). We know these truths to be self-evident, right? According to the fine people at Dallas News, a researcher working with Honeywell Fans ranked 50 U.S. cities &ldquo...
OVERNIGHT: Woman critically injured in crash on I-35 in North Austin
OVERNIGHT: Woman critically injured in crash on I-35 in North Austin

A woman was critically injured early Friday in a crash that happened on Interstate 35 in North Austin, Austin-Travis County EMS officials said. Medics said they responded at 12:27 a.m. to the 12800 block of the Interstate 35 North frontage road, which is near Parmer Lane, for the crash. A woman was taken to St. David’s Round Rock Medical Center...
Pedestrian hit by vehicle, critically injured late Thursday, EMS says
Pedestrian hit by vehicle, critically injured late Thursday, EMS says

A pedestrian was critically injured late Thursday after being hit by a vehicle in North Austin, Austin-Travis County EMS officials said. Medics said crews responded to the crash on Lamar Boulevard and Powell Lane shortly before midnight. Officials said they took a man to Dell Seton Medical Center with critical, life-threatening injuries. No additional...
TRAFFIC ALERT: Several downtown streets closed as police investigate shooting
TRAFFIC ALERT: Several downtown streets closed as police investigate shooting

Austin police have shut down several streets in Downtown Austin while investigators gather evidence related to a police shooting that left a 21-year-old dead on Friday morning. According to police, Sixth, Seventh and Eighth streets are blocked off at San Jacinto and Trinity streets, along with the intersection of Seventh and Brazos streets. Drivers...
Student stabbed in Oklahoma on first day of school
Student stabbed in Oklahoma on first day of school

A 14-year-old Oklahoma girl was stabbed multiple times during an orientation session at her high school Thursday. >> Read more trending news  Police said the incident happened at Luther High School. A 14-year-old boy was taken into custody and booked at the Oklahoma County Jail. Luther police later said the girl was stabbed...
More Stories