VA clerks manipulated wait data, long-awaited federal report says


A long-awaited internal investigation has found that Department of Veterans Affairs scheduling clerks throughout Central Texas masked the true nature of wait times at hospitals and clinics in the region by inputting false appointment data.

More than 20 VA employees, from San Antonio to Kerrville to Austin, told investigators they engaged in the practice, according to a report released this week. Several said supervisors instructed them to manipulate the data and that they feared being fired if they did not participate.

According to the investigation, one former scheduling clerk at the Austin Outpatient Clinic said she “was taught to manipulate the desired date by one of the supervisors and another employee. After moving to another facility, she was again trained to make the patient wait times equal zero.”

Another scheduler in Kerrville said “a former VA supervisor threatened to fire her if she did not make the wait times equal zero.” The practice involved logging patients’ desired appointment dates to sync with appointment openings.

Despite the findings, the VA Office of Inspector General did not find executives ordered the data manipulation. Instead, the report noted that “numerous employees opined that there was no malicious intent by any employee to defraud or mislead anyone regarding wait times. Many individuals indicated problems with scheduling ranged (sic) from improper training, lack of supervision, to non-centralized scheduling.”

In a letter sent to congressional offices and released to the media late Wednesday, local VA officials hailed the report as vindication, writing that “it is important to note that OIG has not substantiated any case in which a VA senior executive or other senior leader intentionally manipulated scheduling data.”

The investigation was sparked by allegations of data manipulation in Central and South Texas made by a San Antonio scheduling clerk in the spring of 2014, part of a wave of allegations that convulsed the VA over accusations of lack of transparency and resulted in the resignation of former VA secretary Eric Shinseki.

Earlier this month, the OIG began releasing the results of investigations into scheduling practices across the nation. The federal Office of Special Counsel has complained that at least two investigations were “incomplete” and “failed to respond” to issues raised by whistleblowers.

Local VA leaders said that despite the lack of “intentional wrongdoing,” the OIG report shows “the need for standardized training on scheduling.” All employees involved in scheduling have been retrained, they said.

Several Central Texas supervisors told investigators the data manipulation was the result of “bad habits” of schedulers. One San Antonio administrators said “the concept of scheduling errors seemed to confuse schedulers.” The administrator “stated that there was pressure to get patients seen in a timely manner but there was no pressure to manipulate the data,” the report said.

Investigators also determined that no VA employee received a bonus or award related “specifically” to wait time measures.

Yet the report found data manipulation was widespread in San Antonio, Kerrville and the Austin clinic, where “almost all schedulers and clinics had zero wait times.”

Several schedulers said they feared ending up on what one scheduler called a “hit list” if they scheduled appointments with wait times longer than 14 days.

“In order to make sure her name was not on the list, she stated she would make the wait time equal zero,” the report said of a San Antonio scheduler.

In response to the growing scandal in 2014, Congress approved $16.3 billion to pay for new staff and facilities and pay for private sector care for veterans facing long waits. In Central Texas, the money helped fund 118 new positions — a mix of medical providers and support staff.

Last year, VA numbers showed that the rate of delayed appointments was falling in Austin, but remained higher than the national average.

Corry Schiermeyer, a spokeswoman for U.S. Rep. John Carter, R-Round Rock, said the congressman “continues to pressure the VA leadership… and will continue to do so until real reform is made.” Last year, Carter called on the FBI to investigate the VA hospital in Temple over abuse and misconduct, and is seeking an update, Schiermeyer said.

The VA OIG also dismissed several other allegations in reports released Wednesday, including a claim that the chief of imaging services for the Central Texas VA manipulated appointment times for radiological studies and that a home-based primary care program in San Antonio prohibited the use of an electronic wait list, which theoretically could reveal long wait times.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Accused dealer took ferry, brought children on drug buy, police say
Accused dealer took ferry, brought children on drug buy, police say

A New York man accused for his part in a heroin and fentanyl distribution ring commuted from the Bronx to Staten Island to sell the illicit drugs -- and took his children on a drug buy, police said. >> Read more trending news  Steven Ildefonso was one of six suspects arrested and indicted Thursday, the New York Daily News reported. ...
Tennessee man admits to whipping child, 6, to death with extension cord
Tennessee man admits to whipping child, 6, to death with extension cord

A Tennessee man was arrested for whipping his 6-year-old child to death with an extension cord, police said. >> Read more trending news  Memphis police said Donald Rich, the child’s stepfather, called 911 after the child “began to throw up and became unresponsive.” The incident happened Wednesday.  The...
Police arrest suspect in stabbing death of DC jogger
Police arrest suspect in stabbing death of DC jogger

Police in Washington, D.C., arrested a 23-year-old man and charged him in the fatal stabbing of a woman jogging through the city, the Washington Post reported. >> Read more trending news  Anthony Marquell Crawford was arrested and charged with first-degree murder in the death of Wendy Martinez, 35, who was attacked shortly before 8...
Jet Airways flight in India forced to return due to low cabin pressure
Jet Airways flight in India forced to return due to low cabin pressure

A Jet Airways flight from Mumbai to Jaipur in India was forced to turn back Thursday when 30 passengers complained of nose and ear bleeds because of low pressure in the cabin, CNN reported Thursday. >> Read more trending news  "The B737 aircraft, with 166 guests and 5 crew landed normally in Mumbai," Jet Airways ...
Sprint Car driver Greg Hodnett killed in crash during race
Sprint Car driver Greg Hodnett killed in crash during race

Sprint Car driver Greg Hodnett was killed in a crash Thursday night during an event at BAPS Motorspeedway in York Haven, Pennsylvania, the World of Outlaws said in a news release. He was 49. >> Read more trending news  Hodnett, from Spring Grove, Pennsylvania, was a five-time champion at Williams Grove Speedway in Pennsylvania and was...
More Stories