Contentious 331st District race pits longtime judge against attorney


Highlights

Eldridge said she’ll probably hire a registered sex offender to be her judicial aide.

Crain disposed of the fewest criminal cases in 2017 among the eight criminal court district judges.

The only contested judicial race in Travis County’s criminal district courts has gotten contentious, with challenger Chantal Eldridge saying taxpayers have been underserved by the incumbent while Eldridge faces questions of her own about the registered sex offender she employs in her law firm and intends to bring on as a judicial aide if she wins.

Eldridge, a 53-year-old career defense lawyer who narrowly lost a judicial race in 2016, is running against state District Judge David Crain, who has presided over the felony 331st District Court since 2010 and has been a judge in Travis County for 32 years. He said his experience sets him apart in this race, suggesting “you wouldn’t want a novice to sit and try to conduct a jury trial for a murder case, child sexual assault, bank robbery or something like that.”

On the campaign trail, Eldridge has characterized Crain as inefficient, pointing to statistics from Dec. 8 that show defendants awaiting resolution of their cases in Crain’s court had averaged 129 days in jail — the most of the county’s eight felony courts.

Those numbers are misleading, Crain said, noting that the total days spent in jail fluctuate as cases are resolved and that he’s “always in the middle” among his peers for the number of pending cases in his court and jury trials. The average time a defendant sits in jail is not among the standards included in an analysis the county did last year to assess judicial efficiency. Neither are jury trials; Crain had eight in 2017, tied for fifth among the eight judges in felony courts.

The county does keep an eye on the number of cases a judge disposes. Crain ranked last in 2017.

“I don’t think he’s doing enough for Travis County,” Eldridge said.

Sex offender on staff

Eldridge faces questions related to the criminal history of a staff member.

Shortly after losing to now-state District Judge Brad Urrutia in 2016, Eldridge hired John Gerard Zamarripa, who had volunteered on her campaign, to be her legal assistant. Zamarripa, 53, pleaded guilty in 1990 to sexual assault of a child after an incident with a family member at a South Austin home. According to a March 1988 arrest affidavit, a 14-year-old girl said she was watching TV with Zamarripa when he began began to kiss her and had sex with her.

Zamarripa was 24 at the time. Under the terms of his plea deal, the conviction was dismissed from his record in 2000 after he successfully completed 10 years of probation. He was ordered to register as a sex offender for the rest of his life.

Eldridge said Zamarripa will probably be her court coordinator if she’s elected, “unless there is some legal reason he shouldn’t, or new allegations come up.” He has been involved in the campaign, coordinating the placement of yard signs and handling media requests.

Refusing employment to a past felon would run counter to her faith in criminal justice rehabilitation, Eldridge said. She called Zamarripa a conscientious worker.

“I just don’t think a criminal history — after somebody has successfully completed their punishment — should bar someone from getting a job, or at least being considered,” she said.

Eldridge’s campaign website addresses Zamarripa’s past — “True to her belief in criminal justice reform, Chantal knows that if she were not willing to offer an ex-felon a second chance, an opportunity to show he was rehabilitated, then she would be a hypocrite.”

If Eldridge wins, Zamarripa’s role in her office could be complicated, as a criminal history might impede his access to certain court documents, according to court administrative director Debra Hale. However, nothing stands in the way of Eldridge hiring him, Hale said.

Zamarripa worked on Mike Martinez’s 2014 mayoral campaign, first as a volunteer and then as a paid staff member. Zamarripa disclosed his criminal history to the campaign before taking the paid position, Martinez said.

“We saw no reason to cut ties with him for something that had happened several decades ago that he disclosed to us,” Martinez said. “He continued to serve on the campaign until the campaign ended.”

A sheriff’s report shows Zamarripa has a pending Class C misdemeanor assault by physical contact charge stemming from multiple incidents last fall in Travis County.

Two female clients at the Travis County Correctional Complex at Del Valle made complaints against Zamarripa, with one saying he grabbed her breast while placing business cards into her pocket, the report says. The woman told deputies that Zamarripa also asked inappropriate questions about her sex life and discussed with her a tattoo on her breast that he saw while looking her up on Facebook.

The second woman said Zamarripa asked inappropriate questions about her sexual history and grabbed her hands, the report says. Eldridge said Zamarripa was checking for markings that would indicate whether she had been cutting herself — a past concern with the woman. That assessment was needed to get the woman approved for outpatient services, Eldridge said.

Zamarripa’s attorney, Charlie Baird, called the allegations frivolous.

