Capital Metro says releasing candidates’ names could start ‘bidding war’


The agency’s lawyer contends that a Texas Supreme Court ruling on private companies extends to governments.

Revealing candidate names, the agency says, could put it at a competitive disadvantage for leader searches.

The Statesman on Nov. 29 had requested names of semifinalists for Cap Metro’s soon-to-be-vacant CEO job.

Capital Metro, in a letter opposing the disclosure of semifinalists for its open president and CEO position, has become the second Central Texas government to argue that a court ruling protecting businesses in a competitive environment should apply to government entities as well.

In a four-page letter sent Wednesday to the Texas attorney general, a lawyer for the transit agency cites the 2015 Texas Supreme Court decision in Boeing v. Paxton, which allowed the aircraft manufacturer to prevent disclosure of information from a government lease, which otherwise would be public, because it could offer a market advantage to other businesses.

In this case, attorney C. Robert Heath wrote on behalf of Capital Metro, “releasing the candidates’ names will put Capital Metro in a disadvantageous competitive position and can put Capital Metro in a bidding war.”

Capital Metro’s letter comes in response to a public records request by the American-Statesman seeking the names of candidates who interviewed this month for the transit agency’s top job.

The newspaper made a similar request this fall for names of contenders for Austin city manager, and lawyers for the city also argued the Boeing decision should apply to its executive search. The Statesman has sued the city for records related to the city manager search, which culminated Tuesday in the City Council’s selection of Minneapolis City Coordinator Spencer Cronk for the job.

AUSTIN VS. WATAUGA? City claims competition to keep candidates secret

While Capital Metro has not named the larger pool of semifinalists, the board revealed the names of four finalists Monday to replace president and CEO Linda Watson, who is retiring Dec. 31. Those finalists are:

• Randy Clarke, a vice president with the American Public Transportation Association.

• Erika Mazza, deputy general manager with the North Arizona Intergovernmental Public Transportation Authority in Flagstaff.

• Darrell Mobley, director of public works and transportation for Prince George’s County, in Washington, D.C.’s Maryland suburbs

• Raymond Suarez, chief operating officer of the Denton County Transportation Authority in North Texas.

Capital Metro’s letter Wednesday argues that revealing candidates’ names could lead to other transit agencies poaching its contenders, while the candidates’ current employers could launch a “bidding war” to keep them.

Heath also noted that search consultant Krauthamer & Associates said nine potential candidates declined to apply for the Capital Metro job because of fears of their names becoming public, potentially damaging their standing at their current jobs.

RELATED: How Boeing ruling has put some government spending in the dark

In its Nov. 29 public information request, the Statesman pointed to the Texas attorney general’s 2010 opinion, issued during a previous Capital Metro leadership search, that said the candidates’ names should be released to the Statesman.

The next leader of Capital Metro will oversee a public agency with a $323.3 million budget, about 80 bus routes, one rail line and a door-to-door paratransit service that altogether provide more than 30 million rides a year.

Heath argued the Boeing ruling trumps the 2010 attorney general’s opinion.

“The concern that Capital Metro is competing with other transit authorities who may be interested in hiring the same person is not an idle one,” Heath wrote in the letter. Transit agencies in New York; Philadelphia; Boston; Tampa, Fla.; Columbus, Ohio; Atlanta, Denver and Toronto are all looking for CEOs and other high-ranking executives, he said.

The attorney general has 45 days to make a ruling, starting from when Capital Metro referred the Statesman’s request to his office on Dec. 13.

RELATED: Watson retiring after seven years leading Cap Metro

Heath argued that the fact that the search for a new president and CEO is nearly over — the board likely will choose a winner Jan. 9 — does not dilute Capital Metro’s argument. This new CEO, he said, will one day move on and a new search will occur with similar potential concerns.

“Also, (Capital Metro) conducts searches for other top administrative positions,” Heath wrote, “so the issue comes up frequently.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Traffic report for Monday, Sept. 24, 2018

Interstate 35 (Hays County): Slow moving striping work crews in both directions between RM 150 and Robert S. Light Boulevard from 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through Thursday nights Interstate 35 (Travis County): Alternating closures on the frontage roads in both directions between Slaughter Lane and Williamson Creek from 8 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through...
Community news: Austin Energy hosts small business open house Tuesday

TRAVIS COUNTY SOUTH AUSTIN Small business open house Tuesday Austin Energy will host an open house for small business owners from 1:30 to 4 p.m. Tuesday at Austin Energy’s Town Lake Center, 721 Barton Springs Road. The free open house will allow business owners to exchange information, meet with staff and learn how to effectively partner with...
Cruz gets O’Rourke where he wants him — on a debate stage
Cruz gets O’Rourke where he wants him — on a debate stage

For the first time in his re-election campaign, U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, had Democratic challenger U.S. Rep. Beto O’Rourke, right where he wanted him Friday night — on a debate stage confined behind a lectern and constricted by 90-second answers, 60-second responses and 30-second rebuttals. It forced O’Rourke to confront Cruz...
Heavy rains lead to flooding, rescues in Williamson, Travis counties
Heavy rains lead to flooding, rescues in Williamson, Travis counties

Authorities rescued dozens of people in Williamson and Travis counties early Saturday after thunderstorms hammered Central Texas, dropping nearly 10 inches of rain in some spots and causing flash floods, road closures and power outages. Approximately 90 people were forced to evacuate the Rio de Colores wedding venue in Liberty Hill as waters rose to...
TEXAS DIGEST: Funeral held for 4th victim of serial killings

LAREDO Funeral held for serial killings victim About 150 people gathered at a Texas church for the funeral of one of the four women who authorities say were killed by a Border Patrol agent they’ve described as a serial killer. Saturday’s funeral for 35-year-old Guiselda Alicia Cantu at a Catholic church in Laredo is the last of the memorial...
More Stories