Ruling rejects Austin’s old fundraising window. What about the new one?


Former Council Member Don Zimmerman wins partial victory against Austin City Council’s fundraising rules.

Ruling against city’s old 6-month limit should also apply to its new 12-month one, Zimmerman’s lawyer says.

Federal appeals court does uphold campaign contribution limit of $350 per donor in an election cycle.

Former City Council Member Don Zimmerman’s mixed victory in his fight against Austin campaign finance rules will stand, an appeals court ruled Thursday.

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with the lower court’s ruling from 2016 that struck down two provisions of Austin’s campaign finance rules and left two others in place. Most notably, the decision held that Austin could not justify a blackout period that prohibited candidates from fundraising until a certain period of time before an election.

Previously, Austin’s rules disallowed any fundraising earlier than six months before an election day. After the lower court overturned that in July 2016, City Council members passed a new ordinance allowing fundraising only within one year before an election.

BACKGROUND: ‘Two to go,’ Zimmerman says on campaign rules

In its ruling, the appellate court noted that Austin conducts business year-round and does not change its consideration of votes based on when elections are, so candidates are no more susceptible to bribes six months before an election than they are a year or two before.

“Austin needed to establish that even if a $350 contribution near the time of an election is not likely to lead to actual corruption or its appearance, the same contribution made at another time is,” the court wrote.

Zimmerman’s attorney, Jerad Najvar, said the court’s arguments clearly apply to the new one-year window the council approved in October, just as the six-month window it struck down. Najvar won a similar case against Houston that overturned a nine-month fundraising window there.

“The new one-year fundraising window (in Austin) is just as unconstitutional as the six-month window, and this ruling just reinforces that,” he said. “The sooner Austin learns the lesson of how the First Amendment applies to these rules, the better for taxpayers.”

Last August, the council put an additional $75,000 toward the legal bills on the case, bringing the total tab to $255,000.

‘UNPRECEDENTED’: Zimmerman sues Austin over campaign finance rules

It’s unclear whether anyone in Austin will challenge the new time period. Previously, Council Member Leslie Pool said she hoped a longer fundraising window would be less susceptible to lawsuits.

“A year is … twice as long,” she said in October. “It’s unseemly for people to be raising money when they’re also passing judgments on issues that have very real consequences to the community.”

The appeals court also sided with Zimmerman over a “dissolution requirement” that said elected officials could not use campaign money for future races, rejecting Austin’s argument that Zimmerman lacked standing to challenge it, and finding that use of the money for campaigns amounted to freedom of speech.

The court sided with the city of Austin in upholding a campaign contribution limit of $350 per donor in an election cycle and a rule that a candidate cannot raise more than $36,000 total from donors who live outside of Austin’s city limits.

Najvar plans to continue fighting on those fronts. Zimmerman intends to file a motion for the entire 5th Circuit to rehear the case, he said.

INTERACTIVE TIMELINE: Don Zimmerman’s political career

On the $350-per-donor limit, the court noted that the Supreme Court has held that contribution limits are different than expenditure limits — and less of a burden on free speech.

“We decline Zimmerman’s invitation to blur the line that the Supreme Court has drawn,” the court wrote.

It added that the limit was on par with others that have been upheld—such as Missouri’s $275 contribution limit in 2002 for candidates for any office representing fewer than 100,000 people. It also took into account testimony from Zimmerman’s former council colleagues, and it shot down arguments that the policy favored incumbents.

“Zimmerman himself, an incumbent, was defeated when he ran for re-election in 2016,” the court wrote.

It agreed with the lower court ruling that Zimmerman did not have standing to challenge a maximum total of $36,000 to be raised from outside the district, because he had raised nowhere near that much.

Zimmerman told the court in a signed declaration that, if he could have raised more, he would have paid $5,000 to purchase a list of conservative donors from outside his area. But the court wasn’t persuaded that was enough of an injury to give Zimmerman standing.

ALSO READ: This Don Zimmerman lawsuit won’t make it to court (and he’s OK with that)

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Three arrested workers identified in Travis Tax Office fraud case
Three arrested workers identified in Travis Tax Office fraud case

Three employees of the Travis County Tax Office who were arrested Friday amid a fraud investigation are charged with third-degree felonies, according to jail records. Shell Prieto-Reese, 43, and Cathy Wilson, 57, are each charged with engaging in organized criminal activity and forgery, and each have bail posted at $50,000. Susie Alvarez, 43, is charged...
Chance of storms again Monday, but rest of week looks clear
Chance of storms again Monday, but rest of week looks clear

There’s a slight chance the Austin area could see more thunderstorms again Monday, but forecasters say weather for the rest of the week will look nothing like it did Sunday. The weekend wrapped up with showers and thunderstorms developing throughout the day Sunday and a warning that rain levels could reach 5 inches in parts of Travis County....
SANTA FE SCHOOL SHOOTING: Dan Patrick renews call to arm more teachers
SANTA FE SCHOOL SHOOTING: Dan Patrick renews call to arm more teachers

Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick on Sunday blamed the Santa Fe High School shooting on “a violent culture where we devalue life,” citing movies and video games, bullying on social media, and abortion. He called for arming teachers as part of the militia envisioned by the Second Amendment. Patrick’s remarks on ABC’s “This Week&rdquo...
Downtown Austin’s ‘Jenga tower’ marks milestone
Downtown Austin’s ‘Jenga tower’ marks milestone

The Independent, a residential high-rise under construction in downtown Austin, has reached its peak height — a milestone for the 58-story building nicknamed the “Jenga tower.” Now standing at its full height of 685 feet, a topping-out ceremony Sunday marks the Independent’s official debut as the tallest building in Austin,...
Texas Digest: Gunfire near Dallas police station prompts more security

DALLAS Gunfire reported near police station Dallas police officials have advised officers to increase security outside the city’s police stations after someone in a vehicle opened fire near a station. Police Sgt. Warren Mitchell told The Dallas Morning News someone was shooting late Saturday night near the city’s Central Division station...
More Stories