City attorney says CodeNext petition is invalid


A legal memo from Austin’s city attorney indicates that legal staff believe an ongoing effort by some residents to upend CodeNext through a petition is not valid.

A Feb. 28 memo from Austin City Attorney Anne Morgan that was forwarded to the City Council states that the city had hired an outside attorney to examine the legality of the petition, which calls for a voter referendum on whether the public should get to vote on all large-scale changes to zoning law.

The organizations behind the petition drive hope to place that question before voters in November. If the measure passes, a specific referendum on CodeNext would be scheduled next year.

The memo, which was first reported by the Austin Monitor, included recommendations from Austin attorney Robert Heath.

“In short, his determination is that council is neither required nor authorized to call an election on the petition because Texas courts have held that zoning is not a permissible subject within the scope of the initiative and referendum process,” Morgan said in the memo.

Heath’s memo also states that the petition is flawed because it outlines an ordinance that would override conflicting portions of the Austin City Charter. Ordinances cannot trump the charter, Heath said.

BACKSTORY: How a petition drive aims to put CodeNext’s fate in voters’ hands

One of the PACs behind the petition, IndyAustin, recently announced that it was nearing its goal of gathering 28,000 signatures. The group’s leader, Linda Curtis, said on Monday that they already have more than 24,000 signed petitions. About 20,000 signatures are needed to trigger an election.

The PAC responded Thursday to the existence of the city attorney’s memo.

“This is an extraordinary … dumb move by City Legal, a department that has long served as a rat’s nest of impervious cover (pun intended) for the real estate lobby,” the group said in an email. “Their missive about stopping this petition before placement on the ballot signals that they know CodeNext is too unpopular with Austinites!”

CodeNext is the city’s attempt to implement the recommendations of the 2012 Imagine Austin comprehensive plan by revising what type of development can go where. The effort aims to address many of Austin’s problems, including a lack of low-income housing as well as gentrification and traffic congestion.

Opponents of CodeNext believe that it will destroy neighborhood character by encouraging redevelopment and demolitions of homes. Proponents believe that CodeNext will make housing cheaper by making it easier to build in the city.

If the petition makes its way to City Council members, Heath recommended they reject it as invalid, though he noted the petitioners may respond by taking legal action.

Or, if the council allows the election and voters approve the measure, the council could challenge the validity of the election. However, Heath noted that that option was fraught with legal “pitfalls.”

RELATED: Anti-CodeNext PACs spend thousands to force vote



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Deputies searching for shooter after man shot in eastern Travis County, officials say
Deputies searching for shooter after man shot in eastern Travis County, officials say

Deputies are searching for the shooter after a man was shot in eastern Travis County on Friday night, sheriff’s officials said. Deputies responded at 8:43 p.m. to the 9300 block of FM 969 and found a man shot and injured at a mobile home park, said Travis County sheriff’s officials. The suspected shooter is a man who was last seen driving...
40 Texas lawmakers in favor of removing Confederate plaque; Abbott mum
40 Texas lawmakers in favor of removing Confederate plaque; Abbott mum

More than 40 state lawmakers support removing a Confederate memorial inside the Capitol that offers a debunked history lesson on the Civil War, even as most state leaders have remained silent on the issue. State Rep. Eric Johnson, D-Dallas, a candidate for House speaker, has been the leading voice calling for the plaque’s removal. He met privately...
Founder of Austin-based Johnny Carino’s Italian restaurants dies at 66
Founder of Austin-based Johnny Carino’s Italian restaurants dies at 66

Restaurant mogul Creed Lamar Ford III, known for operating Austin-based Johnny Carino’s Italian, died Friday. He was 66. Ford suffered cardiac arrest on Tuesday while taking a morning walk with his wife, Lynn. He was taken to Dell Seton Medical Center in Austin, before being moved to the Intensive Care Unit at Seton Main Hospital. “After...
Criner guilty: Slain UT student’s father says she did not die in vain
Criner guilty: Slain UT student’s father says she did not die in vain

A Travis County jury found Meechaiel Criner guilty of capital murder Friday for the violent death of University of Texas student Haruka Weiser, bringing closure to the shocking homicide that rocked Austin and the state’s flagship university in April 2016. Criner did not react when the verdict was read or when Weiser’s father, Dr. Thomas...
40 Texas lawmakers in favor of removing Confederate plaque; Abbott mum
40 Texas lawmakers in favor of removing Confederate plaque; Abbott mum

More than 40 state lawmakers support removing a Confederate memorial inside the Capitol that offers a debunked history lesson on the Civil War, even as most state leaders have remained silent on the issue. State Rep. Eric Johnson, D-Dallas, a candidate for House speaker, has been the leading voice calling for the plaque’s removal. He met privately...
More Stories