$1 billion rail, roads proposal rejected


Rail failed in Austin on Tuesday, again, and — given the emphatic “no” vote and the difficulty of bringing such a complex venture to the ballot — even the measure’s head cheerleader doesn’t see another serious proposal arising anytime soon.

“It’s dead until somebody revives it,” retiring Austin Mayor Lee Leffingwell said as disappointed rail supporters mingled quietly around him at a somber Threadgill’s election party. “And that will be a long period of time.”

The city’s $1 billion rail-and-roads proposal, the culmination of a generation-long effort to enlist Austin in the national light rail movement, remained well behind Tuesday with more than 80 percent of the vote counted.

The measure, if approved, would have allowed the city to borrow $600 million to provide most of Austin’s share of a proposed $1.4 billion, 9.5-mile light rail starter line through the city’s core. The proposition also would have had the city first “provide funding” — almost certainly by acquiring still more debt — for $400 million in improvements to Interstate 35 and a handful of other city roads.

City and Capital Metro officials, who had planned the project in tandem, hoped that the companion proposal for roads would draw in enough rail skeptics to put the measure over the top. But that approach drew criticism. Travis County Commissioner Gerald Daugherty, long known for his support of building highways, called it “blackmail.”

Jim Skaggs, a retired high-tech executive and longtime rail foe who formed a political action committee that raised more than $270,000 to fight the proposal, said the electric rail line would’ve had no noticeable effect on traffic.

“For the 99.7 percent of the people who take daily trips on our streets, it is obvious we need to improve our road structure, and do it with urgency,” Skaggs said, suggesting that the incoming 10-1 Austin City Council should expand local highways and streets.

“Austin needs to get serious about fixing its own roads,” he said.

The proposed light rail line would have run from North Austin near Highland Mall and the Austin Community College campus taking root there, through downtown, and east on East Riverside Drive to Grove Boulevard. Transit officials estimated that the line could be ready to open by 2022 and would have daily ridership of about 18,000 by 2030.

Borrowing the money for both the rail line and road projects would have increased taxes on a $200,000 home by $217 a year by 2020, city budget officers estimated. That projected hit to taxpayers, and a general sense that Austin is becoming too expensive a place, led to the defeat, Leffingwell said.

Getting a rail proposal teed up this time took seven years, promotion by two Austin mayors, endless meetings and several million dollars for consultants. Those who think a different rail proposal can quickly return to the ballot are “Pollyannas,” Leffingwell said.

Not so, said Lyndon Henry, a former Capital Metro board member who was among a coterie of rail supporters who nonetheless opposed the city ballot measure because they favored an alternative route on the city’s most popular transit corridor, Guadalupe Street and North Lamar Boulevard.

“This city leans toward good transit solutions,” Henry said. “But people looked at this and said, ‘This is not a good plan.’ I think they would go for a plan that makes sense and is in the right corridor. And that’s what we’re going to work for.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Onyeri says he didn’t mean to shoot Judge Kocurek, rails at banks
Onyeri says he didn’t mean to shoot Judge Kocurek, rails at banks

Chimene Onyeri took the witness stand Monday and continued to deny that he purposefully shot state District Judge Julie Kocurek while also railing at banking institutions and attempting to discredit several dozen witnesses who have testified against him. Onyeri spent much of the day sparring with federal prosecutors, refusing to identify his associates...
Paxton: Abbott can use disaster powers to hasten special election
Paxton: Abbott can use disaster powers to hasten special election

To the extent election law prevents or delays the recovery of Texas’ coastal areas in the long aftermath of Hurricane Harvey, Gov. Greg Abbott can suspend that law, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton announced Monday. Tying the ravages of Hurricane Harvey with the abrupt resignation of U.S. Rep. Blake Farenthold, R-Corpus Christi, Abbott had...
JUST IN: George H.W. Bush admitted to Houston hospital Sunday
JUST IN: George H.W. Bush admitted to Houston hospital Sunday

Former President George H.W. Bush was admitted Sunday morning to a Houston hospital, according to statement from his office.  Bush contracted an infection that spread to his blood, the statement said.  “He is responding to treatments and appears to be recovering,” the statement said. Bush was admitted to the hospital less than...
In beef over law, Ken Paxton backs brisket slingers over Sid Miller
In beef over law, Ken Paxton backs brisket slingers over Sid Miller

In the ongoing beef between restaurants and Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller over the regulation of food-weighing scales, state Attorney General Ken Paxton has sided with the purveyors of brisket — not to mention frozen yogurt, salad plates and other food sold by the ounce. Paxton said Miller’s agency, which has been charged with verifying...
Jury weighs murder charge in Austin stabbing death of Daniel Spencer
Jury weighs murder charge in Austin stabbing death of Daniel Spencer

A jury Travis County is now deliberating in the murder trial of 67-year-old James Robert Miller Jr., who is accused of fatally stabbing 32-year-old Daniel Spencer in September of 2015. Miller’s attorney says it was self defense. Spencer was killed at his home early Monday morning on September 21, after inviting Miller to his house to play songs...
More Stories