AUSTIN ANSWERED: Why isn’t panhandling illegal? It’s about free speech


Highlights

A panhandler and a group of students advertising a car wash to raise money are both legally panhandling.

Aggressive panhandlers who follow pedestrians or make physical contact with another person can involve police.

In the latest installment of our “Austin Answered” series, a reader asks the American-Statesman, “Why isn’t there a law against panhandling?”

The answer could be understood better when you frame the question a different way: What’s the difference between a person standing on the side of the street asking for money and a group of high school students advertising a car wash to raise funds for their class?

Nothing, legal experts say. Both groups are considered to be panhandling but neither one is breaking the law, according to an Austin city ordinance.

“It’s legal because the First Amendment protects freedom of speech,” University of Texas law professor Lucas Powe said.

RELATED: Panhandler threatened to kill UT student, police say

People can stand on the side of the street and ask for money, with or without a sign, said Powe, who added that a typical sign he’s seen said, “Jesus Loves You.”

The city of Austin is trying to reduce the number of panhandlers through a recently passed City Council resolution that would provide temporary jobs to homeless people and panhandlers. The plans for the program will be reviewed at the beginning of next year.

Technically, panhandling can include a variety of solicitations, such as people holding up signs saying they have no job or home or people asking others to donate money to a specific cause.

However, limiting a person’s ability to panhandle would limit a person’s freedom of speech, UT law professor Lawrence Sager said.

“The very term ‘panhandling’ is asking people for something immediately,” Sager said. “To say that the one thing you can’t do on the street is ask for money now is to really single out a really particular form of speech on the street.”

Sager said various forms of speech can be done in the streets, such as waving to people or talking to each other in the streets — and panhandling is included.

“It would be quite difficult in some ways not to single out panhandling by content,” Sager said.

RELATED: Facebook photo of panhandler’s money sparks controversy

According to the city ordinance, panhandling is allowed unless it becomes an aggressive action, such as following pedestrians, asking for money from people at or near a bank or ATM, or making physical contact with another person. Other forms of aggressive panhandling include using obscene language or gestures toward a person while asking for money or continuing to ask someone for money after they have refused.

This type of panhandling can get law enforcement involved.

“Obviously if it’s reported to us, then we can issue (panhandlers) a citation, or depending on the circumstances, we might take them to jail just because they might have some warrants,” said Austin police Sgt. Matthew Wright.

GET UP TO SPEED: Check out other Austin Answered stories arising from readers’ questions

• Why don’t gas stations get credit card chip readers?

• Why doesn’t Austin have more east-west highways?

• Who is Maufrais, and why is the name written on Austin sidewalks?

• What are the oldest buildings in downtown Austin?

• Where do the Congress Avenue Bridge bats go at night?

• Why did the bathroom bill become such a big thing this year?

• Are algae blooms bad for your health?

• Why can’t you swim in Lady Bird Lake?

• Quick answers to 11 of your questions and 8 more



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Traffic report for May 21, 2018

Interstate 35 (Hays County): Reduced to one southbound lane between FM 2001 and RM 150 from 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through Thursday nights. Interstate 35 (Travis County): The left lane on the southbound access road will be closed between Blackson Avenue and St. Johns Avenue until 9 p.m. July 5. The southbound two right lanes will be closed between...
Party boat company returns to Lake Austin dock after legal cease-fire
Party boat company returns to Lake Austin dock after legal cease-fire

At least one Lake Austin party boat company will be able to pick up passengers off of Lake Austin Boulevard this summer, after a reprieve in the legal tussle over the use of a public dock there. Austin Party Cruises sued the city of Austin and Parks and Recreation Department Director Kimberly McNeeley in January after the parks department declined...
PolitiFact: In governor’s race, abortion divides Democrats
PolitiFact: In governor’s race, abortion divides Democrats

Houston investor Andrew White says he’ll protect abortion rights if elected governor despite personally believing abortion to be wrong. During the debate for the Democratic nomination for Texas governor, White declared that a national abortion rights leader, Cecile Richards, said there’s room for people like him in “her movement.&rdquo...
Southern Methodist University removes cultural survey from public view
Southern Methodist University removes cultural survey from public view

Southern Methodist University distributed a survey last fall that asked students to rate how much they wanted answers to such questions as “Why are black people so loud?” and “Do black people hate America?” The survey, distributed by SMU’s Cultural Intelligence Initiative and posted online, was taken down Thursday after...
Cedar Park police, detective arrested wrong Nathan Cook, lawsuit says
Cedar Park police, detective arrested wrong Nathan Cook, lawsuit says

An Austin man is suing Cedar Park and one of its police detectives over a case of mistaken identity, according to a federal lawsuit filed this week. Nathan A. Cook was arrested on a charge of felony theft of services, and escorted out of Austin-Bergstrom International Airport in August, according to the lawsuit. It names the city of Cedar Park and...
More Stories