Five municipal judges out after Austin City Council vote


Highlights

The City Council voted to not reappoint five municipal judges to city courts.

Those in favor called process thorough, while those against said the judges didn’t have a chance to respond.

Municipal judges conduct most magistrate hearings in Travis County, setting bail for defendants.

Five municipal judges will not be returning to the bench after the Austin City Council voted Thursday to not reappoint them, following the recommendation of a panel that conducted the city’s first performance review of sitting judges.

While the panel didn’t provide specific reasons for not keeping the five judges in question, panel member Emily Gerrick said these judges broadly showed patterns of belittling defendants, jailing them for speaking during hearings and refusing to grant bail requests from certain attorneys because of personal reasons.

The recommendation drew a fiery response from one of the judges in question.

“I’m unfit?” Beverly Landers, a substitute magistrate for 21 years, asked council members Thursday. “That is an insult to your predecessors. It is an insult to me. It is an insult to our citizens.”

The other judges who were not reappointed to the bench are Judge Erik Cary, who worked an overnight magistrate shift at the Travis County Jail, and substitute Judges F. Witcher McCullough, Olivia Ruiz and Celeste Villarreal.

The council’s vote Thursday was 8-0, with Council Members Ann Kitchen, Sabino “Pio” Renteria and Ellen Troxclair abstaining.

Municipal judges most often try cases involving traffic tickets. However, they often serve shifts as magistrate judges, approving probable cause affidavits that allow law enforcement agencies to press charges against an individual. They may also set bail.

A panel of nine attorneys conducted the review last month of each of the city’s 22 judges and looked at applications, performance reviews and comments made on sitting judges. They recommended reappointing 17 and hiring one new judge, leaving four vacancies at the court.

Austin attorney Amber Vazquez, one of the panel members, said that this was by far the most thorough process she had seen in reviewing municipal judges.

“This process was a watershed moment for how we do things,” Vazquez said. “For the first time, we were given a broad view of everyone that was on the bench and everyone that wanted to be on the bench.”

Villarreal has faced some backlash since she authorized the release of a teen accused of threatening to “shoot and blow up” Akins High School on $15,000 bail with no conditions for monitoring. In 2016, Villarreal authorized the release of a man accused of stalking on a public recognizance bond; he then attempted to hunt down and kill his ex-girlfriend but killed himself when he did not find her in her home.

The city has created panels in the past to review those applying to be municipal judges. However, this was the first time it ever reviewed the performance of sitting judges.

Even so, several council members were concerned that the judges did not have a chance to respond to the review.

“I do think this is a better process,” Kitchen said. “My difficulty is I am just not comfortable with a process … where allegations that individuals were performing in a certain way were made and they did not have the opportunity to respond to that.”

Update: This story has been updated to correct the spelling of Council Member Sabino “Pio” Renteria’s name.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Pflugerville tween finds camaraderie through guns
Pflugerville tween finds camaraderie through guns

Like most 12-year-olds, Ashlynne Thomas can be shy and timid when talking about herself. But out on the shooting range, she comes alive with the confidence of a highly skilled competitor. For the past year, Thomas has competed in the three-gun circuit, a form of competitive shooting that involves the use of three different types of firearms: rifles...
Man dies days after being beaten at South Austin bus stop, police say
Man dies days after being beaten at South Austin bus stop, police say

A man who was beaten at a bus stop on Redd Street and Manchaca Road Saturday has died, Austin Police Department officials said Tuesday.  Officers responded to a disturbance call at the bus stop on Saturday at 8:02 p.m. The caller told police that one man was beating and kicking another. When officers arrived, they found Allen Kiddy, 66, injured...
Abbott’s ‘frightened like a feeble squirrel’ of Trump, GOP lawmaker says
Abbott’s ‘frightened like a feeble squirrel’ of Trump, GOP lawmaker says

In a rare move Tuesday night, a Republican state lawmaker attacked Gov. Greg Abbott for not taking a stand against President Donald Trump’s “zero tolerance” policy toward immigrants crossing into the U.S. from Mexico illegally. Under the policy, 2,000 migrant children have been separated from family and placed in shelters, sparking...
UPDATED: Woman found in Granger home had been dead for several days, Wilco sheriff says
UPDATED: Woman found in Granger home had been dead for several days, Wilco sheriff says

11:30 p.m. update: A woman found dead in a Granger home Tuesday night had been dead for several days, Williamson County Sheriff Robert Chody said. Her death is being treated as a suspicious death, Chody said. He had initially said the woman’s death was being investigated as a homicide.  “All I can say is there’s evidence that...
Lake Travis District selects name, mascot for new middle school
Lake Travis District selects name, mascot for new middle school

The Bee Cave Middle School Raiders was selected by Lake Travis School board members Tuesday evening as the district’s official name and mascot for its newest middle school campus. The district conducted a month-long community survey in the April to gather suggestions for an official name and mascot. District policy states that “facilities...
More Stories