Judge tosses out campus carry gun lawsuit filed by UT professors


Highlights

The judge said the professors presented no concrete claims that they face a greater risk of physical harm.

An attorney for one of the professors said he is confused by the ruling.

Saying their fears are hypothetical and not rooted in reality, a federal judge tossed out a lawsuit filed last year by three University of Texas professors hoping to stop students from bringing concealed handguns into campus buildings.

The professors had requested an exemption from Senate Bill 11 — the controversial law that allows license holders to carry concealed weapons in most classrooms, common areas and labs at Texas public universities — telling the court the possible presence of firearms could bring a “chilling effect” to classroom discussion. Their request for a temporary injunction at the time was denied.

In a seven-page ruling signed Thursday in Austin, U.S. Judge Lee Yeakel said the professors’ worries are unfounded and that the threat of physical harm is not heightened just because a student might have access to a gun.

Q&A: UT’s campus carry gun rules

And, Yeakel said, educators are to blame if fear for their safety results in a muted classroom atmosphere.

“The chilling effect appears to arise from plaintiff’s subjective belief that a person may be more likely to cause harm to a professor or student as a result of the law and policy,” Yeakel wrote, adding the professors “present no concrete evidence to substantiate their fears, but instead rest on mere conjecture about possible … actions.”

The ruling is a win for Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who in August of last year asked the court to discard the lawsuit on the grounds that people on campus should be entitled to the same level of protection as anyone else.

Paxton, the state’s chief law enforcement officer, released a statement Friday calling the ruling “the correct outcome.”

“The fact that a small group of professors dislike a law and speculate about a ‘chilling effect’ is hardly a valid basis to set the law aside,” he said.

Attorney Renea Hicks, who represents sociology professor Jennifer Lynn Glass in the lawsuit, said he’s confused by the ruling because it fails to reach the merits of the professors’ First Amendment claims or their Second Amendment or equal protection claims.

The lawsuit suggested the presence of deadly force infringes on the teachers’ freedom of speech.

“It appears to be a very narrow ruling based on jurisdiction alone,” Hicks said. “My co-counsel and I will confer, and we will confer with our clients to determine our next steps. Given summer travel schedules (work and vacation), this may take a couple of weeks.”

Campus carry at UT went into effect on Aug. 16, 2016. It broadened a previous law, established in 1995, that allowed those with a license to carry guns on campus sidewalks, parking areas and streets — basically anywhere but inside buildings.

The three faculty members — Glass, English professor Lisa Moore and associate English professor Mia Carter — filed the suit on July 6, 2016, and asked for a preliminary injunction three weeks later that would have temporarily blocked the law from becoming effective. Yeakel denied the motion for an injunction, clearing the way for licensed holders to carry guns on campus to open the fall 2016 semester.

UT President Gregory L. Fenves opposed the change, but said he had an obligation to uphold the law. He formed a team of students, faculty and others to come up with 25 recommendations to regulate how guns would be carried and stored.

A university spokesman said Fenves, who is a defendant in the lawsuit, is out of the country and had not had time to review the court’s decision.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Central Health to reconsider budget, hold hearing about ending Sendero
Central Health to reconsider budget, hold hearing about ending Sendero

Within days of being diagnosed with lymphoma, a type of cancer, about a year ago, Austin artist Chia Guillory began treatment. Today, she’s in remission. Guillory was able to receive care immediately, she told the Travis County Commissioners Court on Tuesday, only because of the subsidy she receives from the county’s health district, Central...
Well-known Austin activist Chas Moore charged with assault
Well-known Austin activist Chas Moore charged with assault

Chas Moore, a well-known community activist and director of the Austin Justice Coalition, is being charged with assault, a misdemeanor stemming from a recent altercation at a Sixth Street establishment, his attorney confirmed Tuesday. “It is an unfortunate incident,” lawyer Brian McGiverin said. “I think it is going to be resolved...
JUST IN: City drops workers’ compensation suit against firefighter who says her cancer is work-related
JUST IN: City drops workers’ compensation suit against firefighter who says her cancer is work-related

The city of Austin will drop a workers’ compensation lawsuit against an Austin firefighter who was diagnosed with cancer and has argued the disease is related to her work, City Manager Spencer Cronk announced Tuesday. “After discussion with council today, I have asked the law department to dismiss the current litigation involving our firefighter...
Cruz opens up 9-point lead over O’Rourke, poll finds
Cruz opens up 9-point lead over O’Rourke, poll finds

U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, has a 9 percentage point lead over challenger U.S. Rep. Beto O’Rourke, D-El Paso, according to a poll of likely voters released Tuesday. The Quinnipiac University poll has Cruz holding a 54 percent to 45 percent lead over O’Rourke. Ninety-three percent of those polled who picked a candidate said their minds...
NEW: 18-year-old arrested after threatening Caldwell County school, sheriff says
NEW: 18-year-old arrested after threatening Caldwell County school, sheriff says

Caldwell County sheriff’s deputies arrested a man on Friday suspected of making a terroristic threat against a Prairie Lea school district school and a student. David Baros, 18, has been charged with making a terroristic threat and evading arrest or detention, the sheriff’s office said. County officials said deputies received reports of...
More Stories