Ethics panel: Zimmerman violated campaign finance rules


A day after Austin City Council Member Don Zimmerman was found guilty of violating the city’s campaign finance requirements, he criticized the ethics complaint as “bogus” and “politically motivated.”

Zimmerman failed to file two required end-of-year campaign finance documents. On Tuesday night, the city’s Ethics Review Commission voted unanimously to send a formal letter of reprimand because Zimmerman showed “disregard” for the city’s regulations.

But Zimmerman, the council’s most conservative member, pointed out that three other council members also hadn’t submitted some of these required reports. “What about the other council members who did not file?” he said.

This time next year, Zimmerman said, he expects the ethics dust-up to become fodder for direct mail pieces against him. “The reason people do these things is for political ammunition for the next campaign,” he said.

It’s rare for a council member to become the target of an ethics complaint outside the campaign season. And a council member hasn’t been issued a letter of reprimand from the city’s ethics commission in at least a decade.

The reprimand is largely symbolic. The city’s ethics commission has limited enforcement powers and cannot issue fines. It can recommend an ethics violation for criminal prosecution, but the commission declined to do so in Zimmerman’s case.

Ethics Review Commission Chairman Austin Kaplan said the panel hopes the letter of reprimand will send a message to other council members who didn’t file the reports to comply with the city’s campaign finance laws.

The missing campaign finance documents are called “bank reconciliation” and “campaign debt reconciliation” reports, and they are supposed to be filed along with a more comprehensive Jan. 15 report, which Zimmerman did file, disclosing final expenditures, donations and remaining funds.

Most galling to the Ethics Review Commission was that Zimmerman failed to add those reconciliation reports after being told they were missing. Austin resident Mark Walters, who filed the ethics complaint against Zimmerman in July, said he notified Zimmerman as far back as February that he hadn’t filed the correct reports.

After the ethics panel’s decision, Zimmerman conceded on Wednesday he would file the reports. According to his attorney and online records, Council Members Greg Casar, Ann Kitchen and Sabino “Pio” Renteria were also missing one or both of the reconciliation reports. Kaplan said after Tuesday’s meeting that there were no plans to launch ethics investigations of the other council members.

Zimmerman didn’t come to the hearing, to the disappointment of several Ethics Review Commission members who had requested he attend. Kaplan noted that a police chief and a mayor have previously come before the panel upon its request.

Kaplan said Zimmerman’s absence was demeaning to the commission and hamstrung its ability to get to the bottom of the ethics allegations.

Zimmerman said he had a “prior engagement” related to constituent issues and was in Seguin. “I didn’t get back in to Austin until later that evening,” he said. Zimmerman attorney Jerad Najvar said he also advised Zimmerman he didn’t need to attend because it was a “technical” issue and there wasn’t a factual dispute.

Najvar’s defense of Zimmerman focused on the “ambiguous” and “confusing” reporting requirements. He has also noted that the information on the end-of-year reports Zimmerman failed to file is available on the quarterly campaign finance report that Zimmerman did file.

Tuesday’s decision was a victory for Walters, a freelance law clerk who has filed several complaints and lawsuits against various entities since being released from state prison. The Ethics Review Commission declined last month to pursue Walters’ first complaint against Zimmerman, in which he accused the council member of violating city rules with a Facebook post criticizing the U.S Supreme Court’s ruling in June legalizing same-sex marriage.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

‘Whole lotta women’ changing the face of the Texas Democratic Party
‘Whole lotta women’ changing the face of the Texas Democratic Party

Kim Olson strode to the stage of the Democratic State Convention on Friday to Kelly Clarkson’s “Whole Lotta Woman.” “Let me just repeat those lyrics, a bad-ass woman with class and self-confidence,” Olson said. “I run for office because I’m confident I’m going to win.” “Whole lotta women&rdquo...
UPDATE: Texas 130 near U.S. 79 reopened after firefighters battle grass fire
UPDATE: Texas 130 near U.S. 79 reopened after firefighters battle grass fire

5:00 p.m. update: Williamson County officials say all lanes of Texas 130 near U.S. 79 have reopened after being closed previously for a grass fire. Authorities say there is still smoke over the road and have asked drivers to remain careful and to drive 20 mph under the speed limit as firefighters work in the area. Earlier: A fast-moving...
In Rio Grande Valley, a life-altering limbo as asylum process shifts
In Rio Grande Valley, a life-altering limbo as asylum process shifts

In shelters in Mexico, in detention facilities in the United States and in consultations with attorneys, they wait in uncertainty. Lorena, 31, left Honduras with her husband and four children in mid-April, when gangs started killing children attending local schools and skimming the money she earned as a laundress. “Every day you hear that they...
Vinnie Paul was co-founder, drummer of Texas metal band Pantera
Vinnie Paul was co-founder, drummer of Texas metal band Pantera

Vinnie Paul, co-founder and drummer of the Arlington-based metal band Pantera, has died at 54. Pantera’s official Facebook page posted a statement early Saturday announcing his death. The label of Hellyeah, his most recent group, confirmed the death but neither statement mentioned Paul’s cause of death. His real name was Vincent Paul Abbott...
BAD BREAD: H-E-B pulls some bread after finding ‘unfavorable aroma’
BAD BREAD: H-E-B pulls some bread after finding ‘unfavorable aroma’

H-E-B is voluntarily pulling some of its bread products off its shelves after discovering an unfavorable aroma, the company said in a statement. The store has pulled all H-E-B and Hill Country Fare bread products, including hamburger and hot dog buns, that have a best buy date between June 26 and July 2. The company said it was concerned about the...
More Stories