As jump in water bills riles Circle C residents, few answers from city


At least 12 residents within York Bridge Circle saw unusual dips and spikes in their summer water bills.

Austin utility billing representatives deny theories that meters weren’t read for two months.

In the 30 years Gordon and Valerie Brown have lived in Austin — 12 in their home on York Bridge Circle in the Circle C development — their recent utility bill was the first one that’s come as a surprise.

The couple’s August water bill was only $20. Then, in the billing period from Aug. 25 to Sept. 26 — time that included rain from Hurricane Harvey — the bill shot up to $365.

“There’s clearly something weird,” Gordon Brown thought.

He wasn’t the only one. Within three blocks of the Browns’ home in the Park Place neighborhood, 12 bills the American-Statesman evaluated all showed water use in July and August that was a third to half of each home’s annual average and September use triple to quadruple its average. Two doors down from the Browns, retirees Bob and Peggy Hinman received a September water bill for 62,100 gallons of water — nearly 25 times their August usage.

They all checked for leaks: Nothing. They contacted the city and were told the meters were read correctly, period. The city is looking into individual complaints but maintains it has found nothing wrong with the neighborhood water billing so far and has no reason to believe any individual bill spikes are related.

RELATED: Residents still question water bills; officials still say system works

Water bills fluctuate greatly throughout the year, of course. Typically water use is significantly lower in colder and rainier months and spikes dramatically in hotter and drier months. What’s curious about the Park Place neighborhood bills is that water use was so low during the hottest months and so high during a rainy one.

That led to a neighborhood theory that meters were read incorrectly, or not at all, for two months and then the actual water use was logged all at once. Such a scenario would cause an exponential jump in bills because Austin’s tiered billing system charges more per gallon for residents who use a lot of water. For example, 30,000 gallons of water used over three months would cost $182.40, while the same amount of water used in one month would cost $359.69.

“I don’t think they’re charging us for too much water; I think they screwed up for two months and now they’re trying to make it right,” Brown said. “But in doing so, they’re significantly overcharging us.”

Unlikely, said Robert Cullick, a spokesman for Austin Energy, which handles the water utility meter reading and billing.

“We do not have instances of failures of water meter reading systems because it is a heavily audited system,” Cullick said.

The city will evaluate each of the homes that complained based on historical water usage, comparing the same months over multiple years, Cullick said. But he emphasized that the city can’t explain abnormal spikes in water use and hasn’t found anything suspect in the York Bridge Circle bills it has looked at so far.

Water billing spikes in the summer of 2015 led City Council members to order an audit of the billing system. Completed last year, it found 15 errors in water meter reads in a sample of 1,138 meters. Austin Energy representatives said that validated a tiny error percentage and a system working correctly, but critics said errors should be no more than 1 in 1,000, per the city’s contract with meter readers.

As the Park Place neighborhood tries to get answers, residents have grown frustrated at the responses from customer representatives, who outline their options as paying the bill or applying for a one-time adjustment that would refund up to 70 percent of the difference from an average month.

“I tried to tell the guy it was a neighborhood problem, and he was really condescending,” said Christina Allen. “He goes ‘Well, if you’re having problems paying it we can put you on a payment plan.’ … He wouldn’t even entertain the idea that it was a group problem.”

RELATED: Audits suggest Austin water billing system not to blame for high bills

Cullick said representatives who receive complaints can tell if there are a large number of problems in a particular area, but cases are handled individually.

“Water comes through a pipe,” he said. “There’s no relation from one customer to the next except for meter reading, and we have very accurate meter readings.”

Council Member Ellen Troxclair, whose district includes the neighborhood, said she hears often from residents about unexpected spikes in water bills. Last year, the council approved a resolution from Troxclair to allow residents to receive an adjustment every two years if their bill spikes to more than three times the average.

A water rate adjustment defers 70 percent of the difference between the bill and the average monthly cost. Troxclair said she plans to bring forward another resolution that would refund all of the difference for such an abnormality.

Utility billing representatives looked at the bills from the 12 York Bridge Circle homes the Statesman evaluated but said they couldn’t reach any conclusions without a deeper dive into their historical data.

“Although our review is incomplete, we have found no evidence of any failure of the water meter reading system,” Cullick said.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

1 man injured after shooting in Southeast Austin, officials say
1 man injured after shooting in Southeast Austin, officials say

Officers are currently searching for the perpetrator after a man was shot in Southeast Austin, police said.  The shooting was reported at 10:39 p.m. at Raleigh Circle and Lambs Lane. The man’s gunshot wound is not life-threatening, Austin-Travis County EMS officials said. Investigators believe the shooter and the victim knew each other,...
Texas oil and gas regulator: Science isn’t settled on global warming
Texas oil and gas regulator: Science isn’t settled on global warming

Contrary to widely held conclusions by scientists, a senior official in Texas’ oil and gas regulatory agency said Tuesday “we don’t know whether man-made greenhouse gases are impacting our climate in a harmful way.” Wayne Christian, a Republican elected in 2016 to the state Railroad Commission, which oversees oil and gas operations...
Abbott calls June 30 special election to replace disgraced congressman
Abbott calls June 30 special election to replace disgraced congressman

Gov. Greg Abbott on Tuesday ordered an emergency special election for June 30 to elect a U.S. representative for a congressional district that stretches from Corpus Christi to Bastrop and Caldwell counties. The winner will serve out the remaining months of the two-year term of U.S. Rep. Blake Farenthold, R-Corpus Christi, who resigned in early April...
Man arrested after SWAT standoff at La Quinta Inn in North Austin

NORTH AUSTIN Man arrested after SWAT standoff at La Quinta Inn Austin police have arrested a man who had threatened to shoot anyone who approached him in a North Austin hotel bathroom. SWAT officers used pepper spray to force the man to leave the lobby bathroom at the La Quinta Inn and Suites near the Domain shopping center, police said. A police spokesman...
Jam session with Austin musicians leads to fatal stabbing conviction
Jam session with Austin musicians leads to fatal stabbing conviction

A chance meeting between two Austin musicians led to the violent death of one man and a felony conviction for the other. James Miller, a former Austin police employee who took up the guitar in retirement, was found guilty Tuesday of criminally negligent homicide in the September 2015 stabbing of saxophonist Daniel Spencer. The two had gathered to drink...
More Stories