“We intend to proceed with the case and have a jury trial if necessary, and we expect him to be fully vindicated,” Baird said.

Zamarripa pleaded not guilty and is scheduled for a pretrial hearing March 29 before a justice of the peace. The maximum punishment for a Class C misdemeanor is a $500 fine.

Zamarripa did not return a message for comment.

It came out in her previous campaign that Eldridge has a criminal past of her own, a 1995 charge for obstruction of process in Putnam County, Tenn. A grand jury indicted her on the misdemeanor charge, which is described in the state statute as intentionally obstructing a law enforcement officer from effecting a stop, frisk, halt, arrest or search by using force against the officer. Eldridge denied that there was any physical contact between herself and the officer, who she said made the arrest in retaliation after Eldridge filed a complaint against him for excessive force against her elderly mother, who was injured while being arrested for a loose dog.

The charge against Eldridge was dismissed in January 1996 — 10 months after the incident. Later that year, Eldridge filed a petition to have the charge expunged from her record.

She moved to Austin with her mother in 2003 and began a criminal defense practice.

Bar association favors Crain

Since mid-December, Crain has secured $45,280 in campaign donations to Eldridge’s $4,451. Of endorsements, Crain has 12 and Eldridge three. The local bar weighed in on the race, with 72 percent of participants siding with Crain.

Eldridge was the only woman in 2016 to lose to a man in a Travis County race, when she got 47 percent of the vote against fellow defense lawyer Urrutia.

Championing fresh ideas, she said she’d like to expand the misdemeanor Phoenix Court — which provides alternatives to jail for defendants charged with prostitution — by bringing it to her felony court. She’d also like to discontinue any conditions that require a person charged with a crime to have permanent housing to qualify for a personal bond.

She also wants to take over a docket that caters to defendants with mental health needs — something Crain developed years ago as a County Court-at-Law judge. The docket is currently handled by Magistrate Judge Leon Grizzard.

While Eldridge has questioned Crain’s record, he’s taken shots of his own, saying Eldridge is not known to take cases to trial.

“She will tell you she’s done some, but no judge I know of has ever heard of them or seen them,” he said.

Crain, 65, said he wants another four-year term and will then probably retire.

Early voting in the Democratic primary gets underway Tuesday. Election day is March 6.

This story has been updated with details of John Zamarippa’s most recent criminal charge, based on documents obtained by the Statesman on Feb. 22.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Review of peer cities finds Austin’s legal structure has different look
Review of peer cities finds Austin’s legal structure has different look

Most of Austin’s peer cities have city attorneys who report directly to the City Council as opposed to the city manager, which is how Austin has framed its legal structure. The finding, through a staff review completed last week, has added context to lingering debate about whether Austin should adopt the same setup. Earlier this year, a Charter...
PolitiFact: Cruz didn’t say what viral image alleges
PolitiFact: Cruz didn’t say what viral image alleges

U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz has been openly opposed to same-sex marriage, but he didn’t blame gay people for mass shootings and public nudity during a 2014 speech. A 2015 viral image that falsely quotes Cruz is gaining traction again on social media as the Republican incumbent looks to keep his seat against Democratic nominee U.S. Rep. Beto O’Rourke...
Austin gentrification study touted as tool to fix affordability crisis
Austin gentrification study touted as tool to fix affordability crisis

When Delwin Goss moved to the Montopolis neighborhood in Southeast Austin in 1992, it wasn’t safe to walk down the street at night because it had so much crime, he said. Over time, the fabric of the neighborhood has started to change: People jog at night at dusk, and many of the drug houses have closed. But home prices are rapidly increasing...
Echoes of Anita Hill in charge against Brett Kavanaugh
Echoes of Anita Hill in charge against Brett Kavanaugh

In a prologue to their 1994 book, “Strange Justice: The Selling of Clarence Thomas,” journalists Jane Mayer and Jill Abramson wrote of how “unresolved the conflict” remained between Thomas, the conservative justice, and Anita Hill, the law professor who testified that he had sexually harassed her a decade earlier...
Did backers of city audit proposition skirt ‘dark money’ restrictions?
Did backers of city audit proposition skirt ‘dark money’ restrictions?

The political action committee behind a ballot proposition that calls for an independent efficiency audit of Austin City Hall might have broken local campaign finance laws by shielding the identities of its donors, according to city officials. In the sole campaign finance report it filed with the city, Citizens for an Accountable Austin showed only...
More Stories