breaking news

Ted Cruz says he’ll introduce a bill to end most family separations

Panel: Five Austin municipal judges should come off the bench


A committee of Austin City Council members on Monday recommended not reappointing five municipal judges after they received reports indicating some had exhibited unprofessional behavior and made dangerous decisions.

The five judges not recommended to serve another four-year term include Erik Cary, the city’s overnight magistrate judge, who is often the first judge defendants see after being arrested to set their bail. The four others are part-time “substitute” judges.

A panel of nine attorneys conducted the review of each of the city’s 22 judges and looked at applications, performance reviews and comments made on sitting judges. The four members of the council’s judicial committee approved the panel’s recommendation unanimously Monday.

“We all unanimously agreed that none of them are fit to continue as judges generally because they weren’t fair and didn’t consider defendants’ individual circumstances,” said panel member Emily Gerrick, an attorney with the Texas Fair Defense Project.

Municipal judges most often try cases involving traffic tickets. However, they all can serve shifts as magistrate judges, approving probable cause affidavits that allow law enforcement agencies to press charges against an individual. They may also set bail.

“These positions are extremely powerful positions, and they are not elected, so it is very hard … for them to be held accountable if there is something going on that we don’t want to see in our judges,” Council Member Delia Garza said.

Municipal judges are appointed by the City Council. To be eligible, a person must be a licensed attorney in good standing with at least five years of legal experience, in addition to meeting residency and citizenship requirements.

The part-time judges who will probably not be reappointed are Beverly Landers, F. Witcher McCullough, Olivia Ruiz and Celeste Villarreal.

Villarreal has faced some backlash since she authorized the release of a teen accused of threatening to “shoot and blow up” Akins High School on $15,000 bail with no conditions for monitoring. In 2016, Villarreal authorized the release of a man accused of stalking on a public recognizance bond; he then attempted to hunt down and kill his ex-girlfriend but killed himself when he did not find her in her home.

Villarreal did not return a call seeking comment.

The most excoriating input on the judges’ performance came in anonymous responses to surveys given to law enforcement, court staffers and prosecutors, according to copies of the input provided to the Statesman.

For Cary, one said he was rude and unprofessional. For Landers, one said she makes poor decisions that endanger the community, though the survey didn’t specify how.

Cary is the only full-time judge the committee did not recommend for reappointment.

Gerrick said she has seen Cary jail defendants without asking them questions about their financial situation and ability to pay bail.

“You need judges who treat people with respect and are compassionate and make bail decisions based on whether someone was a threat, whether they are a flight risk and their ability to pay,” Gerrick said.

Cary did not return a message seeking comment.

The City Council committee recommended hiring one new judge. That leaves four vacancies at the municipal courthouse that Council Member Jimmy Flannigan said he hopes to have filled in April.

The council could give final approval to the committee’s recommendation at its March 8 meeting.

McCullough, who has been a part-time judge for the Municipal Court since 2012, said he was blindsided by the committee’s recommendation not to reappoint him.

“I’m certainly disappointed and surprised,” he told the Statesman. “I don’t understand where they are coming from.”

Landers and Ruiz did not return phone messages seeking comment.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Historic downtown building damaged by arson, fire officials say
Historic downtown building damaged by arson, fire officials say

A single sprinkler on the third floor of the Millett Opera House — home of the Austin Club, a plush reception venue — kept a blaze from spreading through the 140-year-old building in downtown Austin and destroying the valuable paintings and antiques inside. Austin fire investigators said an arsonist broke into the building at 110 E. Ninth...
Sen. Carlos Uresti to resign days before his sentencing
Sen. Carlos Uresti to resign days before his sentencing

Texas Sen. Carlos Uresti, the San Antonio Democrat found guilty of 11 fraud-related counts in February, announced Monday that he will resign his seat effective Thursday. Uresti, who is scheduled to be sentenced June 26 in federal court and faces the potential of years in prison and restitution of more than $3 million, said in a letter posted on Twitter...
JUST IN: Credit card skimmer reported at 7-Eleven on Burnet Road
JUST IN: Credit card skimmer reported at 7-Eleven on Burnet Road

Someone reported a credit card skimmer at a gas station pump in North Austin, according to the state Department of Agriculture. An inspector found a possible Bluetooth skimmer device at a 7-Eleven at 7844 Burnet Road, officials said.  Police have removed the device, state officials said.
ACC celebrates renovated, revitalized African American Cultural Center
ACC celebrates renovated, revitalized African American Cultural Center

Austin Community College has completed a renovation of its African American Cultural Center, and a celebration Monday showcased the center’s artifacts as well as palpable enthusiasm about the need for cross-cultural appreciation during turbulent racial times. The center has existed for years at ACC’s Eastview campus, offering movies, financial...
Crash near San Marcos kills three from Wimberley

SAN MARCOS 3 killed in crash Three people from Wimberley died in a fiery crash Friday near San Marcos. According to the Texas Department of Public Safety, 22-year-old Ramiro Ramirez, 40-year-old Angela Mary Masullo and 44-year-old Daniel Stuart Masullo all died about 8 p.m. on RM 12, three miles south of San Marcos. Three others also were injured in...
More Stories