Austin: Meter readers made up reads, causing fall water bill spikes


Utility had long insisted that it was impossible for meter readers to have caused the problem.

City “will be seeking remedy” from its former meter-reading contractor.

Austin officials now have an answer to the mystery of what caused the water bills of thousands of residents to spike in September — and it’s exactly what residents had suspected and the Austin Water Utility had denied was possible.

Two former water meter readers apparently fabricated readings along their routes in late summer, said Kerry Overton, deputy general manager of Austin Energy, which handles billing for both the water and electric utilities.

“What they put in as meter reads could not have happened during the time frame,” Overton said of Corix’s analysis of its employees.

The city contracted out the meter reading work to Corix, and city officials said they expect to seek legal action against the firm. Corix representatives, who have not responded to requests for comment for previous stories, did not immediately return calls for comment late Tuesday afternoon.

BACKGROUND: Austin utility to give refunds for fall water bill spikes

The conclusion directly contradicts Austin Energy’s repeated insistence that its system would have made it impossible for meter readers to falsify meter readings. Officials told the American-Statesman and other media outlets that readers do not have access to previous usage numbers for residences on the meter and, thus, have no way to make up new readings.

It shouldn’t be possible for meter readers to estimate reads under the process, said Elaine Veselka, Austin Energy vice president of customer accounts. “How they did it — if they wrote July reads down and then guesstimated an August read or if they gained access to the system — we don’t know,” she said.

The faulty readings underestimated August water use in certain neighborhoods, which caused overbilling in September when accurate readings were made. Because Austin has a tiered billing system, some of the affected residents were billed at higher rates than they would have been if their meters had been read accurately in August.

August was the final month Corix worked for Austin before a new company, Akron, Ohio-based Bermex, took over the contract in September. Corix was short-staffed on meter readers during that time, according to information presented at a Utility Commission meeting in January.

MORE: New Austin Water billing safeguards coming amid unexplained spikes

The Statesman first reported on the bill spikes in October in one Circle C neighborhood. The Statesman then analyzed usage of more than 100 residents who sent their bills to the paper, showing the unusual dips and spikes. Austin Energy ultimately provided refunds to more than 7,000 residents who were overcharged.

Most of those customers received a “smoothing” of their bills that averaged them across the affected months, to reduce the impact of higher cost tiers. Credits ranged from 3 cents to $84.

In January, the utility began requiring readers to take photos of each individual meter, at an additional cost of about $400,000 to $500,000 a year. Austin Water also sent its workers to read some meters and double-check the work of the contracted readers.

Overton said a legal team representing Austin Energy has been notified and “will be seeking remedy under the contract” with Corix, a private corporation with headquarters in in Vancouver, B.C., and Northbrook, Ill. It’s unclear at this point what that might entail.

He added that the two meter readers involved no longer work for Corix and do not work for Bermex either.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Valdez squeezes past White, faces big Abbott challenge next
Valdez squeezes past White, faces big Abbott challenge next

Lupe Valdez was beaming Tuesday night as she accepted the cheers of supporters at a downtown Dallas restaurant in her hometown for making history as the first Latina and the first lesbian to become the Democratic nominee for governor in Texas. “I am constantly hearing this is going to be such an uphill battle,” said Valdez, elected four...
Familiar name, black voters helped Cole win in House District 46
Familiar name, black voters helped Cole win in House District 46

With name recognition and a push to mobilize African-American and white women working to her advantage, Sheryl Cole narrowly defeated immigration attorney Jose “Chito” Vela III in the Texas House District 46 Democratic runoff Tuesday. Cole, a former Austin City Council member, earned 4,967 votes, or 50.9 percent, on Tuesday, 173...
Early Bird: Scooter company, license in hand, relaunches in Austin
Early Bird: Scooter company, license in hand, relaunches in Austin

Bird, once again, is the early bird. The Venice, Calif.-based scooter-rental company, which released its electric vehicles onto Austin streets in early April without city permission, scattered them about Central Austin on Wednesday after being granted a city license to operate. The company, and its chief competitor, Lime, had taken their stand-up electric...
Feds: Lockhart man ‘verbally harassed’ Sutherland Springs church members, said shooting was a hoax
Feds: Lockhart man ‘verbally harassed’ Sutherland Springs church members, said shooting was a hoax

A Lockhart man and his girlfriend went to First Baptist Church in Sutherland Springs in March and “verbally harassed” church members, saying that the Nov. 5, 2017, shooting that killed 26 people at the church was a hoax, the U.S. Department of Justice said Wednesday. Robert “Side Thorn” Ussery, 54, was charged Wednesday with...
Are there black bears in Central Texas?
Are there black bears in Central Texas?

If you’ve traveled to East Texas, you’re likely aware of the danger of black bears. But black bears in Austin are unheard of, right? Well, not exactly. According to Texas Hill Country, black bears used to be plentiful all across Texas, but over the years, populations have decreased. However, recent sightings may indicate they’re making...
More Stories